Top
Best
New

Posted by taubek 2 days ago

Cisco gives engineer unlimited AI tokens to rewrite legacy code(fortune.com)
227 points | 270 commentspage 6
classified 2 days ago||
So there's a real risk that Cisco might become history in just a few years. Taking that kind of risk with a rather unproven technology has to be psychosis. Or is that kind of belief a form of Religion?
wmf 1 day ago||
Many customers will definitely stick with the pre-sloppified versions of IOS.
m4rtink 2 days ago||
Clear case of AI psychosis.
beloch 1 day ago||
"At most companies, only someone with decades of experience under their belt would be trusted with a project this size. Patel thinks that’s a problem.

“If you don’t hire the early-in-career [workers], and you just let your workforce continue the way that they were, where do fresh ideas get injected? How do you challenge the status quo?” he said."

-------------------

This would be an interesting approach for a bleeding edge startup that's betting big on producing something novel or going bankrupt. If you're going to bet the company on one guy and some AI, that's bold. He'd better have some serious chops and not be merely a slick salesman.

However, Cisco is an infrastructure company. Status quo is what most people want from an infrastructure company. You don't want your Cisco stuff to suddenly start doing new, innovative things that require a complete redux of everything built on top of it. This, of course, assumes that having one guy do a refactor of your entire code-base produces something "innovative" rather than a cavalcade of snafu's.

It's probably not the best time to be holding CSCO.

insane_dreamer 2 days ago||
rewriting code is the easy part

it's the testing in real world usage to shake out all the edge cases and bugs that's hard and that you can't just write unit tests for

dboreham 1 day ago|
I think we can all agree that the task as set forth in the PR puff piece is impossible. That said however, current AI tools are amazing for cleaning up and reanimating old codebases. I've been using Claude on a very large Java protocol proxy product and it's been able to do amazingly useful things for me. I originally wrote much of the code but Claude now knows much more about it than I do today, because people forget stuff over decades. It will sometimes remind me "as you noted in November 2016 this feature was designed to...", based on its analysis of the code and git commit messages.
mikevertal 1 day ago||
[flagged]
pdimitar 1 day ago||
First LLM PTSD case coming soon. You heard it here first, folks.
SidMangsatabam 1 day ago||
[flagged]
spkm 1 day ago||
[dead]
draw_down 1 day ago||
[dead]
pupppet 2 days ago|
[dead]
More comments...