Top
Best
New

Posted by devanshp 8 hours ago

I’m leaving OpenAI to build telepathy(naomibashkansky.com)
115 points | 192 commentspage 5
baron3dl 5 hours ago|
who holds the copyright on the transcriptions of my thoughts read by this hardware? what license to those do you impose through EULA? what privacy controls need to be invented to prevent literal thought police?
dudefeliciano 5 hours ago|
if you get an earworm you will have to pay royalties
fatcatsbestcats 2 hours ago||
No, thank you.
commieneko 2 hours ago||
People that get to know each other very well, it can take a while or people can just "click", often have something I wouldn't be embarrassed to call telepathy.

Talking and listening are a really still a big mystery. And thinking is deep underground beneath our understanding.

We barely understand what we are doing when we are doing any of this. Personally I think I under stand what I'm doing when I'm writing much better than what I'm doing when I'm listening.

I'd find that a little surprising, except I've been doing it all my life. I barely have any memories from before I talk, and I have loads more memories from after I learned to read.

Learning to draw and play a musical instrument deepened all this. As did having good, close friends, and partners. I expect having children, which I haven't done, is even more deepening.

The thing is, all these words are just that: words. Very loosey goosey and they change from person to person just as the communicators come from different experiences. And tomorrows me often has a very different outlook than yesterday's me.

I'm not surprised that I can't read the mind of tomorrows me but I'm always a little shocked when I realize I can't read the mind of yesterday's me.

What was I thinking!

I can easily read that blog post as a description of what might come to pass. It might very well not connect very well with us now because, well, we haven't had the experiences yet. Telepathy might mean something very different after we've had experiences with the new technology.

My grandmother, who was born in 1893, often told me about how the world changed radically and almost imperceptibly during the first half of the 20th century. She lived to be 97, and she once said she wondered if would be possible to talk about the, then, present to her younger self. The words she used at the time of the conversation, would not communicate very well because of the lack of common experiences.

I think Shannon had something to say about that. Information is something new and unexpected, but you need the expected to frame it. Give it a foundation.

I'm now in my late 60s, and I can totally relate to what my grandmother was saying. The main difference is that we are now accelerating much faster.

2026 me would have a hard time explaining things I'm doing with AI to 2023 me.

I think that 2027 might be a bit early for some of the things the blog post is describing. But, come the day, I might just shake my head and wonder what in the heck I was thinking.

m4ck_ 6 hours ago||
Maybe I’m just demented but i feel like the first time I interface with chatgpt via telepathy it’s going to see my thoughts when the guy in the cube behind me farts or chews loudly, and send the FBI.

What a terrible idea.

cormorant 6 hours ago||
Never mind "how could this go wrong". How could this go right?
Razengan 6 hours ago|
Simple, think about going right
robterrell 5 hours ago|||
For some reason your comment reminded me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ky-uzsw0kqw
yunnpp 5 hours ago|||
Up and to the right, to be more specific. Transcend your one-dimensional thinking, Razengan.
dminik 2 hours ago||
Maybe all of those authors exploring dystopian cyberpunk settings were onto something.
mcfdoesdev 6 hours ago||
My thoughts being beamed to a frontier model where they are monetizable (and used for training) is terrifying.
gorgolo 5 hours ago||
They will also want to beam back the response straight back into your brain one day.
dudefeliciano 5 hours ago||
it's in the article, around 2030 the device should be able to write and "make changes to the brain: hear audio, or tell the brain to use more calories" ...and later she envisions chatGPT becoming an extension of the brain like a sixth sense.
prerok 5 hours ago||
The future is Borg.
mcfdoesdev 5 hours ago||
I am locutus.
goatlover 5 hours ago||
No worries, I'm sure there won't be Flock cameras reading your thought crimes as you drive/walk by.
Garlef 3 hours ago||
Baumkuchen
gverrilla 5 hours ago|
> My AI is a natural extension of me. It feels like a sixth sense and another limb. I wonder about a problem, feel as though I’m literally surfing the web, see glimpses of the websites, get flashes of intuition about the problem, and ultimately derive the answer. It feels fun! My brain is like the Flash. Because of write tech, my thinking is the fastest it's ever been even when I turn my AI off.

I read "race conditions" all over this vision.

More comments...