Top
Best
New

Posted by iamflimflam1 11 hours ago

Why is Google still serving dodgy ads?(www.atomic14.com)
667 points | 316 commentspage 3
bashtoni 4 hours ago|
Don't be evil -> What does "evil" really mean, anyway? -> Judgements about good and evil don't belong in business -> Evil is pretty profitable, actually
dpkirchner 10 hours ago||
I think the obvious answer is they aren't held to account by regulators. If a few execs were sent to prison for defrauding their users (and investors for taking on so much risk) things would change overnight.
hn_submit 10 hours ago||
These days almost all Google search results return nothing but links to stuff that you can buy instead of useful information you were looking for. They do this because they think they can get away with it, they're the only game in town.

To me this signals a huge opportunity for other companies to dive into. If a new internet search company appeared that returned actual useful search results and clearly delineated ads (like Google used to) I would switch to it almost immediately.

The only way these companies are ever going to change their game is when people vote with their feet!

cmoski 9 hours ago|
Kagi is better. You might want to try it.
hn_submit 9 hours ago|||
Kagi will never make it. Asking people money for search is a non-starter.

Also, I type in something in the search bar and...nothing happens. There's a pop-up below the search bar which tells me nothing is saved with a "Dismiss" button. When I press it I'm being directed to the homepage telling me to pay-up.

bbor 9 hours ago|||
Kagi is such an amazing team, building a truly next-level product. It's hard to realize what you're missing until you experience a real search engine for the first time in decades. It's wonderful.
ChaoStatiX 2 hours ago||
I believe Google already has systems in place to block malicious ads and is actively running them. In fact, according to last year's 'Ads Safety Report 2025,' Google blocked over 8.3 billion bad ads in a single year. Of course, despite these efforts, the sheer volume of ads being uploaded makes it practically impossible to catch every single one of them. Therefore, rather than simply criticizing the issue in a negative light, we should recognize and appreciate the platform's ongoing efforts to clean up its ecosystem.
VinnyBarreca 5 hours ago||
Facebook too. There are so many scams being promoted on FB, which is strange because both Facebook and Google ads used to be really strict about what they approved.

Now, it seems like they just approve anything.

cwillu 3 hours ago||
Google itself serves similar ads for its own services in all its properties. I've been “critically low” on google storage space for several years now, and every google app prompts and notifies and nags about it on every launch.
genrader 3 hours ago||
This is untrue and you have to be at least 80%
acomjean 2 hours ago||
I get those. To be fair they're asking for you to pay for some of the storage you are using for free. They have some tools to help clean up, but not enough... They'll keep nagging.

I mean apple music/tv/icloud are always pinging me with "free 3 month subscriptions".

MS is no better with the "lets finish setting up your pc with one drive..." to which the options are [yes/ remind me again later]

I've moved mostly to linux and its refresing.

-A

flerchin 9 hours ago||
They don't have liability for dodgy ads, but they are paid to run them. POSIWID.
calny 5 hours ago||
I was irritated by this exact same misleading ad a few weeks ago and tweeted about it into the void. Kudos for the author for trying to do something about it.
karim79 3 hours ago||
I think the answer is, that's always been Google's business and not much has really changed. Advertising accounts for about 78% of their total revenue.
ArcHound 10 hours ago|
Man, Google is catching strays from all directions. I recently posted an article about their bot behaviour [0], only to be drowned in other more pressing issues.

To comment on this one: as long as there is no backlash from their real customers (those that buy ads) nothing will change.

[0] https://blog.miloslavhomer.cz/how-google-sees-your-site/

BLKNSLVR 4 hours ago|
This one isn't a stray. This is multiple sources actively and accurately directing their shots.
More comments...