Top
Best
New

Posted by therepanic 7 hours ago

I love LLMs, I hate hype(geohot.github.io)
309 points | 187 commentspage 4
kotberg 4 hours ago||
[flagged]
fuckaiwriter 6 hours ago||
[flagged]
jaaacckz 5 hours ago|
You eat poop for fun
fuckaiwriter 4 hours ago||
Fuck you
HellDunkel 6 hours ago||
How to you love this stuff so hard? I could newer love any ai generated music, book or artwork. Anything ai gemerated i have ever seem or heard was either disgustingly slop or indistinguishable from something else which was real. It‘s a like finding a cool track only to discover it‘s a lazy bootleg.
nylonstrung 6 hours ago||
Yeah but it was only like 2 years ago that artists were arguing this on the basis that AI-gen images would consistently mangle hands

Now we're at a point where that never happens, and where lipsync is almost a completely solved problem

If the issue here is simply that the quality is bad, one has to contend with the fact that it is undoubtedly exponentially improving and there's no reason we should expect that improvement to stop

I also don't have any interest in consuming AI generated art, but the same criticisms were levied at computer graphics and if we're comparing to CGI we'd be at the late 1970s in terms of nascency

Jtarii 3 hours ago||
An LLM cannot make art because it isn't human. It can make "art like artifacts". Art involves one human communicating some emotional experience to another human, LLMs cannot experience human emotion, so they cannot make art.

The process of making art is not a subset of hill climbing optimisation algorithms.

int_19h 2 hours ago||
By this definition most of our culture isn't art because it's made not to "communicate some emotional experience" but to induce one in order to make money. 90% of pop music is like that, for example. And LLMs can do that just as well - better, probably, since they know all the psychological tricks from their training data.
m463 6 hours ago|||
I've made ai generated art using family photos as the starting point, and it was wonderful. :)
ivanjermakov 6 hours ago||
I'm sure most engineering is LLM-assisted already and nothing is wrong with it. It's just the one-shot vibe-coded low quality slop that spoils sentiment of this tools. Also many people are interested in what agents can build unsupervised as a test of "superintelligence".
apsurd 6 hours ago|
Your SF hate isn't a good look.

There are many things to be critical about but shoehorning an entire metro into the echo-chamber you're supposedly beyond yet can't help but orient your entire world view as the anti-SF-tech-bro all while running a startup and discussing AI on HN.

TLDR: SF is more than Paul Graham worship parties.

EDIT: Think I'm being misunderstood! author goes out of his way to blame shitty San Francisco.

> This is negative valence hype, not only is it not true, it’s mostly designed to make you feel bad about yourself and move to shitty San Francisco where everything really does suck like how these people claim.

markasoftware 6 hours ago||
the vast majority of the target audience of this blog post would only consider moving to SF because of the tech scene. This isn't a mountain biking or asian food blog.
nylonstrung 6 hours ago|||
> shoehorning an entire metro into the echo-chamber you're supposedly beyond

The SF metro is possibly the worst in the entire world in terms of CoL vs QoL.

It has a higher proportion of unsheltered population living on the streets than almost any city outside of Africa except Manila and possibly Dhaka

NetOpWibby 6 hours ago|||
False equivalency
apsurd 6 hours ago||
ooh I like your site: https://webb.page

false equating that author's AI hate is hating SF tech-bros? Oh I think I am being misunderstood, that makes me feel better about the insta-downvotes. Author states it plainly:

> This is negative valence hype, not only is it not true, it’s mostly designed to make you feel bad about yourself and move to shitty San Francisco where everything really does suck like how these people claim.

apsurd 6 hours ago||
damn, you all hate SF that much?
vatsachak 6 hours ago||
I don't hate SF it's just overpriced.

Whenever I visit SFO it's really funny seeing all the advertisements from startups above a population struggling to find housing.

Won't it be better to pay someone 100k in Reno than 180k in SF? Most collaboration happens online these days anyways.

Honestly 60k in Barcelona is like 200k in SF when you look at housing and public services.

We need to punish bad city governance for being bad.

mistrial9 2 hours ago||
San Francisco has always been a crooked city

source: Barbary Coast USA