Top
Best
New

Posted by tehwebguy 3 hours ago

Tell HN: I hate your fuzzy search

Not just HN the site, everyone’s fuzzy search sucks. Let me do exact match search. Even if it’s an option I have to dig deep to find.

When I ran a site that had lots of search use I agonized over making search good and never nuked exact match for the sake of some fuzzy matching. I wish others would do the same.

79 points | 47 commentspage 2
NikolaNovak 2 hours ago|
Oh man, I hate my area has switched to Facebook marketplace over Kijiji or even craigslist.

Even when an ad exists with EXACT obscure model I'm looking for... It spits out pages of unrelated or semi related garbage before it may or may not show me what I'm actually looking for :-(

Quotes, slashes, nothing seems to work. So I'm with you! Sometimes I just want an exact literal search.

tehwebguy 1 hour ago|
Facebook is the biggest offender (could say that a lot tbh)

"New listings were added that match your search: <$search>"

so-that-was-a-fucking-lie.jpg

alt227 1 hour ago||
I guess most sites just chuck it into elasticsearch and dial up the config values such as fuzziness?
KolmogorovComp 2 hours ago||
Teams, Zulip, WhatsApp, they all suck so much... Discord is decent in my experience.
alex1138 2 hours ago||
Hello there Youtube with your lowest common denominator cheap trash in search results
aeagentic 2 hours ago||
Best search is windows where u get trash can Onlineshop when u look for the trash and terminal the movie if u look for the terminal
yallpendantools 2 hours ago||
Amen! I hate this trend towards fuzzy-first for everything. Deterministic should be default, fuzzy should be a special toggle.

I'd say close to 90% of my daily searches could be served with exact matching. The next 8-9% could be solved by a little more deterministic sophistication (e.g., edit distance, equivalence classes for synonyms). Then the last 1-2% is when I really need some fuzzy magic; mostly to give me an idea what to do with obscure programming-related problems.

bawolff 3 hours ago||
> Not just HN

Umm, does HN even have a search?

Almost every site i've ever used the search of supported exact matches by putting the query in quote marks.

mplanchard 3 hours ago||
Search input box is at the bottom, yes
bawolff 3 hours ago|||
Oh wow. Never noticed that before. Guess im blind.

Although when i tested it just now it did seem to support exact matches using quotes.

bdangubic 3 hours ago|||
absolute marvel of design. it is exactly where it should be!
gabrielsroka 1 hour ago||
Yes: https://hn.algolia.com
gertburger 1 hour ago||
that is algolia's search of hn...
soupspaces 2 hours ago|
script for finding HN GH links ranked

https://gist.github.com/hundredwatt/183191d02f1fe0db31c3e910...

More comments...