Top
Best
New

Posted by yenniejun111 16 hours ago

Are we offloading too much of our thinking to AI?(www.artfish.ai)
439 points | 415 commentspage 10
integricho 15 hours ago|
Yes.
christkv 15 hours ago||
Yes that seems pretty clear. We also need quick adaptation in school and university to avoid cheating. Back to closed book exams I guess, home projects not counting for the final score. It sucks but I don´t see how you can´t avoid removing technology for evaluation. Sure people can use AI to boost their ability to get better results but they will have to prove it the old way with no assisted help and people watching them during exams.
m0llusk 15 hours ago||
LLMs are strongly mean reverting in their decision making, so heavy users are likely to be readily identified by their unadventurous conformism much as generated media is identified now.
therobots927 16 hours ago||
I’ve found that when I ask AI to do something for me that I know how to do myself - but would rather not spend the time doing - there is a not insignificant chance that the AI will return a subpar result, which I can usually tell rather quickly. Either by glancing at the code, or trying to compile it and getting an error.

This happens frequently enough that it creates a real disincentive for me to use AI for anything that I already know how to do - and use it exclusively for things I don’t know how to do.

It’s deeply frustrating to realize you just wasted 20 minutes posting error messages into Claude when you could’ve just locked in and written it yourself.

SecretDreams 16 hours ago||
Yes
nickphx 16 hours ago||
Who is "we"? Is there a mouse in your pocket?
recursive 15 hours ago|
The royal "we"! You know, the editorial "we"!
theultdev 16 hours ago||
"we" no. just allows me to think about the stuff that matters.

and work on things that would usually be out of my element.

if you aren't thinking more than ever, you're using ai wrong.

zytoon 15 hours ago||
Absolutely. Calculators made us lazy. GPS made us dumb. LLMs are turning us into idiots. Because idiots have the power to damage themselves and others
jitl 16 hours ago||
yes
josefritzishere 14 hours ago|
The normal application of Betteridge's law of headlines is "no" but I think this is one of the rare instances where it's "yes."
More comments...