Posted by theanonymousone 18 hours ago
I have to admit it rarely comes up in the coding tasks I usually give to LLMs.
But you already know that.
If you poke it just a few times, however, you get to the point where it will eventually say (paraphrasing) that basically only Israel, the US state department, and the ICJ say it's not a genocide.
That is to say that it's framing it as some sort of tricky complex question when it's not. And when interrogated, it basically admits that the only people who dispute it are Israel and it's supporters.
The majority of the world is religious - doesn’t mean the debate on religion isn’t a complex question.
The majority of the world approved of slavery historically.
The majority of countries have ethnically cleansed their Jews, many of them in living memory.
When interrogated you will find that the only ones asserting the war in Gaza is a genocide are people who were anti-Israel anyway.
I'm always suspicious that's the case given how mentions of gaza seem to bring out brand new accounts who only talk about Israel.
[1] https://quincyinst.org/research/the-eighth-front-inside-isra...
We are on a thread discussing Chinese models. Every discussion on here that’s negative about China or its models suddenly gets derailed via whataboutism to Israel/Gaza. A very convenient distraction.
And yes, we were discussing censorship of models which, as I pointed out, doesn't seem like ChatGPT is directly censoring data though it does appear to be manipulating it. Pretty on topic.
It was you, brand new account hiding your past opinions, who came in here to make this solely about Israel.
Yeah, I think you are likely a foreign agent. Prove me wrong and post from an established account.
Any normal user is much more likely to ask questions to which the Anthropic and OpenAI models do not answer, than to ask questions about the modern Chinese history, to which a Chinese LLM will not answer.
This has been debunked here on HN so many times. The Chinese open models do answer the hairy Chinese political questions, and the raw APIs pass-through the response. Now, the answer might be blocked by the agent who's calling the API, specially if you are using a Chinese endpoint instead of the RoW (i.e. Singapore) endpoint.
That's the reason why you should always prefer a open agent/harness as well instead of using the provider's.