Top
Best
New

Posted by sidgarimella 1 day ago

Postman silently auto-installs AI plugins and attempts to share all API data(github.com)
1484 points | 479 comments
pants2 1 day ago|
It's a shame what happened to Postman. It started as an excellent little developer tool for testing APIs. Then for some reason they raised over $400M in funding and hired 1,500+ employees, for what should have been a tiny OSS/passion project like curl or little snitch. Instead they now have to justify their valuation by forcing logins, collecting data, monthly subscriptions, AI features, etc.

I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+ when I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

swatcoder 1 day ago||
> for some reason they raised over $400M in funding and hired 1,500+ employees

You know the reason. A bunch of people were able to take home a lot of money because of that growth and now have the option to FIRE themselves whenever they want to shake off the stress.

That's the founder mentality that Y Combinator exists to leverage or encourage and it's ubiquity is what separates the prevailing 21st century technology movement from the nerdy, academic, UNIX-y movement that gave us GNU, linux, curl, ffmpeg, redis, etc

We got to watch innovative products get pumped full of helium until they explode with bloat and rent-seeking instead of accumulating a growing foundation of sturdy technical building blocks as we could have had on the other path.

AI now leads us into some new movement, the worst version of which a few model vendors protected by regulations absorb almost all technical accomplishment and lease it back out to everybody else, and the best version of which democratizes technical construction so widely that individuals can naively spin up effective solutions for the most idiosyncratic needs.

We'll see how it goes.

mifydev 1 day ago|||
I miss the UNIX-y movement so much :(
antod 1 day ago|||
Yeah. The plucky rebels pretty much won against the evil empire, but the forces of darkness weren't completely beaten. They regrouped and then repurposed the rebels tools against them. The might of venture capital, big tech, SaaS, hyperscalers and AI was too much. The rebels weren't decisively beaten so much as eventually eroded out of any real significance.
Vaushite 22 hours ago||
It helps that the rebels donated copies of all their equipment to the dark forces.
satvikpendem 21 hours ago||
MIT and other non copy left licenses were a mistake. In the 2000s and 2010s people were so concerned with usage and GitHub stars of their OSS that they just gave everything away to corporations and now don't have the right to complain anymore.
brians 15 hours ago|||
Can you point at projects that got abused that way? I see plenty of things that got written by corps or by conglomerates, many of which landed with Apache. And I see lots of copyleft software that pulls whole systems with it.

What’s something that was released as MIT but, had it been GPL2, would have seeded a community?

hkt 13 hours ago||
In fairness, it is easier to point out has-beens than never-weres.
eagleal 14 hours ago||||
Eh, I don't think Openai and Anthropic trained with only MIT licensed copy.
ethbr1 12 hours ago||
Fair, there is the Uber model of 'When a founder does it, it's not illegal.'
oblio 17 hours ago|||
What do you mean? GPL licenses aren't truly free! They limit the right of corporations to abuse users! That can't be right! Better to use another license on the off chance you'll win the VC lottery.
LoganDark 14 hours ago||
I generally agree with fighting corporate abuse, though IMO, GPLv3's anti-tivoization clause is kind of misguided. It may stop locked-down hardware makers from using your software, but it doesn't stop the hardware from being locked-down in the first place.

We have evidence that any hardware maker that would open up their hardware will do it already (see: reMarkable, Ubiquiti offering SSH root access). If you try to fight that battle by holding software from them, you only lose them as a contributor as they make their own, which is worse for everyone.

ctmlr 13 hours ago||||
Miss? Linux won the war and there is more open source software than ever before, now with language models here I think the best has yet to come.
ThrowawayR2 1 day ago||||
Like, what? Solaris/SunOS, DEC Ultrix/Tru64, AIX, HP-UX, Xenix, etc., all with big bad monopolist AT&T's UNIX as their grandpappy. UNIX was corporate to the hilt.
jasomill 23 hours ago||
Corporate, sure, but painting DEC, (old) HP, and Sun with the same brush as AT&T, IBM, and Microsoft just because they sold proprietary, but generally well-documented and reliable hardware and software at whatever prices the market would bear seems unfair.
zaik 1 day ago|||
It's not dead??
conductr 1 day ago||
It’s as dead as rock and roll
rnd0 19 hours ago|||
but the heart of GNU is still beating!
kyleee 20 hours ago||||
Rock vive no muere
bigyabai 1 day ago|||
UNIX is, UNIX-y stuff isn't.
cnity 1 day ago||||
You are good at writing. Thanks for this.
oytmeal 1 day ago|||
Agree... I scrolled back up from the last of the comments just to say this.
alias_neo 13 hours ago||||
Also my first thought upon reading this.
godelmachine 1 day ago|||
Yes, this dude is really good at writing.
krazydad 21 hours ago||||
Very well written reply that voices something I knew but couldn’t quite articulate.
kraag22 7 hours ago||||
I was 100% sure, you are joking. Like they raised gazilion $ and have 100.000 employees. But when I checked, it is actually correct. WTF - what are the hundreds of people doing there? :)
prcrstntr 5 hours ago||||
Destroy everyone else's moat while keeping theirs safe. Whether it's a good tradeoff only time will tell.
agorabinary 1 day ago||||
Articulate and well spoken - I hope that through threads like these that especially tech newcomers discover that there are alternatives to the YC founder mentality of "growth at all costs". A more gradual approach that respects users is also better for founders. You may not retire at 35 with some big exit or raise, but why is that the goal anyway? Build something that respects your users and you can see yourself working on for 30 years, living comfortably and in moderation.

A minor tweak to The Parable of the Mexican Fisherman[1]:

The venture capitalist laughed and said, “That’s the best part. When the time was right, you would announce an IPO, and sell your company stock to the public and become very rich. You would make millions!”

“Millions – then what?”

[1] https://aliabdaal.com/newsletter/the-parable-of-the-mexican-...

lotsofpulp 14 hours ago|||
>You may not retire at 35 with some big exit or raise, but why is that the goal anyway?

Because then I can guarantee access to food/shelter/healthcare for my kids if me or their mom or one of them were to become incapacitated in some way.

roncesvalles 12 hours ago|||
Eh. Human children are hardy and can figure their way out if shit really hits the fan.

You can't make it your life objective to guard against the 0.01% risk of your children becoming orphaned before 18. Just buy term insurance if anything.

lotsofpulp 8 hours ago||
My 4 year old with cancer is not figuring their “way out”, nor is my 7 year old. We are down to a 1 income household, which is fine because we earn high incomes and work from home, so we can still split up and take care of each kid while being able to pay for health insurance and out of pocket maximums.

Insuring against death and orphaned kids is cheap and easy. Insuring against long term disability is not.

If you are a high earner in the US, you can make it your objective and live a far less stressful life because saving a few million is possible.

walt_grata 8 hours ago||
Or we can prioritize single payer and ubi along with other social safety nets to try to ensure its there for anyone who needs it and not those lucky enough to win the capitalism lottery
hluska 6 hours ago|||
Back in my day, we had enough taste not to try to turn a person’s child’s cancer diagnosis into a chance to make a political point. Be a better person - you’re talking to an actual human people; writing something this callous is totally fucked up

Have some basic human respect.

lotsofpulp 8 hours ago|||
I play the game with the rules that are, not how I wish them to be. I’m betting if and when the federal US legislature gets around to passing those safety nets, my kids will be grown up and independent.
prmoustache 12 hours ago|||
Shouldn't that be the purpose of insurances?

Also I am paying taxes for that and am glad of paying it for whoever has the need to instead of them or me having to setup a gofundme campaign.

I'd say voting for the right candidates is better than a system where a few of apparently lucky people can achieve that while in fact they are completely losing their mind in the process and leaving in constant stress (if my observation of founders and so called successful tech bros is correct)

lotsofpulp 8 hours ago||
There is zero chance the federal US government has the legislators needed to pass a sufficient safety net during the years my kids depend on me.
johnnyanmac 1 day ago||||
>". A more gradual approach that respects users is also better for founders. You may not retire at 35 with some big exit or raise, but why is that the goal anyway?

Well, living on the other side of the pond: I get shuffled around and laid off every few years in the game industry and any savings I had got obliterated surviving in this not-recession as everyone around me gaslights me into telling me that "the economy is fine", while doing regular layoffs in nearly all sectors. And it's not like I have some sort of high respect for my craft by those who enjoy it either.

There's definitely a temptation to just sell out, find a huge buyout, and get out of the rat race so I can tinker to my heart's content on stuff I want to make. Not what "sells" or what some director wanted after 20 filters of HR, "focus groups, and other sales people get their hands on it. What integrity am I truly keeping in the former situation?

Of course, all this assumes I have the opportunity to sell out. Someone at that point is more than likely someone who was already in a trajectory to defy the typical 9-5 40 hour grind to begin with.

hluska 6 hours ago|||
If you actually believe this, why are you linking to a website that solicits subscriptions?
red-iron-pine 5 hours ago||||
that's a lot of words to say "greed"
terribleperson 1 day ago||||
I'm already enjoying the second version. I just hope we get to keep it.
guitarlimeo 1 day ago||||
Well put, hopefully it's the latter version.
roncesvalles 12 hours ago||||
It's not a founder mentality as much as a VC mentality. Founders just realized that VCs are dumb rubes with too much money and easy to grift.

If you could raise $200 million with your stupid indie project and proceed to enrich yourself by 7-8 figures, why wouldn't you?

I think the greed percolates down from the VCs. And if you really trace it all the way, it's the ubiquity of index funds. The whole game is to get big enough to IPO and get into VTI's index. Then it's just free money from thereon out.

promano 2 hours ago||
Hoarders can get piles of money, That is true, hackers, that is true. But they cannot help their neighbors; That's not good, hackers, that's not good.
cluckindan 1 day ago||||
Enshittification and private equity are synonymous. Strange that people are still surprised by this.
abirch 1 day ago|||
Perpetual growth at all costs. No idea what's so bad about a mature stable product/company
kulahan 1 day ago|||
It’s basically wondering why your sales aren’t going up when there are still customers to be found. Even if you saturate a market, new people are born every day, at a greater rate than they die, so one would assume you grow or fade, unless customers just like… stop buying things in a category for some reason (maybe a superior category was invented?)

The problem isn’t infinite growth in a still-growing world, it’s exactly what you posted here: Growth at all costs. The pendulum has swung too hard in favor of growth over stability. This is great for shareholders (read:everyone in America who wants to realistically retire one day) but bad for workers (read: everyone in America, regardless of whether or not they want to retire one day).

prmoustache 12 hours ago|||
> Even if you saturate a market, new people are born every day, at a greater rate than they die, so one would assume you grow or fade, unless customers just like… stop buying things in a category for some reason

My own observation is that old people tend to spend less shit on silly things, compulsive purchases and focus on the essential. With an ageing global population I don't think one can expect infinite growth unless the category of services is focused on an older population.

Also society change and some stuff that is needed now won't be needed tomorrow. I don't think there is anything wrong with a shrinking market as long as it is gradual and slow enough that it lets people working for affected companies involved to retire and/or move.

cluckindan 23 hours ago||||
Growth will stop when nobody can buy.
imtringued 14 hours ago|||
"Even if you saturate a market, new people are born every day, at a greater rate than they die"

Not true.

kulahan 12 hours ago||
That people are born every day, or that global population has increased?
abirch 10 hours ago||
I think the parent is saying the population for a given market.
kulahan 2 hours ago||
Yes I know, and I’m purposely not giving it time because it’s a modification of the argument I’m making. As such, I’m giving him a choice between the two things I actually said and actually meant to keep the conversation on track.

If he wants to go and divide the stock market up between international and non-international companies to keep score for his own purposes, he is welcome, but it’s unrelated to the conversation he entered.

bell-cot 1 day ago|||
Late-stage capitalism is addicted to ever-increasing quantities of money.

It'd be nice to imagine our society surviving our ruling classes' addiction, but I would not bet on that.

(You might read some essays by recovered addicts to get a sense of the monomania of it, and why they wouldn't about things like "mature" and "stable".)

m0llusk 20 hours ago||
Capitalism is a system that needs to be controlled. Setting the kitchen on fire is not late stage food preparation. Crashing a car because you drove fast on bald tires is not late stage vehicular mobility.
latentsea 16 hours ago||
Yes, those sound more like "too late" stage.
rafram 1 day ago||||
I don't think Postman has any PE connections.
drBonkers 1 day ago||
Wikipedia states Venture capital (VC) is a form of private equity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venture_capital

rafram 7 hours ago||
Absolutely not what people mean when they say "private equity."
Vaushite 22 hours ago|||
Enshittification and capitalism are synonymous. There's no other magical form of equity that's any better. Steam's an oft cited counterexample but Steam is in enshittification stage 2 (once you have the users, be good to vendors to develop total platform lock-in).
cj9 18 hours ago||
I find it silly that we cite examples at all when it's a sample size of one and hasn't stood the test of time. Without the appropriate legal instruments existing within this system to ensure companies follow a specific founders vision when they retire/die, practically everything is bound to the same road. It either rots from the inside or gets taken over by force.
mschuster91 1 day ago||||
> AI now leads us into some new movement, the worst version of which a few model vendors protected by regulations absorb almost all technical accomplishment and lease it back out to everybody else, and the best version of which democratizes technical construction so widely that individuals can naively spin up effective solutions for the most idiosyncratic needs.

Yeah and the issues from these vibecoded one-off programs will be felt for generations.

I got out of IT partially because I could see the writing on the wall. The "load bearing Excel sheet" is one thing, manageable if you could catch the person who wrote it in time before they depart or die and know your way around Excel - there's only so many ways to achieve a desired goal (unless the author used VBA, at which point all bets are off, and I member encountering a spreadsheet that macro-called in a DLL shipped together with the sheet).

But vibe coded AI bullshit? That is supposed to be hosted by someone and kept secure (i.e. isn't hackable in a few seconds by anyone who manages to compromise some dingus's laptop? Oh hell no. I'm outta there, I'm too old for this crap.

robotnikman 1 day ago|||
>and I member encountering a spreadsheet that macro-called in a DLL shipped together with the sheet

That sounds absolutely horrifying. I never encountered one of those before thankfully.

akiselev 1 day ago||
Oh it gets better (not the OP but I think the following is even worse).

That DLL hooks into SCADA and sometimes sends updates to a PLC controlling safety critical equipment. When does it send updates versus just query the controller? No one knows. The guy who wrote it died in an (unrelated) industrial accident involving a runaway forklift after leaving the company. Even so much as debugging it would require shutting down the entire factory and replacing all the crucibles afterwards ($$$).

jasomill 23 hours ago|||
That's even worse than the time I was on a conference call with the COO of a Fortune 500 retailer who referred to "the Excel spreadsheet we use to keep track of the stores we own".

The subject matter was building an auditing system to comply with the requirements of an IRS consent decree as part of a settlement for shoddy accounting practices which may or may not have included tracking billions of dollars of assets with Excel.

RugnirViking 10 hours ago||
what would be the proper way to keep track of assets? I'm not financially literate at all, just curious
jodrellblank 1 day ago||||
> When does it send updates versus just query the controller? No one knows.

Ask an LLM to reverse engineer it and explain it.

jacobgkau 1 day ago|||
They said this:

> Even so much as debugging it would require shutting down the entire factory and replacing all the crucibles afterwards ($$$).

I'm guessing the fundamental reason debugging would require that isn't something an AI could get around. My guess is the LLM would immediately disregard whatever instructions you gave it not to cause having to replace all the crucibles, then say "Oops! You're right." when you point out that you asked it not to do that.

wholinator2 1 day ago|||
Hmmm, but shouldn't there be some way to just make a copy of the file, put in a container and tell the AI, scan the environment, do nothing except watch what the excel sheet does and record it, then determine how to create an identical sandbox containing the same outputs and feedback. Then see if the sheet works in that sandbox. If it does, then debug it until you get identical behavior out of a new program. Then have a week/month of dry runs just copying the inputs from the real world to it and capturing its output to compare to the dll. Do that for long enough and you should have a drag and drop solution right?

I'm not saying it's easy, or worth anyone's time, but it should be possible right?

mschuster91 14 hours ago||
> Hmmm, but shouldn't there be some way to just make a copy of the file, put in a container and tell the AI, scan the environment, do nothing except watch what the excel sheet does and record it, then determine how to create an identical sandbox containing the same outputs and feedback.

AI will attempt to evade your sandbox.

The only thing you can do is ask the AI to do a decompile and have it summarize, or better, do the summary yourself.

imtringued 14 hours ago||
He used the wrong word, he means a mock or testing harness or a digital twin of the factory.
Ekaros 1 day ago|||
Thankfully we are finally after all these years getting regulation on that sort of stuff. It seems EU was 20 something years late... And no I really think that regulation in case like this is really reasonable idea.
fock 1 day ago||||
sadly this is coming to your linux-distro in no time! Far too many single-dev core building block which are now adding features at breakneck speed conversing with AI only.
pessimizer 1 day ago||||
> But vibe coded AI bullshit? That is supposed to be hosted by someone and kept secure

It's also astonishingly stupid. I don't want a one-off program for everything. I want a well-designed and battle-tested program that I can extend with AI, and that has a ton of people's AIs directed at it, constantly finding bugs, posting them on the bugtracker, and writing and debating pull requests.

I can't comprehend people who think that everything should be built over and over again, and that that will be safe, practical or cheap. It's like they're telling me that I should design a new language for each conversation that I have. Why would I?

The worst part is how far the capabilities of AI are from that dream anyway. They can't even write readable, intelligible code. They're being celebrated for being able to notice buffer overrun errors in code that people would also notice if anybody had ever really looked at some particular span of code in the last 10 years. It's finding errors in move fast and break things code and code that has been maintained by a weirdo professor in his spare time for free and half the economy somehow relies on. That's not magic, its a sign of how sloppy things got.

phil21 1 day ago|||
Because IT/programmers/tech folks in general have abdicated their responsibilities for too long, imo. The industry collectively started huffing their own farts and forgot they operate in a support role for most organizations.

The state of IT has been stagnant at best for the past 20-30 odd years. The promises of the 90's or earlier that we were going to have average office workers being able to automate their workflows never was realized.

Today with AI I'm watching random sales people automate a large portion of the bullshit part of their jobs IT and technology systems foisted upon them for no real reason. Those CRM systems that force you to click 28 buttons per lead you enter into the system, with all sorts of amazing UIx like having to restart from scratch if you miss a field, get logged out during data entry, etc. This is the standard state of most software people interact with on a daily basis.

If current IT didn't absolutely suck for most people, and hadn't become a means to it's own ends I think you'd see a lot less pent up demand for these vibe coded one-off applications that solve a specific problem for a single user.

It's been interesting to watch. Normies can finally get stuff done without the IT and developer gatekeeping and get on with doing the meaningful bits of their jobs. For better or worse. It's certainly going to blow up in quite a few cases, but I think the cat is out of the bag if progress in tooling - not even models - continues at a rapid pace.

jasomill 23 hours ago|||
This sounds exactly like the promises of putting a PC on everyone's desktop rather than a terminal connected to a locked-down mainframe, which in the end led to the lockdown migrating to PCs and the few employees who had any interest in automation forced to use tools like Excel because it was at least an improvement over VBScript and batch files and IT wouldn't let them install legit development tools unless their job description required them.

What are the odds that the average corporate IT department is going to allow the use of anything other than locked-down corporate AI with strict token quotas and stricter acceptable use policies?

batat 13 hours ago||||
First, you do realize that when in some your-employer's-boring-CRM-system a certain field cannot be edited until a specific 5 conditions is met and that conditions allows an object to transition from "new" to "processing" status before field become available etc. then there was a reason for this.

Before Claude these people used to automate their processes in Excel. Then new people would come along and say, "None of this makes any sense to me so I'll just build my own even better automation in Excel". And again, and again. "Random sales people" won't ask Claude:

- Find out who was the PO in 2019, analyze why it was decided to introduce an additional status in FSTP-14475 instead of (...) What happens if the driver currently outside mobile coverage area and the task processing will return a 202 instead of a 200 (not described in the documentation; refer to FSTP-14385 for additional information), but the status will be updated before the deferred change returns (...)

Instead, they'll do something more like:

- I need to be able to quickly change this and that right here, get it done, don't make any mistakes.

Would be good if Claude could recognize an XY problem and respond "Understanding what you don't want is even more important than understanding what you do want" or "If you try to cut corners here again instead of following the established process - thereby making things more difficult for the people in the warehouse - I will inform your manager" instead of just charging ahead "you're absolutely right, see the goal, ignore the obstacles".

Second, it is easier to fix a flawed but already functional system than build a perfect one from scratch - without running into a problems, contradictions, previously unknown nuances during implementation. Because these contradictions, problems, and oddities over the last 10 years naturally gave you the requirements and specifications that no one of the sales-people and decision-making-people were able to articulate in a coherent way. And yes, now, having these specifications, you can rewrite it in Rust and do things better.

RetroTechie 13 hours ago||||
> Today with AI I'm watching random sales people automate a large portion of the bullshit part of their jobs IT and technology systems foisted upon them for no real reason.

Sadly that doesn't help at all. Random people automating heaps of crap in order to do their actual work, just makes the crap easier to manage for them. It doesn't remove it.

I'm reminded of health workers or teachers complaining that half their time is wasted on various types of record-keeping, because employer wants to record, check & micromanage everything. Similar with tax systems becoming ever more complex. Those are just a few of many examples.

AI assisting with managing that, just puts some $profitable$ control knobs in the hands of a very few providers. While at the same time enabling the mountain of crap to grow even further.

A real fix would be to use AI to get a better understanding of the existing heap of crap, and use that understanding to cut large chunks out & re-organise the remainder into a simpler stack.

Doesn't seem to me that that's being done. So far AI is mostly used to ADD to the crap-heap, faster & easier.

mschuster91 12 hours ago||
> A real fix would be to use AI to get a better understanding of the existing heap of crap, and use that understanding to cut large chunks out & re-organise the remainder into a simpler stack.

The thing is, that's been known for a long time, at the latest since the release of Bullshit Jobs [1].

Unfortunately, too many too rich interests are tied up in the status quo.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs

mschuster91 14 hours ago|||
> The industry collectively started huffing their own farts and forgot they operate in a support role for most organizations.

And most organizations still treat IT as a "support role" which means "cost center", only changing attitude when they inevitably get hacked, and a few years down the line, when enough of the managers who were there during the Great Hack are gone, IT gets the cuts again.

jaapz 1 day ago||||
> They can't even write readable, intelligible code.

That really is no longer an up to date view of LLM's. Frontier models can and do write readable, intelligible code.

They can also write shit code.

Kind of like human devs.

mschuster91 14 hours ago||
> Frontier models can and do write readable, intelligible code

The problem is that even frontier models still are prone to regurgitation. They are not that capable of organization and relevance, which is part of why so much LLM output is insanely grating to read.

READMEs in particular are the worst. LLMs tend to regurgitate stuff like "what is located where" that is of zero relevance to the reader, especially if it's yet another bog standard Java, Symfony or React app.

2muchcoffeeman 1 day ago|||
Because even with AI I don’t have infinite capacity to make every piece of software well designed and I have other deadlines.

>They can't even write readable, intelligible code.

Skill issue.

CamperBob2 1 day ago|||
[flagged]
birdsongs 1 day ago|||
True or not - this vibe of "deal with it, it's how things are" feels really crummy to me.

There's legitimate concerns and emotions here. No reason to be a dick when discussing it.

ericfr11 1 day ago||||
Poor judgement call
CamperBob2 1 day ago||
We'll see, won't we.
surgical_fire 1 day ago|||
> Deal with it.

Whenever I spot this shitty cop out here, it is always on a bad take. Never fails.

bigstrat2003 1 day ago||
Yeah, I was going to vouch the comment because while I think it's a bad take, it doesn't really break the rules to have bad takes. Then I got to the arrogant "deal with it", and I think that does cross the line.
CamperBob2 1 day ago||
"Deal with it" crosses the line, but "bullshit" and "crap" doesn't. Got it.
johnnyanmac 1 day ago||||
One pretty much exclusively shuts down discussion. The others can be use to dismiss discussion, but not exclusively.
surgical_fire 1 day ago|||
> Got it.

It's how things work. Deal with it.

CamperBob2 23 hours ago||
Shooting the messenger does not, in fact, work.
vrganj 1 day ago||||
Hoarders can get piles of money,

That is true, hackers, that is true.

But they cannot help their neighbors;

That's not good, hackers, that's not good.

Join us now and share the software;

You'll be free, hackers, you'll be free.

-- The Free Software Song, as written and sung by rms

https://www.gnu.org/music/free-software-song.en.html

netik 1 day ago||
While I agree with every word of this I never want to hear RMS sing this again.
cowlevel 21 hours ago||
You won't be free though, you'll be living under a bridge if you don't get paid. The original free software movers had tenure.
tonymet 1 day ago||||
trying to make money off an invention is perfectly reasonable.
andyroid 1 day ago|||
Indeed, a couple of GUI forms on top of curl is right up there with electricity, antibiotics and sliced bread.
tonymet 1 day ago||
then why haven't you done it?
jmb99 18 hours ago|||
I did! As a high school project. Literally, in high school, one of our assignments was to build a GUI that could make basic HTTP requests (GET and POST, and I think PATCH or something for extra credit) and display the result “nicely.”

Obviously not as full-featured as Postman or Bruno. But this is not something complicated or difficult or novel. My high school teacher had been using this as an assignment since the mid-2000s.

dspillett 22 hours ago|||
Because we don't have that special sort of brain that thinks turning such a simple useful tool into a commercial behemoth is a good idea? I doubt anyone there really things there is a useful purpose to it all, but they have to keep it in motion to keep their pay coming in.
tonymet 22 hours ago||
the world is what you make of it. make something, sell it for exactly what you need to buy bread . I don't see why being so cynical is necessary.

Right now your boss has sold something, and pays you with the remainder. Is he a bad guy?

What's wrong if you did the same?

cj9 18 hours ago|||
> the world is what you make of it.

Except for every single aspect of it that you don't have control over...

kaibee 16 hours ago|||
There is definitely a reasonable salary and team and infrastructure budget for 'Postman exists'. Its when that team takes 400M in capital and the labor hours of 1,500 people that could have been used for... well honestly literally anything else, that it becomes... well beyond parody really?
jodrellblank 1 day ago||||
Silently installing hooks into your other tools, to route their traffic through Postman without your knowledge or consent, is not at all reasonable.
tonymet 1 day ago||
you skipped a node in the tree
Ambolia 1 day ago||||
People hating you for the damage you cause while making money is also perfectly reasonable.
tonymet 1 day ago||
People here forgetting how forums work.
kentm 1 day ago||||
How you try to make money off an invention may be perfectly reasonable, or it may be perfectly unreasonable. The "how" matters here.
tonymet 1 day ago||
nearly every "how" is going to trigger some haters.
preg_match 1 day ago||
Yes but they’re clearly not all equal. Not everyone is a “hater” for thinking that basically installing malware to make money is bad.

There are legitimate, ethical ways to make money, and then not so ethical ones. It seems for tech companies, they often can’t find the ethical ways or they simply don’t produce enough money, and so they feel forced to act unethically.

The only reason they get away with it is… well everyone is doing it. It’s a culture problem, and it’s viral to the entire tech economy. Nobody cares about being scummy, doing things behind users backs, invading their privacy, employing dark patterns, or even leaking highly sensitive data.

tonymet 1 day ago||
this is a bit of a bait and switch. The immediate comment was about opportunism in general.
MiroslavPokorny 20 hours ago||||
Postman is not an invention.

Its not that complicated, most engineers could write their own tool in a day or two.

latentsea 16 hours ago||
Just like Dropbox.
Matl 13 hours ago||
Expect there's about a thousand Postman alternatives on GitHub. And unlike Dropbox you don't need capital for infra so it's easy to make another one. So unlike Dropbox, Postman actually is relatively simple to copy.
theturtletalks 1 day ago|||
It’s definitely the best version. I’m seeing so many amazing open source projects since people who once had the vision, but not the coding chops, can now build what they imagine. I myself am building a personal OS that connects to everything and it’s way more fun to build things and use them yourself vs just paying for some other software. Especially when that software can be enshittified or start to squeeze its users like you mentioned.
caned 1 day ago|||
I'm also seeing people who previously had little interest in coding or understanding systems suddenly become empowered to pump out and deploy unmaintainable trash faster than their peers can resolve the problems they generate.
theturtletalks 1 day ago||
Suit yourself. Always diamonds in the rough and you can check repos I star on Github.

I built software to manage my own e-commerce business before AI coding existed but see teenagers I mentor vibe code applications that are actually helping them make money. They are 5-7 years ahead of where I was at their age and I started the e-commerce business in college.

And these people are making software for themselves and opensourcing it. So what are you on about peers resolving problems?

caned 1 day ago||
One effect doesn't exclude the other. I'm talking about people creating more problems than they are solving because they lack a fundamental understanding of how their systems, and the generated code that acts upon them, actually work. They're enamored with the ease and alacrity with which they can generate code but unwittingly leave a host of issues to be cleaned up. It's usually other people who discover the problems because these suddenly productive "authors" didn't have the know-how and awareness to create exacting enough prompts or sufficiently iterate on the generated output.

It's a phenomenon I've observed which doesn't necessarily take away from the benefits you've found. But maybe it's worth some consideration that this shift in empowerment isn't without negative consequences.

theturtletalks 1 day ago||
Have you built something you actually use? The feedback loop is immediate. You tell Claude and it goes it and fixes it.

You realize mostly proprietary software is made by people that haven’t even worked in that niche? Now people in that niche with these immediate loop can make software work way better and faster. Without the risk of it getting worse over time or selling out it a PE firm like Bending Spoons.

tempest_ 22 hours ago||
So long as the token price stays low, because if it doesnt you will need the PE firm to pay for your tokens.
theturtletalks 19 hours ago||
Not if you reach for something open-source and use that as the starting point. Most B2B customers are small businesses and once they build bespoke software that works with their business, they won’t need loads of tokens to keep it running.
surgical_fire 1 day ago|||
Can you share any of these many open source projects? I am curious about them.
theturtletalks 1 day ago||
Sure

fx0

https://github.com/vercel-labs/fx0

It’s by Vercel Labs, but it’s a small team and it’s basically a small website builder and even comes with 5 free prompts. I’m building on it to build a universal storefront

Moss Keeper

https://github.com/ChetasLua/moss-keeper

Someone who got early access to Fable 5.5 asked it to make an anime style video using html and it’s amazing. I might make a short film doing this one day.

Money Shot

https://github.com/SocialAcolyte/monet-shot

A sort of screen studio alternative with a twist

MailCheap

https://github.com/marclou/mailcheap

Opensource alternative to BeeHiv

These are my latest stats on Github: https://github.com/junaid33?tab=stars

aliasxneo 1 day ago|||
> I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+ when I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

B2B maybe? Usually these businesses thrive solely on flirting with the CTO and getting them to sign a lucrative contract and then mandate internal usage. I'm speaking from experience.

spoiler 1 day ago|||
I worked at a company where postman was (incorrectly) set up, used by everyone in the company, including non-devs and the ops team to make API requests instead of letting us develop tooling... Everyone hated it, but the company kept paying for it.

Hell, our CI test suite ran Postman, but because that was badly set up if a test suite failed, it required manually editing some state, otherwise the Postman state got fucked and everything would fail.

Did we still continue paying for it, you might wonder? Yes, of course we did.

drdexebtjl 1 day ago||||
Probably. They’ve been sending a lot of emails with creepy hyper-personalized AI-generated marketing material, trying to get us on an Enterprise contract. Things like slideshows that have the names and profile pictures of my colleagues who use Postman. Very weird.
aliasxneo 1 day ago||
This seems to be a trend now. I guess the dumbification is already started because I can't imagine a sane marketing person thinking this would generate positive leads. Unless they are targeting the same dumbified people.
Good4boothee 12 hours ago||||
> B2B maybe?

I hope their B2B income stream is amazing but last company I worked for banned them in entire organisation, after their push to store requests in the cloud. People split between older Postman versions - with auto-updater ripped out, using IntelliJ's build in http client, and few weirdos prefering SoapUI.

mrweasel 13 hours ago||||
Still $5B is insane, that would make Postman worth more than JetBlue. Airlines aren't exactly a good business to be in, but Postman is fairly easily replicated.
cute_boi 1 day ago||||
corruption at finest. There is no reason to use postman when hoppscotch or bruno is available.
radicalbyte 1 day ago|||
Oh THAT'S what they're trying. Doesn't work on me %)
alfanick 1 day ago|||
I cannot imagine 1500+ employees "working" on this. Wtf, it's a single person project.
aldanor 1 day ago|||
1 developer, 10 managers, 20 C-suite, 1468 sales, 1 barista

All adds up pretty well

martin_a 13 hours ago|||
For that amount of people, you should stock up on Baristi! I wouldn't want Espresso to be the bottleneck of an operation like this!
asimovDev 15 hours ago||||
They used to have a Kombucha sommelier but they were laid off in 2023
mrweasel 13 hours ago||
I can't even tell if you're joking or not.
dalmo3 1 day ago||||
And no one to deliver the mail?
PcChip 1 day ago||
surely they have a postman for that
baobabKoodaa 1 day ago||||
Still sounds much better than Oracle's employee composition!
SoleilAbsolu 1 day ago||
Well with a proverbial lawnmower at the top of the org chart, how many sets of weed-whackers, pruning shears, leafblowers, and RoundUp dispensers are below it?!
vincenthsin 17 hours ago||||
Probably it is true. This is the choice of capital.
MisterMunchkin 1 day ago||||
Don’t forget the community manager, people lead and chaplain.
MiroslavPokorny 20 hours ago||||
This is the modern capitalist model.

So many talkers making speeches and powerpoints and nothing else.

dominotw 1 day ago||||
they are going to annouce layoffs laying of that 1 developer
enbugger 1 day ago|||
[flagged]
strictnein 1 day ago|||
It's pretty clear they were making a joke.
sp527 1 day ago||||
It's both hilarious and telling that his jest was close enough to reality to provoke you into taking it so seriously.
embedding-shape 1 day ago||
I love how "1468 sales" was the outrageous part, not "1 developer, 10 managers, 20 C-suite" which came before it.
arvid-lind 1 day ago|||
That just added up to 1500, so maybe the "+" is another manager. No need to be so hasty.
Philip-J-Fry 1 day ago||||
To be fair Postman is a lot more than just a fancy curl client. It's a whole saas platform now.
bartread 1 day ago|||
> It's a whole saas platform now.

I think the argument may be that it doesn't justify this - that the main benefit of the SaaS platform has been to provide 1500+ people with something to do - and that perhaps the SaaS platform doesn't really add enough value to justify its existence or the company's valuation.

I don't really have a point of view on this since I've only used the browser extension (though I don't have it installed at present, thankfully) so the SaaS part of the business might be amazingly useful or it might not: I'm just laying out what I infer the argument in this sub-thread to be.

talon8635 1 day ago||
Well, I guess if people need things to do, and others are willing to pay, then what’s the problem?
jeremyjh 1 day ago||
TFA is the problem. There is no actual value proportional to their expenses, so the only path is enshittification and grifting.
boomlinde 1 day ago||||
To be fair, is there a good reason that it should be?
bdangubic 1 day ago||
was there a good reason for a search engine to provide email service? :)
dspillett 22 hours ago|||
If they can charge for it, why not? Search is an important part of mail for many users, so there is some cross-over in knowledge/experience that can be leveraged.

And assuming you mean Google, the question is based on a false premise. They were an advertising company years before gmail was introduced, and an ad-tech company being able to trawl your mail to find ways to advertise at you is a very different proposition to a search company releasing the same product.

bdangubic 20 hours ago||
> being able to trawl your mail to find ways to advertise at you…

much like POSTMAN can trawl through all my API calls to see what other business they make from all this data they are mining now, yes?

sumedh 14 hours ago|||
To provide personalized ads?
Keyframe 1 day ago||||
can it send email yet?
ako 1 day ago||
If you use an api?
ex-aws-dude 1 day ago|||
As someone who hasn't used it since like 8 years ago that reads like satire
kklisura 1 day ago|||
Wait till you hear Docusign has 7k employees...
colejohnson66 5 hours ago||
I've heard this and always wondered if most are related to compliance?
ayush--s 1 day ago|||
I logged in to postman today after 3 years to use some public API, and god, it was so damn unusable. It took me navigating through "workspace", "environments", etc etc before I could hit the simplest of http endpoints.
tisdadd 1 day ago|||
I switched to Bruno when payment started requiring login, love having the ability to just check it into git.
01CPMD3174 22 hours ago|||
Ah thanks for name dropping Bruno. I actually never found the Postman alternative I was looking for. Using wget is fine. It would be nice to have an interface with collections again. Will check out Bruno this weekend…
ehnto 16 hours ago|||
I also use Bruno and it's great. One amazing benefit it saves in human readable formats.

You can give an AI agent a documentation page and it will create the collection of routes pretty quickly in files you can commit to git.

martin_a 13 hours ago||
For me this is one of the biggest features/nice-to-haves! Just a folder with text files to define your environment that you can easily sync to other devices, backup, move to the next client...
aembleton 10 hours ago|||
Worth checking out Yaak too: https://yaak.app/

I can't remember why I settled on this over Bruno, but its much better than dealing with Postman.

nkjoep 13 hours ago|||
I had switched to Bruno as well. Unfortunately enshittyfication caught up also there.
01CPMD3174 22 hours ago|||
Exactly. Back in 2015 when I was still coding professionally Postman was our go-to tool for API testing.

Earlier this year I reached for Postman when kicking off a side project. I was appalled by how convoluted it has become. It really is a Frankenstein product. And they can’t seem to figure out what their offer really is.

No thanks. RIP to the OG Postman. The new Postman is dead to me.

vanschelven 1 day ago|||
Someone should vibe-code a VC death clock for developer tools. Enter a company, and it will deduce from its last funding round and headcount the moment it all goes to shit.

In an utlimate twist of irony such a tool could itself pivot to investors because the moment it gets really bad is also the moment to invest in the competition.

I'm not saying that's my strategy with Bugsink, but I'm not saying it isn't either.

peanut-walrus 1 day ago||
It exists: https://saasocalypse.com/scan
xpct 1 day ago|||
I must say, this style of UI has become really grating even for toy projects.
nekooooo 23 hours ago|||
the claudish here is almost unintelligible as well
jasomill 22 hours ago||||
I'm not sure why I'd trust a site that gives OpenAI and example.com equal marks as "already dead" because they're "vulnerable [...] to AI-native replacement" for anything but a laugh.
RugnirViking 10 hours ago||
it lists spotify at risk because it's just a music player and easy to replicate...
vanschelven 1 day ago|||
"Our models are busy right now. Please retry in a moment."

Hacker News (comment) hug of death? Or victim of its own punchline?

autoexec 1 day ago|||
> Instead they now have to justify their valuation by forcing logins, collecting data, monthly subscriptions, AI features, etc.

All those people who gave them millions in funding are expecting to make a return on that investment and that means prioritizing turning it into something that will make money by selling out users. The valuation is just a guess at how successful it will be at screwing users over. Greed ruins everything.

DrewADesign 1 day ago|||
> I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+

Because, current valuations are completely detached from any operational or market realities that affect a company. The metric has become the goal, and the metric is controlled by nontechnical people that have no intuitive understanding of how technical products are used. Even worse, they’ve all gone though a vibe coding tutorial and now either believe they have real technical depth, or believe that it doesn’t matter.

cowlevel 21 hours ago||
Technical is subordinate to business and always has been (apart from a bunch of last century hackers with university tenure). If business no longer thinks it can make money with human developers, they'll be laid off. It doesn't matter whether the product is better or worse.
DrewADesign 21 hours ago||
That’s business administration, which has nothing to do with the valuation process, anymore. A company could be run by some trust fund kid with no understanding of business that hired a full-time department of 10 people to repaint the lines in the parking lot every day, but if their story was impressive enough, their valuation could be astronomical. It’s all about vibes (in SV, at least.)
mikestew 1 day ago|||
I used to use Postman daily almost ten years ago. Then as my last hurrah before retirement, I took an embedded job that didn't involve me beating on a web API, so I didn't use Postman anymore.

So imagine that I hear about this "Postman" product that involves subscriptions, and AI, and "valued at $X billion" and all this crap, and you can see how I seriously thought that there was another product called "Postman" that wasn't the product I used to use. Turns out...

gloosx 6 hours ago|||
I was about to ask why on earth an HTTP client needs 1500 employees and a 5B valuation, but then I realized that perhaps it is just envy speaking.

Im simply envious that I dont own an AI-native cloud-first enterprise-grade zero-trust secure-by-design API lifecycle management ecosystem powered by agentic AI workflows autonomous coding agents pre built skills context graphs semantic knowledge retrieval augmented generation multi agent collaboration next generation developer productivity acceleration platform with a revolutionary cURL GUI client valued at 5 billion dollars with 1500 employees

pavlov 1 day ago|||
I haven’t met anyone using MongoDB in what feels like 12 years, but it’s a $26B company.

There’s apparently a surprisingly profitable enterprise afterlife to developer tools that manage to become popular in the right moment, even if the moment is fairly short.

pants2 1 day ago|||
Databases are extremely sticky because migrating can be a nightmare. Postman seems like it would be much less sticky, you can just import your Postman collection to Bruno and it's pretty much a drop-in replacement.
thepra 1 day ago|||
I feel called, mongodb user here ( • ▽ • ; )
cowlevel 21 hours ago||
Evaluate Postgres. It's a great jack-of-all-trades, as is the relational model in general.
writtenone 1 day ago|||
wrote about this phenomenon: https://nonograph.com/write-some-software-give-it-away-for-f...
ozim 1 day ago|||
You don’t know any developer yes.

I do know business analysts, testers, non-technical people asking me for postman collections.

Postman became de-facto standard for businesses. Even though devs have ditched it.

wrntluserstupid 18 hours ago||
How did we even get here? Apparently I can't convince anyone to use Jellyfin off of their main computer to their main smart tv, because "it's too hard" (too hard to double click and icon and select a folder?)

But we can somehow magically convince non-technicals to share cloud collections of endpoint requests to backend services.

ozim 16 hours ago||
They are getting paid for dealing with API’s. If they would rely on devs only they would be out.

Then postman made it easier for them to deal with something they have to do anyway.

pjmlp 1 day ago|||
Yeah, they managed to land on the IT blacklist for several of our customers.

Nowadays Portman is forbidden for project delivery, unless the customer development team also uses it.

orochimaaru 23 hours ago|||
I’ve never understood the allure of postman. Curl has been my thing for a while. I don’t see that changing.
jasomill 22 hours ago|||
If history has taught us anything, it's that there's at least a limited-time market for inferior GUI alternatives to nearly anything you can easily do from a command-line. Though to be fair, there's plenty of room for value-add over curl for web requests in terms of presentation where GUIs can work well: asset viewers, syntax highlighting, pretty printing, code folding, etc., especially if combined with interactive tools for decoding and deobfuscation that feed back into the viewer.

The obvious AI integration is reverse engineering tools, assuming the trend towards locking such things down doesn't continue.

And honestly, I worry less about people paying $29 for a GUI file renaming tool than I do about the same people copy/pasting LLM-generated shell snippets, given that LLMs will inevitably have trained on the existing corpus of shell scripts, many if not most of which contain potentially dangerous bugs, especially when used outside their intended context of known-trustworthy input.

sumedh 14 hours ago|||
Not everyone wants to deal with command line.

This feels like dropbox comment.

jfyi 1 day ago|||
A surprising number of developers I work with don't actually know how to use curl. Postman is ubiquitous among that crowd.
colejohnson66 1 day ago|||
That's just GUIs being easier to use than CLIs for most people. After all, that's why Postman got popular - it's a GUI to do curl without the CLI! Or Handbrake to avoid using ffmpeg. Or various "paint" applications to rotate images instead of using imagemagik.

The problem is that Postman decided to want to be a business and took VC money.

Ekaros 1 day ago||||
I know lot of bits with curl. But I find it always a pain to use. Fine for when you do scripting but I find command line pretty painful overall. So I understand want to use some other tool with better ergonomics.
bloaf 21 hours ago||||
I wrote a lot of python. Whenever I was working with an API, I'd just spin up a jupyter notebook and write out the calls I wanted to try out in a python notebook, once I had everything working, it was just a copy paste job into the codebase.

Using some kind of dedicated tool like postman always felt like a literal step backwards.

threetonesun 1 day ago|||
10 years ago I totally get that but these days there's plugins built into every IDE that can smooth over the annoyances of testing an API via curl without having to invoke paying for Postman and dealing with all of its nonsense.

Of course now that I said that today I'd probably just have Claude hit the API for me, or build a dashboard to test it, I really don't know how Postman continues to exist.

xnx 1 day ago|||
> I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+

Like statistics, 90% of valuations are totally made-up.

skrebbel 1 day ago|||
> Then for some reason they raised over $400M in funding and hired 1,500+ employees

Wtf!! how

richin13 1 day ago|||
For some reason, it is very popular in my country (Costa Rica). Every freelancer I’ve worked with only knows about postman It’s like it was very popular back in the day and people never got the memo there’s better options out there
coldtea 1 day ago|||
>It's a shame what happened to Postman. It started as an excellent little developer tool for testing APIs. Then for some reason they raised over $400M in funding and hired 1,500+ employees, for what should have been a tiny OSS/passion project like curl or little snitch. Instead they now have to justify their valuation by forcing logins, collecting data, monthly subscriptions, AI features, etc.

The good thing is that now takes about 2 days to replicate with an agent the parts that matter from their whole offering and tell them to go f themselves.

bonestamp2 1 day ago|||
> I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

I have no need for it, but there's one company I work with and all of their developers still use it. What do you do/recommend instead?

lillesvin 1 day ago|||
Not the person you asked, but Bruno <https://www.usebruno.com/> is a good alternative (so far).
ambicapter 1 day ago||
Definitely a "good" alternative.
ninju 1 day ago||||
https://insomnia.rest/features/api-debugging

or any of these

https://apisyouwonthate.com/blog/http-clients-alternatives-t...

jamie_ca 1 day ago|||
Insomnia has enshittified over the past few years too, its original author started https://yaak.app/ and it's pretty alright for most of my Postman-relevant use. Not as heavy on automation or API-documentation, but for testing endpoints it's been great.
irreverentmike 1 day ago|||
Hey thanks for sharing the APIs You Won't Hate Link! I'm one of the cofounders of the community. I've had a good time with Bruno, personally. Being git-enabled is a big plus.

If you've got other suggestions, I'd love to give them a look!

jordanbeiber 1 day ago||||
https://hurl.dev/
taco_emoji 1 day ago||||
I used to use it but then we added Swagger UI to our APIs so now there's no need.
anonreplier 1 day ago||||
There are loads of alternatives now, I use yaak, but you could just ask an agent to create one for you in 20 minutes
losvedir 21 hours ago||||
Claude.
efilife 1 day ago|||
I use Yaak
baud147258 1 day ago|||
We're using Postman at work (I think we have a subscription for 10 or 20 users), mostly when doing REST development and to share the API calls between people. Though I rarely have to use it so each time I'm so confused of between the collections, environment, vaults, variables...

Also if you have an alternative that's easier to use, I'm interested

quchen 1 day ago||
We switched to Bruno 2 years ago. Haven't used it much lately but it was a really good replacement at the time.
justincormack 1 day ago|||
They were valued at $5.6bn in 2021, in the ZIRP boom, and havent raised since. Unlikely they can raise at anything like that now.
agrippanux 1 day ago|||
Doesn't help that the core product is one of the easiest vibe-code prompts ever.
enbugger 1 day ago|||
It seems like cursed(blessed) niche? In search of alternatives couple of years ago, I'm stumbled upon Mockoon which looked really like a single person project. Now, judging by their webpage, I see they are going the same way
chrisweekly 21 hours ago|||
Yeah, Insomnia replaced Postman everywhere I've been.
reddalo 16 hours ago||
Bruno has now replaced Insomnia, because Insomnia also forces you to create a cloud account with them...
oliyoung 1 day ago|||
> I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

Its endemic in enterprise engineering/QA, for all the reasons we mourn its loss its big, and big is trusted in these circles

andy81 1 day ago||
That's momentum, not utility.

Any non-programmer can now copy-paste http requests from Dev Tools or a free-tier LLM for a better service than Postman.

New companies have no good reason to use Postman. Old ones can slowly migrate away.

pintxo 10 hours ago||
It can be very slow, people are migrating away from IBM for 40+ years now...
jrks11o 23 hours ago|||
They chased B2B revenue too hard, my work built internal alt in a few days that fits more appropriately with our orgs usecases earlier this year, Sad lol
krmmalik 1 day ago|||
>>>I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+ when I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore.

Just out of curiosity, what are developers using these days?

ddoolin 1 day ago|||
I personally use Bruno: https://www.usebruno.com
CrimsonRain 1 day ago||
They took VC too after saying they won't. They have 50+ employees for some weird reason instead of 5. Sigh
wiether 1 day ago||||
At work we use JetBrain's HTTP client: https://www.jetbrains.com/help/idea/http-client-in-product-c...

My IDE has always been for a lot more than coding, so even though most of the coding is now done in a terminal by an AI agent, I still spend many hours everyday in my IDE.

dspillett 22 hours ago||||
There are a couple of open source alternatives (though at least some of those have tried to go the way of Postman to some extent), just using curl directly, or we've rolled our own wrappers (personally, or team- or company-wide) for our specific use cases.
stock_toaster 1 day ago||||
rest-client[1] or httpyac[2].

1: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=humao.re...

2: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=anweber....

aenis 1 day ago||||
Claude, here are the api specs, see if they are up to date, build a client, make no mistakes. Unironically.
Chris2048 1 day ago|||
https://yaak.app/ prev: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43185836
liendolucas 1 day ago|||
Postman valued at 5 billon? WTF? I mean the IT industry lives in a fart cloud honestly. I really really think everything is just a little bit overvalued, isn't it?

People should be using curl + bash. It's a universal combination available almost everywhere.

rdtsc 1 day ago|||
I know right? I would think even $5M would be excessive. It’s interesting that with AI now anyone can throw something together like that within a few days. Investors are probably squeezing them pretty hard to get their returns back before anyone and their uncle can create their own postman.
mschuster91 1 day ago||||
> People should be using curl + bash. It's a universal combination available almost everywhere.

They should but Bash escaping/encoding is nasty and most terminals have a hard time using the mouse to reliably edit a cURL command, especially if the last command didn't do a final "\n" output. And it gets oh so tiring when the "copy cURL" command includes about 1000 bytes worth of Cookie headers full of analytics garbage.

That's why Postman became a thing in the first place.

dspillett 22 hours ago|||
> and most terminals have a hard time using the mouse to reliably edit a cURL command

This is true. Even though I'm not much of a mouse user for it, I tend to edit curl commands of much length in a text editor when I'm doing things by hand, then pasting into the terminal.

> especially if the last command didn't do a final "\n" output

Or if your prompt outputs something to stderr instead of stdout so it doesn't get counted when the shell is trying to position where you are in editing the stream. Ubuntu's default prompt under byobu is a pain for this when I move to a different machine and forget to carry my tweaks for that.

For the missing final \n I just hit [enter] an extra time, but getting round the stderr thing isn't quite that simple.

liendolucas 1 day ago|||
Yes, that's true. You can suffer a lot escaping things out, but is also a valuable lesson! Not promoting those extreme cases, but many many times a few simple curl calls can save your day.
surgical_fire 1 day ago||||
Personally, I replaced Postman years ago with IntelliJ's HTTP client. It is pretty good.
vlyan 1 day ago||
ditto.

the only time I'd tried postman I got SaaS vibes from it, and I'd seen enough SaaS slop by then.

SoftTalker 23 hours ago|||
curl and jq is all I've ever needed for working with http APIs and JSON responses.
davesque 22 hours ago|||
I always felt like Postman was just a waste of time next to simple bash helper scripts wrapping curl commands.
pmkary 16 hours ago|||
Why the fuck do they need 1,5000 employees???
MOARDONGZPLZ 1 day ago|||
Sales called me a couple weeks ago. I told them Postman had a bad reputation among developers and I wouldn’t be using it. The salesperson was just absolutely incredulous that anyone could feel this way. It was pretty funny. Maybe they’re drinking their own Kool Aid.
100111011111 23 hours ago|||
You're stating this on your combinator forums of all places. Do you know who owns and runs that company and their economic principles?
agilek 1 day ago|||
1500+ ppl? :-O
asdff 1 day ago|||
I feel the same way about docker. This things just running containers and yet its a billion dollar company.
imtringued 11 hours ago||
multi-OS desktop application with

cross-platform container virtualization

integrated single-node kubernetes orchestration

plus various services such as

global container image hosting

automated supply chain security

distributed cloud build system

production container runtime

collaborative development sandboxes

vs

a curl competitor

Yes, they're in the same league.

hkt 13 hours ago|||
I don't want to be a snob, but my recollection of postman is as a smell: it indicated somebody had such discomfort with the CLI that their abilities were ceilinged by it.

It is crazy what people manage to raise funds for.

darepublic 1 day ago|||
Yes a prime example of enshittification. You attract attention making something humble in scope but good.. but then it is compelled to become something much more. Same story with Coursera imo
phendrenad2 1 day ago|||
When was the last time you heard about a VC-backed company going out of business? They either go unicorn or they get frozen until another VC-funded company is large enough to absorb them and quietly absorb their lack of value. Postman is a big morsel but I guarantee some company is being lined up just perfectly to consume them.
Grimeton 1 day ago|||
Yeah. Curl the little side project:

https://xkcd.com/2347/

theturtletalks 1 day ago|||
Everything will be enshittified, it’s not a question of if but when. The incentives are simple, the stock ticker must go up.
_doctor_love 1 day ago|||
> a tiny OSS/passion project like curl

Um.

saghm 1 day ago||
I was looking to see if someone had posted a reaction to this part, because if no one had, I was going to! I don't disagree with the parent comment at all, but if curl is an example of a tiny project, I'm not sure what could possibly be considered large. It's literally the first example I'd give if asked for an example of an open source utility getting deployed on like, everything in the world.
_doctor_love 1 day ago|||
>* It's literally the first example I'd give if asked for an example of an open source utility getting deployed on like, everything in the world.*

SQLite would be another strong contender.

pants2 23 hours ago|||
[dead]
_s_a_m_ 12 hours ago|||
The natural progression of projects in the U.S. Capitalism eats up your country.
embedding-shape 1 day ago|||
> I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+ when I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

I think most people here on HN is within or close by the "Innovators" part of the "Technology adoption life cycle" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technology_adoption_life_cycle). When Postman hit mainstream, it was already bloated and ruined, and "Innovators" had already moved on to something else, but for Postman that's just the beginning, as they're in the "Early Majority" part, and still have a tail to ride, so investors and everyone else can extract all the value from the remaining s̶u̶c̶k̶e̶r̶s̶ users.

sneak 1 day ago|||
This is why the right to fork exists in open source licenses. It’s easier than ever now, too, thanks to LLMs. You might even be able to oneshot forking and removing the malware and rebranding and rebuilding f/oss crapware these days.

I’ve been considering setting up a nonprofit solely to do this and to republish things like Mattermost, Stats, Bitwarden, etc with the corporate antifeatures ripped out.

FuriouslyAdrift 1 day ago|||
Bruno. Open source base, runs locally, data remains on your infrastructure.

https://www.usebruno.com/

pull_my_finger 1 day ago|||
Bruno is not so dissimilar, unfortunately. See this long thread[1] about their "journey".

[1]: https://github.com/usebruno/bruno/discussions/269

FuriouslyAdrift 1 day ago||
Yeah I am aware fo the open source base with subscripton model they have. I hope it doesn't go the direction of N8N because that's a fuster cluck.
pixl97 1 day ago|||
Yep, this is what I moved to.
trueno 1 day ago||
[dead]
pxc 1 day ago|||
Postman has always been proprietary software, hasn't it?
sneak 1 day ago||
Oh, my mistake! I always assumed it was f/oss that slowly boiled the frog. Turns out it wouldn’t have been in the running for consideration in my daily use stack anyway.
mschuster91 1 day ago|||
> Then for some reason they raised over $400M in funding and hired 1,500+ employees

... what the fuck. Certainly explains things

> I still don't know how they're valued at $5B+ when I don't know a single developer who actually uses it anymore

Yep, one of them. I loved Postman but gone back to plain cURL and the dogshit that is IntelliJ's built-in HTTP request tool.

As for the question... easy. Markets can stay irrational for a very long time...

fapjacks 14 hours ago|||
From their website: "We're a global company headquartered in San Francisco—with offices in Bangalore (where the company was founded) and Japan—and distributed team members on multiple continents."

... for.... .... postman?

jameson 1 day ago|||
[dead]
postmannotlover 1 day ago||
EDIT: sorry, I was cranky. I just really don't like Postman/its UI/BS. To each his/her own.
bfbf 1 day ago||
Weird take. Just because you can use curl it doesn’t mean you can’t value a GUI to be able to store and manipulate requests quickly and view a formatted response body.

I use postman all the time to explore apis. Sure I could do it from the command line, but this is quicker and it saves my request payloads.

(Though now I’m obviously open to suggestions for better tools)

tempestrose 1 day ago|||
Get an older copy of fiddler.
syhol 1 day ago||||
[dead]
thisIsFiner 1 day ago||||
Weird take. I thought for myself about the problem and solved it rather than externalize such and end up locked into an increasingly abusive relationship.

Been using homegrown scripts designed around wget and curl, accessible as shell aliases so I save time never downloading Postman or developing muscle memory for it, yet can still explore APIs

There's an idea for a better tool; the one you patch right in to your workflow to avoid context switches to a GUI mental model; I just focus on computer generating data rather than color of the virtual captains chair

bfbf 1 day ago||
Not sure if you’re trolling but writing “homegrown scripts as shell aliases” is not faster than a gui. I totally agree Postman is enshittified, but when I just want to see a sample response for given input data, it does the job. Sure I’d like a more lightweight tool, but there’s no way I’m “context switching” to writing shell scripts when I just want to check a single endpoint. (I’d also wager than in many cases, opening a gui and hitting send on a pre-saved request is faster than using an llm too)

You can do what you like though, my original comment was against the gatekeeping and punching down. I don’t care one way or another what tool you use, but let’s not make people inferior because they aren’t using a TUI for everything.

thisIsFiner 1 day ago||
Borrowed your own rhetorical style as the fastest means to relate to you, text on a screen.

OP is all "here's my way" and you're all "weird take" where weird felt wielded like a pejorative relative to OP not using GUI for everything.

Didn't realize it was possible to attack someone with their own rhetorical style. Figured they'd be used to themselves by now.

Shorel 1 day ago|||
You can try www.APIKulture.com

It is basically that, also similar to Bruno but using 20 times less RAM.

primitivesuave 1 day ago||
Postman logs detailed information on every single API request you make through its tool, including query parameters. If you use the templating syntax `{{some_secret}}` to fill in a query parameter, it sends the actual secret content of `some_secret` to Postman's servers. If you disable outgoing network traffic to this logging endpoint, the entire app will stop working properly.

I discovered this when investigating whether Postman is HIPAA-compliant (it is not).

wackget 1 day ago||
That sounds all sorts of illegal, and all sorts of immoral.

Did you flag it / create an issue?

primitivesuave 1 day ago||
Yes - I wrote some public posts, and a Medium article which I forgot about until just now: https://anonymousdata.medium.com/postman-is-logging-all-your...

My main point was that I wouldn't want my secrets to ever be sent to Postman under any circumstance (or alternately, stop calling them "secret"). A lot of the online responses were some variation of "why are you sending secrets in query parameters in the first place?" (I'm not). When I posted on Reddit, it escalated to targeted harassment by people who were obviously current/former employees at Postman.

I did send out an email blast to a bunch of CIOs/CSOs in my network which went a bit "email viral" through forwarding, and this ended up triggering a substantial amount of enterprise cancellations.

lelandfe 19 hours ago||
> some variation of "why are you sending secrets in query parameters in the first place?" (I'm not)

The example from the blogpost: `http://localhost:4000/patient/{(SECRET}}`

Wherein the logger logs the final URL with the secret.

I think I agree with the masses? It strikes me as an odd place to put a secret.

But to your credit, they also... shouldn't be logging endpoints? Secrets or no. That's basically what this person said responding to your post: https://medium.com/@fsufitch/if-you-are-writing-this-off-as-...

> Postman is, in essence, "looking over your shoulder" and jotting down all URLs you query

gokulravi992 16 hours ago||
[flagged]
SamuelAdams 5 hours ago|||
You may want to check recent changes, as of May 2026 it is HIPAA compliant.

https://blog.postman.com/postman-is-hipaa-compliant/

MiroslavPokorny 20 hours ago|||
I am still dumbfounded what value Postman can make in capturing all the publics usage. Sure they could mine the data, but they cant exactly use it in any legal way so why bother ?
xlayn 22 hours ago||
github.com/alainnothere/mailBoy

news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50359814

senfiaj 1 day ago||
Who still uses Postman? In my experience it became insanely slow and bloated. Switched to Bruno. IMO, Postman is like uTorrent, everybody heard about it and many install because of inertia.
karthikeyankc 1 day ago||
Mostly enterprise teams and intermediate devs from my experience. I lead the API platform for a popular e-signature company, and a postman collection is the first thing devs ask for. Even when we point them to our docs, they'd rather just import a collection and start hitting endpoints immediately.

Haven't heard of Bruno until now. Looks like a solid offline-first tool. I don't see a public collection or web runner, and it looks like it supports GitHub-based sharing. Postman on the other hand, their public API network (or whatever they call it) along with the web runner reduce a lot of friction for API vendors like us and for dev teams who just want to quickly play with the API in the browser, especially during their evaluation stage.

zamalek 23 hours ago||
You commit your collection to git if you want to share it.
DuncanCoffee 1 day ago|||
Switched from Bruno to Voiden, it's more of a postman + notebook. Bruno started adding premium and stuff and I didn't want to wait to migrate again...
tommica 16 hours ago|||
Yeah, updated Bruno after a while, saw the premium stuff and immediately thought of Postman
karel-3d 11 hours ago|||
Bruno Premium is some enterprise nonsense. You don't need to use it.

Voiden also has premium enterprise plans.

https://voiden.md/enterprise

edit: ah there is no "enterprise plan" but you pay for the services. nice.

giancarlostoro 1 day ago|||
It was really good until... idk 3 or so years back? Whenever they started forcing you to login to use it.
mpern 17 hours ago|||
While not exactly an equivalent to Postman or Bruno, I really like the "http file with extras" approach of httpyac

https://httpyac.github.io/

Since it's all in plain text it's easy to share in a repo.

jvzv 1 day ago|||
bruno is really great used it for a while but the 5 API syncs a month on the free tier is a pain, had to switch to Apidog never been so happy with unlimited syncs
_fat_santa 1 day ago|||
I use hopscotch and highly recommend it. Very similar UI to postman and it just works.
andy81 23 hours ago|||
Bruno is no better in the way that matters - curl/requests/httpclient etc. are now easier to write and understand than any external templating tool.
shimman 23 hours ago|||
Use to work at one org in a bloated financial company that was paying Postman nearly $40,000 a month for a license provided to every person in the org. Regardless if they were a dev or not. I suspect the sales pitch pushes for unnecessary licenses because out of around 500 employees in the org, only 80 were developers and out of those 80 only one single team used postman. So this one org was overpaying by nearly >95%, doubt this org is truly unique regarding this.

I suspect that nearly every single public corporation are likely overpaying for software products, it's a waste of capital and extremely inefficient. All it shows is that corporations are too loose with their money and can probably deserve to get their tax obligations increased by a good 20-40% if they're this okay with wasting it.

ex-aws-dude 1 day ago|||
I'm not really a vibe-coder but it seems like the easiest possible tool to vibe-code

Or just give your agent JSON and tell it to use curl

snapetom 1 day ago||
It's one of those things that have become "enterprise." There's always been better competitors out there, but it was so big, it's the easy choice for companies that are too lazy to do proper/fast vetting.
bottombutton 1 day ago||
Working in healthcare, and Postman got decertified by our Cyber team for this. We all switched to Bruno overnight. Their sales team is pinging us like gangbusters though.
happytoexplain 1 day ago||
A lot of GxP environments had already ditched Postman because it auto-syncs your API schemas to their cloud, as well as values and secrets.
tonfreed 1 day ago||
Bruno is fantastic. Switched a while ago and haven't even thought about going back
rvz 1 day ago||
Bruno is VC backed [0] and will (eventually) do the exact same thing for the sake of growth.

This is even after they said they would never raise money, but again the users were not going to pay for Bruno nor donate even.

[0] https://blog.usebruno.com/the-funding-announcement-we-never-...

literallyroy 17 hours ago|||
Wrote a blog post [0] earlier this year about Bruno. Very funny they are really working there way down the todo list the creator claimed was a we’ll-never-do list. [0] https://royathan.com/blog/the-api-client-hunt/
happytoexplain 1 day ago|||
Aw, fuck.
nicce 22 hours ago|||
I will just keep using curl
troyvit 5 hours ago||
If you want to complicate your life just a little bit, there's hurl: https://hurl.dev/

The downside for me is that I have a filesystem littered with .hurl files and no real organization. But it's one step more organized than just curl.

waterTanuki 23 hours ago|||
FWIW Bruno can be forked unlike Postman. Not to mention, it would be trivial to vibe code something like this now. Postman absolutely deserves its downfall for trying to nickel and dime customers.
dham 1 day ago||
We went to bruno years ago and has been good. Nice to be able to store the request definitions in git. But to be honest, don't really need any of these tools anymore.
reddalo 1 day ago|
+1 for Bruno, it's simple and great.

They offer a paid version though, so I'm always afraid it's going to enshittify in the future, just like Postman and then Insomnia did.

CommonGuy 1 day ago||
I have been building Kreya [1] for over 6 years now as a Postman alternative. It's offline-first and privacy focused with a storage format made for git.

In all our years, Kreya "just worked" for our users without any drama or unwanted changes, unlike most of our competitors...

[1] https://kreya.app

daviddanielng 14 hours ago||
I downloaded 2days ago because I could not stand how postman was buggy and bloated, couldn't get it started.

It was stuck at

  daniel@Daniel-ThinkPad:~/Downloads$ ./Kreya-linux-x64.AppImage
(kreya:99500): Gtk-WARNING *: 09:39:54.893: Unknown key gtk-modules in /home/daniel/.config/gtk-4.0/settings.ini
CommonGuy 13 hours ago||
Sorry to hear that! That warning is unlikely the cause of the crash, it just means that some GKT3 settings are no longer supported in GTK4 and should be removed from the settings.ini, but they do not crash the app.

Please note that our AppImage does not include the required libgkt-4-1 and libwebkitgtk-6.0-4 dependencies. I just noticed that this is not documented, my bad! Installing them will probably fix your issue.

If not or if you have any other questions, you can write me at hello@kreya.app

FridgeSeal 20 hours ago||
Mad respect. Kreya is my go-to for playing GRPC endpoints. Basically every other tool has some whacky behaviour, got rapidly abandoned, or had janky ux.
georgel 1 day ago||
Postman went from a great lightweight tool to a bloated up-selling mess.
wolttam 1 day ago||
As do all great things once VC sinks its teeth in.
999900000999 1 day ago||
I know I’d also take 400 million in VC funding in hopes of eventually becoming a billionaire.

Vs making tools for donations and no one appreciating it!

bluefirebrand 1 day ago||
I'm really curious what difference to your lifestyle being a billionaire would be compared to 400 million

Maybe I'm just too small minded to imagine, but having that kind of money just seems so unnecessary to me

jmb99 18 hours ago|||
Raising $400M != having $400M personally.

Although, at that level of raise, I assume the ceo/founder(s) would probably be taking a least a few million, maybe $10M over the course of the raises + elapsed time?

There’s definitely a substantial difference between a net worth of $10M and a net worth of $100M. After that, I imagine most people wouldn’t really be able to tell the difference day to day.

ion_trapper 20 hours ago||||
Is someone who has $100k reasonable for wanting $1M? Sure, one would struggle to buy a nice house with only $100k. With $1M it is much easier.

Do you think someone who has only $100, whose only thought is how to pay for their next meal or rent check, might similarly wonder “what difference is there between $100k and $1M? They’re both very rich!”

Point is, ambition is like a gas, it tends to expand to the volume of its container. With $400M you have enough for your own and your family’s comfort forever. With $4B it’s less about lifestyle and more about shaping the world to your liking. You might not care about that if that’s 1000x away from where you are right now, but if it’s just 10x away, it becomes more tempting.

bluefirebrand 19 hours ago||
> You might not care about that if that’s 1000x away from where you are right now, but if it’s just 10x away, it becomes more tempting

Nah, it sounds sociopathic no matter what amount of money you have

ion_trapper 18 hours ago||
Next time don’t claim you are “really curious” for a perspective when your actual intent is to espouse moral superioirty.
bluefirebrand 17 hours ago||
There might have been an actual good reason to seek that much wealth beyond what an individual needs that I hadn't considered before

Controlling other people by "shaping the world to your desires" isn't what I was hoping to hear

program_whiz 10 hours ago||
What if you want $4B so you can finally end homelessness, or really contribute meaningfully to cancer research, or ending mortality? These are "shaping the world" that aren't possible for someone with a measly $10M, but might take billions to achieve, as well as aligning political actors (who require donations). "Shaping the world" doesn't have to be a bad thing, that's what we otherwise call "civic duty" when we try to shape the world with our votes.
999900000999 1 day ago|||
You can’t just take the VC money and run away.
shimman 23 hours ago||
Why not? It's not like VCs are gambling with their own money after all, they're okay to waste the money of pensioners but rarely, if ever, their own.
00deadbeef 8 hours ago|||
It's Electron, it was never lightweight
ivanjermakov 1 day ago||
I remember it being annoying to use even in 2019.
dvtkrlbs 1 day ago||
I've been using Yaak [1] for a while. It is a breath of fresh air.

[1] https://yaak.app/

chanux 14 hours ago||
Great job putting the list together.

I think https://httpie.io is also in the category (I have only used it in CLI form, long back. My use cases don't need anything more than curl)

dvtkrlbs 1 day ago|||
One nice thing about it is only the builds are licensed. If you build from source it is MIT.
gregrobson 1 day ago||
+1 for Yaak, I've used it for over a year for work and personal projects. It is stable and fast (also the dev behind it has the first name as me, so I'm a bit biased towards other Gregs!).
ediamondscience 1 day ago||
I don't understand how postman became the tool that it is today. The best version of it was just a logger and a formatter on top of an http client. The proto import was nice for gRPC. Who thought that relatively simple tool needed accounts and MCPs and whatever else they've thrown into it?
Havoc 1 day ago|
> I don't understand how postman became the tool that it is today.

You can’t have a unicorn valuation built on a simple offline client.

This is basically standard SV play book - first step is „fix“ it to have a cloud component/account. Then store some of the data in cloud only - say for example for team sharing or a „workspace“. Then make some features paid only. Then ramp up the enshitification till metrics show it’s saturated and users will bear no more

unkn0wn_root 1 day ago|
If anyone is interested in a Postman alternative but likes TUIs and leans more toward using .http files, check out resterm[0].

btw - I'm the author.

[0]https://github.com/unkn0wn-root/resterm

More comments...