Top
Best
New

Posted by twapi 20 hours ago

Maximizing the value of your Claude Code sessions(claude.com)
242 points | 131 commentspage 4
apercu 17 hours ago|
I didn't read the whole thing, but I got my back up at the headline and my first reaction is now even the "AI" companies are telling you that "you're holding it wrong".

I mean, they told us "just talk naturally to the AI because it's so much smarter than all you meatbags" and now it's “for best results, please learn to manage context windows, prompt caching, cache invalidation, model switching, output verbosity and when to manually clear or compact your session.”

I get it, but it seems like the "PRODUCT" should be doing this shit. I.e., the PRODUCT is getting less efficient because I didn't manually manage its context correctly and now it's MY fault.

Edit: i.e., for e.g. Doh. Even the robots get that right. Sigh.

QuercusMax 17 hours ago||
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." -Upton Sinclair

Anthropic has no incentive to make their products more efficient as long as they're selling them by the token.

DangitBobby 16 hours ago||
They are selling to many customers by subscription.
DangitBobby 16 hours ago||
There is no shortage of literature on how to communicate effectively with real people.
apercu 16 hours ago||
I'm doing my best to interpret your comment but if I parse it it seems like you think my complaint is "I shouldn't have to express myself clearly" when really its "Why am I being asked to understand and manually manage the implementation details of the product in order to keep it working efficiently?".

Unless I am fully not understanding your comment and you don't actually mean “humans require communication skills too” which in honesty feels orthogonal to my complaint.

DangitBobby 15 hours ago||
> I mean, they told us "just talk naturally to the AI because it's so much smarter than all you meatbags" and now it's “for best results, please learn to manage context windows, prompt caching, cache invalidation, model switching, output verbosity and when to manually clear or compact your session.”

It's true both that it can be smarter than all us meat bags and that talking to it a certain way gets better results. On some of the things it's a limitation of the technology and on some of the others it's just how information and effort work in any context. I don't see it as orthogonal to your complaint, I see your complaint as misplaced frustration, like Anthropic invented GIGO and compute so they'd have an excuse to write a blog post.

apercu 14 hours ago||
Huh. And to me it’s like “I can’t believe Anthropic has the audacity to post that and I can’t believe my peers defend it”

Oh well.

DangitBobby 12 hours ago||
And I in turn can't believe your response to the post. Different strokes for different folks. I understand that HN fucking hates everything and everyone, especially big model providers at the moment, but this shit doesn't make any sense to me and you people are starting to actually make me crazy.
dude250711 14 hours ago||
"TL;DR ..."

If only they had some kind of technology that could make a judgement and automate those actions...

grey-area 7 hours ago|
Well, they claim it is capable of such tasks, but in reality, it can’t reliably do so, or they would address them.
NamlchakKhandro 8 hours ago||
meah Claude is peak trash. Really fucking upset that they ban you for using a superior harness
arakas4488 3 hours ago||
[flagged]
pitiflautico 5 hours ago||
[flagged]
tizerluo 6 hours ago||
[flagged]
dmzxnico 6 hours ago||
[flagged]
wongallen010 8 hours ago||
[flagged]
query_ilands 15 hours ago||
[flagged]
myshapeprotocol 7 hours ago|
[flagged]
ChrisGreenHeur 6 hours ago|
Is this comment written by ai?
binarymax 2 hours ago||
Yeah and their comment history is full of it.