Top
Best
New

Posted by dwwoelfel 13 hours ago

Writing by hand is good for your brain(nealstephenson.substack.com)
1029 points | 495 commentspage 10
malomalsky 12 hours ago|
I like handwriting, but it struggles when you need to copy it in your obsidian
malfist 12 hours ago||
Rocketbook has some products that promise to help with this here. I've tried them and found them high friction but it might be worth it to you.

There's also the pens that use cameras and special papers like livescribe (I think?) but I didn't love those either.

criddell 6 hours ago|||
It's a bummer that Apple Pencil support isn't better in the iPadOS version of Obsidian.
murat124 12 hours ago|||
Take a pic of the pages, extract text.
plastic-enjoyer 11 hours ago||
I just take a photo and let an LLM transcribe it
BiraIgnacio 10 hours ago||
> Don’t worry about conserving paper

The best suggestion, thank you

snorbleck 10 hours ago||
not only writing, but drawing, art, putting a pen or pencil to paper/tablet and just flowing is great to keep the brain muscle active.
ignu 12 hours ago||
I switched from an Obsidian fanboy to only writing by hand, and I'm never going back.

It seemed preposterous to put notes in something I can't back up or "CTRL+F" search, but I've found that yes, sometimes I spend two minutes looking for a note, but when I do I generally never have to look up that information again... as opposed to things I'd search Obsidian for constantly that seemed to never get stored in my brain.

criddell 11 hours ago||
In my first job, my supervisor gave me a Day Timer binder and set of pages for it and I very dependent on it within a few weeks. That thing was always with me and I was a little terrified that I would leave it somewhere. If I were hit by a bus and they gave that book to my replacement, they would have no problem picking up where I left off.

Then I got a series of Palm Pilot devices and left the paper behind. It worked pretty well for me and the grafitti handwriting system was ingenious. Aside from my contact list being duplicated a few times a year, I didn't really have any negative experiences.

Then smart phones hit and even though they can do everything any electronic organizer ever did for me, I've never been as happy with them.

I'm seriously considering buying a paper planner again. Shared calendars is the only thing blocking me.

I love Obsidian too, but for me it's just a place where I park notes for future reference. I don't actively use it.

lilerjee 9 hours ago||
Writing by hand has some advantages and writing by keyboard also has some advantages. Using note-taking app or similar software is very convenient and useful in some situations.
justthehuman 8 hours ago||
So I should buy a drawing tablet for my laptop so I can hand write my AI prompts? Got it!

(/s if not obvious!)

spike021 8 hours ago||
Doesn't work for everyone. I have essential tremor and my handwriting is abysmal.
nephihaha 7 hours ago|
I had to learn to type early on due to my handwriting, but I can read my own. I definitely process things differently through handwriting. When I write stories, my style changes when I type!
bruno_h 8 hours ago||
I'd like to go back to writing with pen and paper, but my bad handwriting bothers me. So any time I start writing something, part of my concentration is wasted on trying to make it look good.
Tepix 12 hours ago||
Great advice. Didn't know Neal is left-handed.

Neal, if you're reading this, will you ever visit Germany on a book signing tour?

ACCount37 9 hours ago||
"Sure, doing X the old-fashioned way is slow, inefficient, and inconvenient in a hundred minor and major ways - but haven't you considered that it might, on an incredibly shaky connection with low effect sizes and uncertain causality, be better than your brain?"

Sorry, but no. I trust that "the Old Way is just Better in an invisible, unproven way" about as much as I trust any other "appeal to tradition".

I like Neal Stephenson's writing, but I wouldn't take this advice seriously.

chris_money202 7 hours ago|
My thoughts on this is there is a deliberate act going on that is doing more for retention than just the simple act of using a (fountain) pen.

If I am in a lecture and I am writing down everything I hear as fast as possible in one ear, on paper, out the other style I don't think writing is any different than typing the same way.

If I am in lecture and I am trying to stay deliberately between the lines of paper, then I have to take the info in, process it in a way where I analyze and summarize it, and then put it on paper neatly. I have to do that for brevity and to keep up with the lecture. Its not the act of just writing, its the analyzation that occurs before the words hit the paper. This can be achieved with typing as well if you deliberately style your notes.

I think sometimes we correlate this in too simple of terms to use pen = better, the pen forces the deliberate action of analysis easier than typing does.

More comments...