Found a dashboard of ICLR 2027 review scores (built on OpenReview data). The scoring is 1 = strong reject, 4 = strong accept.

- 40,458 papers with ratings - 125,048 reviews - Mean paper score: 2.06 (super low!) - Median paper score: 2.00 - Top 25% cutoff: 2.33 - Top 10% cutoff: 2.67

For what it's worth, I had a paper with 2, 2, 4 and it's in the top 10%, which is wild.