Top
Best
New

Posted by teleforce 1 day ago

Bananas sprout in Rayleigh Garden UK after 15 years(www.bbc.com)
174 points | 132 commentspage 2
zakki 1 day ago|
It looks like Javanese call that banana as Gedhang Kluthuk (Stone Banana, direct translation). The owner can use it to make a super delicious Rujak Cingur.
DivingForGold 1 day ago||
... Botanist James Wong has appeared on the BBC's A Countryside Summer

Wong, 45, has presented for BBC series' Grow Your Own Drugs and Secrets of Your Food.

Curious what is the latest on genetic improvement of banana against Panama disease ?

kratikanarad 1 day ago||
Lovely
mytailorisrich 1 day ago||
I have several banana plants in my garden in Southern England. Musa Sikkimensis and Musa Basjoo, 3+m tall at the moment.

Winters are too cold for them here. So either you heavily mulch them and they start from the roots every spring while the stems die in winter. Or you learn how to wrap the stems to protect them over winter.

It might be possible, or borderline to keep them unprotected within London but outside of there and inland temperatures can drop below -5C even in the South.

On the other hand, I think they have started growing tropical fruits like mangos and bananas in Sicily.

ksec 1 day ago||
Um. I wonder if there are any export opportunities for British Bananas ?
ebbi 1 day ago||
Slightly off-topic:

When I used to eat banana-flavored things (milkshakes, chocolate bars, etc), I always thought that the flavor was artifically inflated and tasted nothing like an actual banana...

...until I went to Fiji. Externally, the appearance of the banana would probably render it as waste in Western countries as it doesn't look nice and yellow - and looks close to what an overripe/rotten banana looks like, but gosh they tasted amazing!

Planktonne 1 day ago||
> ...while we say goodbye to some old favourites.

An incredibly dystopian way to minimise human-caused climate change and potential extinction for yet more species.

pocksuppet 1 day ago|
Potential? The Holocene Extinction is already the sixth mass extinction in Earth's history, and that's pre-climate-change.
Planktonne 1 day ago||
I know, but currently we still have rhubarb. The article is extremely blasé about even more species losing their environment.
card_zero 1 day ago||
Rhubarb isn't native to the UK. Its origins are mysterious (the "barb" is for barbarian) but I think it came over with the Romans. I had a feeling that the Tiber was named after rhubarb, but I'm remembering something wrong there evidently.
t43562 13 hours ago|||
I know it grows well in Zimbabwe at least. My mum used to make a lot of rhubarb crumble. Yum!
pvaldes 1 day ago|||
Most probably Asian. There are closer Hymalayan species, if I remember correctly
glasffordd 1 day ago||
[dead]
inigyou 1 day ago||
[flagged]
flyingshelf 1 day ago|
I saw a banana tree with green bananas in Fribourg Switzerland in September 2025. According to Gemini this city is much colder than Essex, and yet.
embedding-shape 1 day ago||
> According to Gemini

According to Gemini, lots of untrue things are true.

More useful to look at https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a7/World_Ha... and see if that makes more sense, although seemingly it's changing a bit and that graphic is quite old by now (2012). A plant's survival depends on more than just its hardiness and what zone it's in of course, but it's a useful starting point.

flyingshelf 1 day ago||
What am I looking at? Switzerland is just a black line mess. The average temperature is lower in Fribourg and you can confirm by looking at actual historical data, which is what Gemini did—correctly.
toasty228 1 day ago|||
> According to Gemini this city is much colder than Essex, and yet

And according to science Fribourg offers more growing degree days

https://weatherspark.com/compare/y/45015~56049/Comparison-of...

jefftk 1 day ago|||
Only infinitesimally more (most of what that chart is showing is that the growing degree days come earlier in the year), and it also gets colder and has a shorter growing season. I'd expect most plants to like this less.
flyingshelf 1 day ago|||
Huh? Fribourg is literally colder, especially in September.
toasty228 1 day ago||
Sure, but there is a reason we came up with growing degree days, wikipedia is one click away
pvaldes 1 day ago||
> "Could bananas be common in British gardens soon?"

Unlikely

> I saw a banana tree with green bananas in Switzerland

1) I believe you. This is not rare. Culturing a banana tree is super easy.

You can easily find one ornamental dwarf banana for your office in Zurich, put it outside in summer and enjoy the sight of the little green bananas. You just need lots of water, a decent sized pot (bananas can produce fruit in pots), some manure and a summer hot. All of this can be found in Switzerland.

Just don't expect fruit.

2) Growing bananas to their harvest time is the impossible part.

Flowers need to mature all winter long, and if they touch just a little chill, commercial banana fruits will stop growing, the stems will wither and collapse to the ground. They need more than 12 months of non-stop warm temperatures to became yellow and tasty. Your banana tree should be treated as an annual herb or kept indoors for many months each year.

But, there are more in this history.

There are around 50 species of banana trees. And lots of hybrids. There are yellow bananas, green bananas, lipstick pink bananas and steel blue bananas.

Some species evolved in mountains of tropical areas. Basically a temperate climate. The trunks that support the fruits can stand much more cold without dying. The problem is that they have small short bluish green bananas that don't worth the effort.

So far, those species are collector oddities or kept for hybridization purposes; but everybody in the field would salivate about breeding a seedless banana of decent quality that stands cold. This creatures are very productive.

gopher_space 1 day ago||
> You just need lots of water

They're more like pets in this sense. Really fun plants to have inside though.