Top
Best
New

Posted by ano-ther 5 hours ago

Thunderbird Desktop settings research: what we learned from your feedback(blog.thunderbird.net)
58 points | 47 comments
extr0pian 4 hours ago|
From user feedback, I wonder if they've learned how to prevent Thunderbird from creating an empty "thunderbird" folder in my home directory yet.
Jaxan 3 hours ago||
Hmm strange, I have never had a thunderbird folder in my home dir. I use thunderbird on Mac, Windows and Linux (Ubuntu).
extr0pian 3 hours ago||
It's been an ongoing issue since the beginning of the year, at least on Linux. Since you're using Ubuntu (which is based on Debian), you may be using an older or an LTS version. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2007074
vlod 3 hours ago|||
Is this is the snap version of tb? If so it has restricted file access.

Maybe try the .deb version? (maybe need to back up your data in ~/snap/thunderbird/

nosrepa 1 hour ago||
The flatpack version does it as well.
grayhatter 2 hours ago|||
If only there was a way to edit the source code, and recompile it yourself.

Oh well, no software is perfect.

llbbdd 2 hours ago||
This is a good encapsulation of why the year of the Linux desktop is perpetually fifteen years away.
fragmede 2 hours ago||
The year of Linux desktop will come after the desktop is no longer relevant, but I'll be honest, I've been AI-pilled, and it's never been a better time to run a Linux desktop. Instead of going sleuthing every time I hit a papercut that previously I'd have spend hours consulting a how-to or a wiki to find the subsystems and config files to fix the problem, I can now just describe the problem to an AI agent that runs around on my system that just fixes it while I go off and do something else.
nullsanity 4 hours ago||
[dead]
sunaookami 3 hours ago||
Kudos to the Thunderbird team for improving TB so much over the past few years, it really helped that they split from Mozilla. K9-Mail (which is now TB) also strongly benefitted from this. Maybe Mozilla will start listening to their users someday...
ajdude 3 hours ago||
> A few weeks ago, we conducted hour-long conversations with 10 of our users to dig deep into how you manage your preferences and configurations in Thunderbird desktop

Is only 10 people representative of the population of thunderbird users?

Aachen 3 hours ago||
Fwiw, even just going through your software with one user can give quite a few insights about what's not obvious about it. That's not at all to say you never need more, but very few open source projects do user research in the first place, being passion projects that just scratch the developer's/s' itch. More samples is always better, definitely at n=10, but I'd also not dismiss the results and benefits of doing it!
InsideOutSanta 2 hours ago|||
Also, how many people you need depends heavily on whether the thing you're researching affects a lot of people. If settings has a problem that affects 40% of people, then a sample of 10 people would yield results representative of the whole population.

Sample size is a very weird, often kinda counter-intuitive topic.

daneel_w 3 hours ago|||
If the crowd is diverse enough. Was it? The article doesn't reveal.
angiolillo 3 hours ago||
The video goes into slightly more depth, and at about 1:30 into the video they acknowledge that the participants were not representative and that they would like to conduct further research.
angiolillo 3 hours ago|||
> Is only 10 people representative of the population of thunderbird users?

For very narrow studies it is possible to get representative data with fewer than a dozen interviews, but in this case it is explicitly not representative. In the video they mention that most of the participants have used Thunderbird for over a decade and follow release notes, development, and various forums closely, which to me suggests that they were recruited opportunistically rather than a random statistical sampling.

They do mention that they have plans to engage a larger audience in the future but that can be incredibly expensive. Even large organizations typically have to augment a small number of representative interviews with a large number of surveys and a very large set of user telemetry to properly weight interview feedback.

mmooss 3 hours ago|||
It's a standard research technique. You can have 2,000 people answer an automated survey but you can't have hour-long conversations with them. Researchers in many fields would like a better solution for in-depth interviews.
BeetleB 2 hours ago||
Thunderbird has as many as 10 users?!

(I jest!)

autoexec 1 hour ago||
> You customize extensively during your initial setup, followed only by minor tweaks to get your workspace just right.

If all of your users customize extensively the moment they get your hands on the software that means your defaults suck. As long as they keep letting people customize it's good enough though.

ptx 2 hours ago||
Why are they repeating the 6 key themes twice but phrased in different ways and in different order? And then there are 6 recommendations and 5 improvements which are very similar to each other, but the article doesn't say how they are related.

I would suggest they first "demystify the language" and "streamline information architecture" of the article itself.

Also some details would be nice. And some acknowledgement of an understanding that the UI being "dated" and not "modern" probably isn't what's making it difficult to use.

autoexec 1 hour ago||
If I were one of those 10 people I'd have told them that I love "dated" UIs. Most modern UIs are trash. I'd hate it if efforts to make Thunderbird shiny enough to attract users sacrificed functionality, ease of use, or customization.
Insimwytim 36 minutes ago||
The post is vibe-slop, prompted by non-technical PM who viewed the task as a chore.

The tone with which it manages to objectify the users and distance from them is a cherry on top.

the__alchemist 3 hours ago||
TB has big UX problems not mentioned: Search works poorly (Misses too many results to be useful), messages you typed have weird paragraph spacings, and reading multi-message threads is a mess.
autoexec 1 hour ago||
Search does miss a lot of stuff. I hope they never get rid of the option for storing messages in MBOX because I find I have to grep through my messages all the time.
pmontra 2 hours ago|||
Which UX problems? When I read

> Thunderbird’s robust functionality is its superpower, but a dated interface shouldn’t be a barrier to entry for newer users.

I started preparing for the worst.

healsdata 1 hour ago||
Search doesn't work on mobile for me at all. On Desktop, I always have to fiddle with filters to find the message I want.
cromka 4 hours ago||
If they make importing an ICS file a one-click action in place of the full-blown, click-through import wizard, I'll be a happy camper.

Deep down, though, I really wish they rebuilt it on top of something less heavy than Firefox, eg. ZED's GPUI.

Daunk 2 hours ago||
I want to use Thunderbird, but it's so... weird. And why can it not be minimized to tray? Am I supposed to sit and keep the Thunderbird window open at all times?
tappaseater 2 hours ago|
It's funny you should say that, because the next release apparently directly addresses this. Including startup to tray. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/close-tray-starting-154
Daunk 2 hours ago||
Wow, finally! Thanks for sharing.
mbeex 3 hours ago||
> Settings

Missing step numero Zero: What is a menu bar, where should it be placed, and how do I use its menu items in a way that adheres to the basic design rules of all operating systems on which this software runs?

BoppreH 2 hours ago|
I tried Thunderbird recently, and was baffled that there seemed to be no way to see received emails grouped with my responses to them (aka threading or conversations). Even grouping incoming emails that have the same subject seemed like an experimental feature.

Surely I'm missing something? How are people using it? If someone replies to you "I think there was a problem with your attachment", do you search for your sent email?

sylens 1 hour ago||
It’s been there for a while https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/message-threading-thund...
commoner 1 hour ago|||
Thunderbird supports threading in the message list pane (which displays replies next to the email that was replied to), but a conversation mode for the message pane is still in development:

https://connect.mozilla.org/t5/ideas/true-threaded-conversat...

In the meantime, the Thunderbird Conversations add-on provides a conversation view that looks like classic Gmail, which is probably what you're looking for:

https://addons.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/addon/gmail...

More comments...