Top
Best
New

Posted by 4diii 16 hours ago

How to Build a Minimal ZFS NAS Without Synology, QNAP, TrueNAS (2024)(neil.computer)
327 points | 222 commentspage 4
rexysmexy 15 hours ago|
To this day I still use a ZFS array for my critical backup storage. I've migrated over to using snap raid + mergerfs for my larger Linux iso storage array. Simple enough and I can pull a drive on it's own without any other stuff.
Beijinger 10 hours ago||
Has anybody used unraid for his Home Server? Is it worth it?

unraid.net

joshmn 7 hours ago|
I'm hardly a sysadmin and I think Unraid is great. My usecase is some Docker containers and media backups. The UI gets the job done well, whereas Synology tries to dumb things down and make things pretty.

Android is to Unraid as iPhone is to Synology.

sleepycatgirl 9 hours ago||
personally, after buying X380, using my old T430 as a mini NAS..(also immich) with a ZFS mirror. works wonderfully :3
aligutierrez 16 hours ago||
this is really cool. I've been dealing with an aging Synology nas and this is something I can pick up, evaluate performance and how safe it is to serve as home for my data.
giov4 13 hours ago||
I killed 2x 4tb Nvme drives on Pciexpress with ZFS raid1 under proxmox, got them replaced, tried again on both pci-express and usb adapter kept getting io problems there too with zfs, drive gets disconnected during scrub or high load, tried already kernel or power management options for pciexpress and usb without sucess, managed to reproduce with high load.

or proxmox ( especially community edition) is fucked or zfs is still unstable, surprisingly with different drives on different interfaces I obtained same results, didnt swap proxmox for clean os, that might being some changes since modules and options would be different i guess. ( drives firmware etc are fine and performing well when inspected with proprietary windows tools)

just search zfs nvme pcie or usb problema or disconnect and you see similar stability problem for different users in different cases (os, drives etc), but also unraid and others, maybe somewhere is rithe right combo of options/glitches but didnt find it yet

6581 11 hours ago|
> usb adapter kept getting io problems there too with zfs, drive gets disconnected during scrub or high load

That's usually caused by the adapter chipset overheating. Don't use USB adapters for important data.

crowd51 14 hours ago||
Very cool
hombre_fatal 7 hours ago||
[dead]
tamimio 16 hours ago|
Yeah no. When it comes to backups and data storage, I would rather use a proven reliable system that’s been used and tested by millions of other users, keep these hacky stuff for your hyperland set up.
bombcar 16 hours ago||
I've lost more data to "proven reliable systems" than to my homegrown hacked-up stuff (which may be because I trust the latter much less).
thenthenthen 12 hours ago||
This. My synology nas got pwned so many times i cant remember.
bakugo 15 hours ago||
> I would rather use a proven reliable system that’s been used and tested by millions of other users

You're describing ZFS.

NexRebular 9 hours ago||||
> You're describing ZFS.

..running on illumos.

tamimio 15 hours ago|||
Not really, zfs is part of it, but not the whole picture, you as a user you need more than just a file system.

Truenas for example add replication, external cloud sync, gui (yes it’s important not to wipe your data with wrong command), HA, custom caching, containers to extend ot with other apps, raid-z expansion with openzfs, and other for monitoring, user management and a lot more.

Other solutions also add more than just a zfs with ssh access.