Top
Best
New

Posted by _da_ 11 hours ago

App Store Rejection of the Week: Dark Hours(daringfireball.net)
308 points | 177 commentspage 3
catuscubitus 7 hours ago|
> It’s actually exquisitely well-designed and painstaking crafted. It’s exactly the sort of app that the App Store ought to celebrate and highlight.

Exactly what I thought at some point. Apple, or whoever they outsource their app store reviews to, certainly try hard to beat that kind of idealism out of people. I let my developer subscription run out and moved on to make web apps only. Never looked back.

jgruber 6 hours ago|
Just fixed the /painstaking/painstakingLY/ typo in this sentence. Thanks for quoting it here.
whywhywhywhy 9 hours ago||
The concept of computers that for programs to run on them need to be submitted to a committee who decides if the users computer can run it or not felt like where the tides were going for a long time.

Post AI this starts to feel absurd and look if OpenAI release a hardware device with an App Store will the process be days to weeks of review or will it be vibe code it in 40 minutes hit publish and it’s available to every device in 2 minutes?

Yeah think software is thankfully going towards a world where bureaucracy isn’t respected.

The apple decides what the box or square in your hand can do era is over.

ungreased0675 7 hours ago||
At first I wondered if this was caused by a language barrier caused by outsourcing app review somewhere where labor is as cheap as possible.

Then I read more and realized it was just stupidity.

namanaggarwal 9 hours ago||
Honestly, reading this, I kinda feel they have an AI integration in the review tool, which hallucinate and tell them it’s Astrology and employees at that level don’t want to go against that judgement
classified 1 hour ago||
> The App Store is not a functioning system.

Sad to say this, but this has been known since forever.

atorodius 8 hours ago||
> We understand that the app includes a live tarot reading feature

I don’t understand why tarot reading apps are banned, can someone enlighten me?

ceejayoz 7 hours ago|
Apple has extremely/problematically vague guidelines about what constitutes spammy apps.

https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/#des...

> Don’t submit apps that are indistinguishable from what's already widely available. Opportunistically creating variants of existing app categories or popular apps degrades App Store discovery, reduces overall app quality, and harms both users and developers. Certain kinds of apps, such as dating, flashlight, sound effects, wallpaper, simple timers, and fortune telling, are well established on the App Store and we will not accept new submissions unless they offer a meaningfully different or improved experience.

drcongo 10 hours ago||
Reject this, but allow a billion spammy gambling scam apps pride of place in App Store searches. Gross.
AlexandrB 11 hours ago|
I look forward to this app now being approved because getting a viral post on reddit/HN/Twitter is what passes for customer service in 2026.
More comments...