Top
Best
New

Posted by casi 4 days ago

Why get an expensive Pi when I have an old phone?(so.long.thanks.fish)
482 points | 273 commentspage 6
walrus01 12 hours ago|
For me if I don't have a need for the GPIO pins, it's "why get an expensive pi when I can get a used ex-corporate small form factor quad core, intel core i7-something desktop PC with 16GB of RAM and a real SSD"... For like 150 bucks on eBay. RAM apocalypse and price of equipment has affected this a lot (these used to be like 90 bucks depending on era of core i7), but they're vastly more useful when a general purpose x86-64 linux is installed on them. Or even just put proxmox on it and then various things inside that.
stn_za 7 hours ago||
You are asking a meaningless question in order to promote, brag, justify and make public your own know-how having already accepted and understood whatever limitations in order to justify your own choice.

The point of a rasperri PI is to allow general, easy, and intentional bespoke availability of a fully programmable platform, where it also allows you access to low level, but practical means of acheiving home automation via GPIO etc.

I have 5 old phones in my cupboard, the most recent 3 of them have locked bootloaders and could potentially be rooted simply because of them not being region locked, while not gauranteeing me any real and complete support such as a PI would.

Nevermind even thinking as far ahead as GPIO pins etc etc.

At best, 1 out of the 5 phones might be able to eventually, and with effort/time and possible additional cost for extras give me parity to a PI, even exceeed the PI in compute.

But that is not the point. You know it. I know it.

Your post is not in search of an answer. You know the answer, you are the minority, and you know this.

You would not get an expensive PI if you had what you need from your old phone and skillz.

So why ask us where you already knew the answer...

It's because you are not asking anything, you are trying to show off and be dishonest by posing it as a question while assuming generousity by 'helping' people not 'waste money'

You are transparent buddy.

Yep, the typos are understood and left as is. Does nothing to take away my meaning.

ForHackernews 9 hours ago||
Similarly, you can get old thin clients for $10 - 30 off ebay that are equivalent or more powerful than a Raspberry Pi, if you don't need GPIO.

https://www.parkytowers.me.uk/thin/

babodabo 10 hours ago||
Pi's are expensive trash
Jemm 10 hours ago||
Is there a project that can handle GPIO from a USB port? To me that and a generalized linux distro for phones is would be the compelling switch.
pbalau 10 hours ago|
adafruit ft232h and probably others
luqtas 8 hours ago||
wouldn't an esp32 or rp2040 be a better solution that also has ADC? also cheaper then the adafruit board you mentioned
pbalau 4 hours ago||
> adafruit ft232h and *probably others*
interludead 11 hours ago||
I've always found it a bit absurd that an old phone can have more sensors and connectivity than a fairly expensive hobbyist computer, yet we rarely consider using it as one
classified 13 hours ago||
As long as it's not an iPhone. Once Apple has bricked your old iPhone, you can't even run your own software on it anymore. Despite all their lip service to being environmentally friendly, that thing is nothing but an expensive paperweight and e-waste now.
b112 13 hours ago||
A Pi is the Apple of small compute. It's the in thing, flashy, with loads of just as capable competitors.

No one cares if you have overpriced white earbuds or not for Pi tasks.

windex 13 hours ago|
Everything including compete is priced sky high these days.
b112 13 hours ago||
And some higher than that, like the Pi, which has been overpriced for years.
ThrowawayTestr 13 hours ago||
Is there a peripheral you can plug into the USB port that exposes gpio pins?
cowlevel 13 hours ago||
Yes, USB to GPIO adapters are available. Note that you won't be able to implement anything that has timing requirements - you'll need a microcontroller for that.

I think in practice the timing jitter and the low cost difference to something like an Arduino Nano or Pi Pico means people use one of those even if they could technically use a GPIO adapter.

siknad 13 hours ago|||
Any dev board like Arduino can work. E.g. by flashing firmware that controls GPIO via Serial.
P-Nuts 12 hours ago||
Look at the FT232H. Does SPI, I²C, UART, JTAG, and GPIO. It’s just a chip but there are hobbyist breakout boards for it.
esafak 7 hours ago|
Pis jumped the shark long ago. Let them try to hawk it to whomever they please; I ain't bitin'
More comments...