Top
Best
New

Posted by babelfish 12 hours ago

StackOverflow now gets fewer than 1000 questions a month(data.stackexchange.com)
528 points | 436 commentspage 12
cebert 12 hours ago|
I don’t think they’re gonna be long for the world
fHr 5 hours ago||
Good, that site sucked after 2015 pretty much. Museum of powertripping mods.
gspr 5 hours ago||
Everyone seems to say that it was always a terrible place to ask questions where you'd have your question closed for no reason.

I don't understand this at all. In its heyday, I found it working really well. The questions that would be closed were either copy-pastes of homework tasks, vague descriptions of some overarching goal ("how do I implement this?"), walls of code ("why does this crash?"), or obvious duplicates.

I think it's good that the site got rid of those quickly. Sure there'd be some snarky high-rep users around, but they'd mostly listen to facts or at least be drowned out by more useful contributions.

code_duck 4 hours ago|
From what I recall, there was a golden era where the site was growing and it was useful and entertaining. One problem is that it had a learning curve. I think it got worse when every answer became editable by other people, and power users and rules lawyers became entrenched and they started closing basically every question as a duplicate. That often resulted to sending people to questions that weren't precisely the same, and often with out of date answers. It felt like they never seemed to figure out whether it was supposed to be a Q&A site, a wiki, or a forum (I suppose forum was generally nixed, other than discussion in comments).
Vaslo 11 hours ago||
I answered a number of questions on there. Some non-native English speaker started going my answers and making language editing suggestions. The grammar was fine. I refused all the changes because they were at best basically the same or at worst incorrect. I refused maybe 4-5. The next day the guy got on and had done a bunch more then went to some of my answers and made hostile comments about my answers on simple things like Pandas for Python.

That was that for that site.

Markoff 6 hours ago||
Well deserved, site full of toxic users who will do anything but answer your question, LLM FTW.
6510 12 hours ago||
This question has already been asked?

Pages bloated like myspace make me reluctant to click the search result and I wont browse around if a website doesn't load instantly. Search some exotic kind of bad. That they haven't implemented an LLM is quite untechnological.

It should have an LLM assist with constructing the questions and it should have answers from all providers willing to donate tokens. Upvotes should generate wonderful data on how to construct an answer.

esafak 12 hours ago||
It is sad because it was such a well designed community. But its lessons live on.
kstrauser 11 hours ago||
Nah. It launched well, but sorely needed a BDFL. Almost without fail, services that delegate moderation duties to users are ruined. Inevitably, well-meaning people form councils and boards, and then those get taken over by people with nothing but time on their hands. It's the same thing that happens with school boards and HOAs: the last people you want running them are the ones that have the time and the drive to actually want to be in charge of them.
esafak 10 hours ago|||
How are you going to run a community at scale without delegation? The only alternative is to let the computer do it.
kstrauser 10 hours ago||
HN does a pretty good job of it. Turns out paid employees seem to be more incentivized to keep people coming back.
nullsanity 11 hours ago|||
[dead]
jdthorpe 11 hours ago|||
It was an AMAZING community... right up until it wasn't. I cut my teeth on trying to answer questions and learned how much I didn't know when other people's answers were better than mine. Literally made a career out of what I learned there, and I thoroughly enjoyed welcoming people to SO and encouraging new coders to keep learning. But then dang, the question purists and eager close-every-question jocks came to dominate the platform and made it no fun to ask or answer. Even if AI was never a thing, the change in culture probably would have opened the doors to a competitor.
glouwbug 11 hours ago|||
Everything is cyclical. Maybe they come back when AI gets heavily regulated or pay gated. Who knows
hackersnooze1 11 hours ago|||
does well designed mean rotten and pointlessly hostile
reassess_blind 12 hours ago|||
StackOverflow helped build the LLMs that replaced it.
gscott 9 hours ago||
They should just make all of their answers incorrect, poison llms, return everybody back to programming again.
eluru 11 hours ago||
it was as well designed as the nipples on a man
paulddraper 12 hours ago||
The highly technical sites -- StackOverflow, Unix & Linux, MathOverflow -- see little use.

Others like SciFi & Fantasy and Worldbuilding have kept relevance.

Unfortunately, these more niche sites relied on StackOverflow to drive referral traffic, so the whole platform is declining.

paulpauper 12 hours ago||
I am amazed it's still that high
eluru 11 hours ago|
good, make it die faster
More comments...