Top
Best
New

Posted by neversaydie 8 hours ago

First atmosphere found on Earth-like planet in habitable zone of distant star(www.bbc.com)
287 points | 200 commentspage 2
dempedempe 5 hours ago|
> Researchers have found the first atmosphere surrounding an Earth-like, rocky planet orbiting within the habitable zone of a distant star.

Well, if they observed not only a planet orbiting the star but also the planet's atmosphere, it must not be a very "distant" star.

techteach00 3 hours ago||
What technology currently available combined with the best launch window, gravity assist etc exists? Might as well send a probe.
creesch 3 hours ago||
The speed of light is 1079 252 848 km/h, the fastest space craft ever made was the Parker Solar probe (using a sling shot) clocking in at 692 000 km/h. So at that speed it would take, 1559 years to travel one light year.

This planet sits at a distance of 48 light years, so it would 74 832 years to get there. Just for good measure, when it gets there it would also take 48 years for us to know that since radio travels at the speed of light.

Note, that the speed of the spacecraft I mentioned was the peak speed. Space is big, really big.

micromacrofoot 3 hours ago||
500+ years, and it would likely need to be inert for most of that trip, space is big
creesch 3 hours ago||
Try 74 832 years actually.
danieltk76 4 hours ago||
i do hope in my lifetime we find other animals on other planets
palata 3 hours ago|
So that we still have animal to kill in our lifetime, after the ones on Earth are all extinct?
kobelb 2 hours ago||
[flagged]
qwerpy 48 minutes ago|
I know HN hates being compared to that social media website which must not be named, but just look at this.
bilsbie 6 hours ago||
Am I understanding right? They detected an atmosphere but don’t know what it’s made of?
notaustinpowers 5 hours ago||
They detected helium escaping from the upper atmosphere which they believe to be evidence of a retained atmosphere, but haven't been able to fully identify the elements present in the lower atmosphere.

Due to the density of the planet they believe it could be a water world, or a mostly-icy world due to the lack of hydrogen found, and the lower atmosphere could consist of nitrogen, water vapor, and carbon dioxide. Since the host star is very inactive, there's little atmospheric erosion that would strip away a heavier atmosphere.

calgarymicro 5 hours ago||
No, they detected helium, which would be in the upper reaches of the planet's atmosphere (as on Earth); they believe there are other gasses lower down, but the helium is what's confirmed.
OrvalWintermute 2 hours ago||
They found Planet X, Nibiru! :0
astral_drama 7 hours ago||
How far will we peer into the unknown? What will we find out there?
NoGravitas 3 hours ago||
We live on a placid island of ignorance in the midst of black seas of infinity, and it was not meant that we should voyage far. The sciences, each straining in its own direction, have hitherto harmed us little; but some day the piecing together of dissociated knowledge will open up such terrifying vistas of reality, and of our frightful position therein, that we shall either go mad from the revelation or flee from the light into the peace and safety of a new dark age.
astral_drama 2 hours ago||
It's a good Lovecraft quote,but I was inspired by Collective Soul's Shine when I saw the OP.

  Lay me on the ground
  And fly me in the sky
  Show me where to look
  Tell me, what will I find?
  What will I find?
an0malous 5 hours ago||
aliems
nobody9999 3 hours ago||
Underlying paper from Science[0]

[0] https://www.science.org/content/article/astronomers-spot-fir...

shevy-java 3 hours ago||
This whole search for life outside planet Earth is ... stupid.

Life is already on this planet. Why would it matter whether life exists outside of this planet or not? I mean, this is pointless. I understand that some have a financial motife to drive this narrative, but it is not logical. The counter argument is quite simple: IF there is no divine being, then ALL of life's complexity is logical and natural. So, it really does not matter WHERE it originates nor how many times. Why would it matter if it originated 10000x or only once? Now, I do not doubt that it has originated several times rather than once, but my point is that this extra-terrestrial search MAKES ABSOLUTELY NO SENSE AT ALL. That is not to say that research and exploration in space are pointless, but that it IS pointless to "search" for extraterrestrial life. Yet none in the media point that out. It's all as if it were some magical, mythical quest here.

seydor 3 hours ago|
life generates intelligence , intelligence (may) generate traversable wormholes
ck2 5 hours ago|
we talked about this in great detail yesterday on HN with some fantastic comments

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48939742

NASA has a neat exoplanet catalog where you can also switch to its solar system view

* https://science.nasa.gov/exoplanet-catalog/lhs-1140-b/

Super-Earths are interesting but not technically habitable, at least not by humanoids, the gravity would be insane

There are new telescopes and techniques coming online really soon that can potentially find closer to Earth-sized planets but they probably won't be within 50 light years

adding: hmm maybe gravity not too horrible on 1140b but still INTENSE

(assuming Google's "AI" is correct)

> Gravity Formula: \frac{Mass}{Radius^2}\)Calculation: \(5.6 \div (1.73)^2 = 5.6 \div 2.9929 \approx 1.87\)

> if you weigh 150 lbs on Earth, you would weigh roughly 280.5 lbs on 1140b

More comments...