Top
Best
New

Posted by ExMachina73 10 hours ago

Chrome again exempts Google from user site data settings(lapcatsoftware.com)
406 points | 60 comments
liquid_thyme 3 hours ago|
Chrome may be an excellent browser, but the venn diagram overlap with malware keeps getting larger.
draw_down 1 hour ago||
[dead]
shevy-java 35 minutes ago||
Is it excellent? It feels more to me that the competition does not really exist - or just sucks. And then people largely gave up, letting the adMoney take over everything.

I abandoned firefox when a mozilla dev claimed Linux users can only listen to audio via systemd+pulseaudio (unless you recompile firefox but who in his sane mind wants to use mozconfig in 2026 - https://www.linuxfromscratch.org/blfs/view/svn/xsoft/firefox...). On adChromium, audio on youtube videos (also owned by Google) works fine, without me having to change anything. And older firefox versions also worked fine. At that moment in time I realised that firefox was no longer about the people. I stopped using it and I seem to not have been the only one who got frustrated with mozilla.

fedpost 7 hours ago||
It's okay, they're not a monopoly according to this administration. Nothing to see here, carry on!
pavon 6 hours ago||
This administration has done nothing to end or undermine the antitrust cases against Google. In both cases the judges found Google in violation of antitrust law, but both handed down fairly mild remedies, despite the administration (prosecutor) pushing for much stronger changes. The judges were appointed by Clinton (Leonie Brinkema) and Obama (Amit Mehta).
eesmith 1 hour ago||
Perhaps not US cases, but those aren't the only antitrust cases against Google.

What about Trump's threats after Google was hit with a 2.95 billion Euro fine from the European Commission's antitrust investigation?

From last year: "EU Trade Commissioner Maroš Šefčovič on Monday made an 11th-hour intervention to stop the European Commission from issuing a penalty against American tech giant Google for its search advertising practices, amid continued trade threats from U.S. President Donald Trump." https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-google-antitrust-decision...

Or from https://www.cnbc.com/2026/04/10/google-meta-big-tech-6-billi... "In February, Trump signed a memorandum stating the U.S. would consider tariffs to “combat digital service taxes (DSTs), fines, practices, and policies that foreign governments levy on American companies.”"

That memorandum is at https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2025/02/fact-sheet-pr...

pampas 5 hours ago|||
No politicians are going to fight a media company. They're in the PR and advertising supply chain.
lostlogin 4 hours ago||
‘Lake America’ buys breathing time too.
shevy-java 34 minutes ago|||
The administration is serving private business only. They don't care about the people.

It is not a democracy nor a republic state. It is an oligarchy. Thankfully more and more people realise how corrupt the orange mafia is. Recent polls show that - people learn slowly, but they learn.

Mountain_Skies 7 hours ago||
[flagged]
patates 53 minutes ago|||
So we cannot say anything bad about the current administration without being divisive? What does criticising them tell you about tribalism?
shevy-java 33 minutes ago||
The point is that no matter which party rules, they are bribed by big business to represent the interest of big business. Criticism without change does not really work well.
asdf88990 7 hours ago|||
Exactly. It is like Google has only emerged during this administration with their shenanigans.
Geezus_42 57 minutes ago|||
What rock have you been living under?
usr1106 3 hours ago||||
It seems to be very popular on this site to condemn surveillance capitalism and billionaires. But who built and still maintains the basis for their power, misusing it and the billions. So-called smart engineers like many of HN readers. If they rated morale higher than their personal 100Ks we would not need to wait for a government to stop the misery (in vain).

Yes, I have worked for 400,000 employees corp, then for a 70,000. For the last 15 years I have staid under 100. The pay is less, but it's easier to look into the mirror each morning.

8note 6 hours ago|||
iirc lina khan was appointed during the first trump admin and got most of her work done suing to split google during the biden admin?

you are a bit out of the loop if you think this is a partisan issue, or specifically one thats only there when trump is in charge

manlymuppet 5 hours ago|||
Allow me to be anal for a moment, but what is the point of doing “if I remember correctly” for something like this?

You can very easily look up exactly when Lina Khan was appointed and get answer very quickly. Is it not worth the effort checking these things before commenting?

Ok rant over. Sorry to be an asshole. This is not your fault as much a standard which should be changed.

c0balt 6 hours ago||||
She got nominated by Biden in Biden's last term in March of 2021 and left in 2025 two weeks after Trump assumed office.

She did not get appointed under Trump nor did substantial work done under his administration.

Edit: I do not necessarily disagree with your comment on the partisan aspects of this issue. This is only meant to respond to the first paragraph.

thephyber 5 hours ago|||
Using Lina Khan as an example (your only example?) undermines your point because she started upset Biden and was quickly fired after Trump 2 started.
mgiampapa 7 hours ago||
I feel like the obvious thing to check here is that all chrome processes have terminated between tests. If it's still running some zombie process of course the data would persist.
stkdump 5 hours ago||
It would still be a (albeit convenient for google) bug, as the setting indicates closing all windows as the trigger for deletion.
troupo 29 minutes ago|||
It's convenient that "zombie processes" only retain data for Google-owned sites https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49583517
frankacter 7 hours ago||
At least on windows, closing chrome doesn't close the system tray process which keeps Chrome and Gemini prestaged and cached. Wonder if OP is experiencing a version of that on his Mac?
Tempest1981 7 hours ago|||
Microsoft Edge does this too, iirc, for "Startup Boost".
lapcat 4 hours ago|||
> Wonder if OP is experiencing a version of that on his Mac?

No.

flyingshelf 6 hours ago||
When you log into Google, you also log into Chrome. This means that you'll have a lot of exceptions for Google websites or else a "clear history" would log you out of Chrome.

Not justifying it (I don't use chrome) but that's likely what's happening here.

ande-mnoc 6 hours ago||
This is what the “Allow Chrome sign-in” setting is for and is turned off by the post author.
demibabs 6 hours ago||
In the article he explains he’s not signed into Chrome nor Google during the experiment.
Zarathustra30 5 hours ago||
While I absolutely believe this, the author should include a control. Go to a different website that sets data, and show that it is deleted when Google data is not.
lapcat 4 hours ago|
I did: "As far as I can tell, www.google.com is the only site exempted by Chrome."

My screenshots do not show this, but my screenshots were not intended as proof, merely as explanation. Chrome is available to everyone and used by millions of people, so anyone who wants proof can reproduce the issue themselves, and I hope that they do.

netsharc 2 hours ago||
The fact that the first screenshot is a totally empty browser window (just to show the address bar) made me lose faith about reading the rest of your writing...
jrflowers 56 minutes ago||
Looks like a lot of the other folks here read the post
shevy-java 38 minutes ago||
Folks,

We must do something about Google. They ruin the www.

vehemenz 9 minutes ago|
Hey, let’s not forget Cloudflare
procaryote 2 hours ago||
Just another reason to stop using chrome and it's related browsers.

If you don't want to hand the biggest ad company a monopoly over web-browsing, start using a gecko based browser like librewolf, zen, mullvad or firefox.

est 4 hours ago||
I used to search on google.ca exclusively with disabled js and cookie

Until the day it no longer works. Sad.

righthand 5 hours ago|
Google/Alphabet is a bunch of useful good intentioned services wrapped around an nonuseful evil analytics core/monopoly. The people who work with good intentions that “just want to build cool things”, protect the monopoly and the people with bad intentions, who work to empower Google’s monopoly.
More comments...