Top
Best
New

Posted by csmantle 7 hours ago

Qwenputer: A functioning, deterministic RISC-V CPU inside Qwen3.5(divagr.com)
351 points | 77 commentspage 5
rickcarlino 6 hours ago|
If anyone else has an easier way to emulate RISC-V I’d like to hear it. /S
gigel82 6 hours ago||
But... why? </s>

This reminds me of C++ Template Metaprogramming (TMP) (it's Turing-complete so people wrote "games" that run at compile time). The same with TypeScript types, I think someone got DOOM running entirely in the TypeScript type system. An interesting tech demo but entirely superfluous.

ansk 5 hours ago||
[flagged]
fudged71 4 hours ago|
Be more specific with criticism
ansk 4 hours ago||
This perspective -- that the burden of proof is on the experts to disprove the slop -- is exactly what I think is unsustainable.
rvz 6 hours ago||
So this is yet another rube goldberg machine.

We have gone down this path already in [0] and this is the same thing but overly complicated. This reason is "because LLMs".

Why?

[0] https://arxiv.org/abs/1410.5401

jwitthuhn 5 hours ago|
It is a great example to refute the common misconception that LLMs are inherently non-deterministic. I see people repeating this a lot and being able to point at a CPU implemented within one is a very strong counter-example.
rvz 4 hours ago||
> It is a great example to refute the common misconception that LLMs are inherently non-deterministic.

No it isn't.

Realistically the opposite is true in practice and LLMs are really non-deterministic beyond simplistic experiments such as this in useful activities in production. Even with hacks such as "setting temp=0" (which no-one seriously does) to "achieve determinism", was one of the most common misconceptions ever propagated by "AI engineers".

So using tiny slop experiments aren't really useful as a "strong counter-example". In fact this is a very weak one.

ram_rattle 6 hours ago|
Cool cool cool
crossgrainlab 3 hours ago|
such a nice page. The font and the background colour are comfortable for my eyes to read the context.