Top
Best
New

Posted by LecroJS 2 days ago

Ask HN: Which TV do you recommend for privacy?

I haven’t owned a TV in years and would like one that respects my privacy. Are there any TV’s which do this well? I am looking for something in the 60”to 80”range and would like a 4k display with at least 60hz display. I don’t mind paying a premium.

I have heard good things about Apple TV as a better alternative to most smart TV native apps. Would some TV’s pair better with this than others for privacy? I don’t want the TV doing anything other than being the display for Apple TV.

I am curious what success others have had.

721 points | 865 commentspage 20
x3haloed 1 day ago|
Any TV that you want. Just don't connect it to a network. Why is this hard?
bitwize 1 day ago||
Sceptre dumb TV. Failing that, large computer monitor or digital signage display. You WILL pay a premium.
Night_Thastus 2 days ago||
Rather than trying to get a TV which doesn't have blatant spyware (when in all likelyhood, they all do, or will get one in a software update), I would suggest solving the problem the other way around - get a TV you know you can disable that functionality in. Trusting the manufacturer is a recipe for disaster.

I stripped out the bluetooth+wifi module from my TV and keep it disconnected from ethernet. Now it doesn't matter what it tries to collect, it can't send it anywhere.

SOFTWARE SWITCHES CAN NEVER BE TRUSTED!

amelius 1 day ago||
Panelook.com (DIY)
nowittyusername 2 days ago||
Next TV I buy im connecting to to Claude code and lobotomizing it...
andsoitis 2 days ago||
It's like every 3 months someone asks some variant of this question.
smlacy 2 days ago|
There are certainly new TV models coming out almost constantly, do it seems warranted? I see no problem with "duplicated" questions?
andsoitis 2 days ago||
What I find amusing is people asking for advice on buying an appliance on this site. Not bad, just an unexpected pattern to my eyes at least.
tristor 1 day ago||
I'm unsure on current models, but historically the best bet (and what I did last in 2023) was to purchase a TV from Costco, as Costco used to (and probably still does) mandate that SKUs they sell must be able to be operated in a non-connected state. I bought a 70" Sony 4K TV in 2023 and /only/ the Costco version provided this option, but on first power on you could select "Basic Display" or "Connected Experience", and after that unless you explicitly changed it that was set. It's never asked to connect to a network or done anything I can detect as nefarious since, and is used only via an HDMI connected appliance I use for streaming.
encom 1 day ago||
Buy a TV from 2016. Mine's a Samsung from 2016. It showed me a EULA on first boot. I declined it. It's been a dumb TV ever since. One input is a LibeELEC NUC, the other an Apple TV, because Netflix requires a botnet to stream >480p.

4K is unironically a meme. You don't need it. A set of decent floor standing speakers (and room treatment) will elevate your movie experience far more than more pixels ever will.

NoMoreNicksLeft 1 day ago||
Does anyone know about the kiosk tvs used for professional displays? Do they still make/sell those?
ubermonkey 1 day ago|
OP, I have been a user of the AppleTV family of products for years. I have no complaints. So far I trust Apple more than Roku or Amazon, and I find the devices work far more smoothly and easily than other players in this space.

Consequently, I have no interest in hooking ANY TV directly to the network. It seems pointless.

I'm 100% not interested in any discussions that begin with "buy model XXX and then install different software..."

I'm not going to hack my TV. I have no interest in sysadmining my television. Success for me would be finding a TV that would work fine for its working life without ever being attached to a wifi network, and that will not try to do so on its own (ie, by joining known-open networks like those provided by Comcast and ATT).

More comments...