Top
Best
New

Posted by donohoe 7 hours ago

New Evidence Shows School Phone Bans Are Gradually Improving Test Scores(www.nytimes.com)
944 points | 474 commentspage 4
jimnotgym 4 hours ago|
If they allowed phones into the test, those test scores would improve even more.

I'm hoping that the study authors framed the question more rigorously than the headline writers.

hypfer 6 hours ago||
I remember using early smartphones to hang out in IRC, Jabber etc with people that vibed a lot better than what was available on-site.

Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.

But I suppose it makes sense. The majority absolutely got their brain fried by the products SV (read: HN) built and we need to protect the majority.

I wonder what the next generation of misfit kids will come up with. Or maybe we will create school environments that work for all kinds of people? Nah. Of course not.

JshWright 6 hours ago||
As the parent of a (second generation) "misfit" kid, the kids are doing fine, in my opinion.

In the narrow slice of the world I have visibility into, it does genuinely seem like school culture is significantly more accepting of a wider range of folks. While I can obviously only speak to my suburban/rural school district in Central New York, I do have the interesting viewpoint of watching my kid attend the same school I did 25-30 years ago. One thing I can say with 100% certainty is that I would have been bullied mercilessly if I showed up in the same way they do today, but they have an active social life and participate in several active social circles that would not have been available to me.

I do think your "us vs them" mentality (i.e. "the majority got their brain fried" as if you are somehow superior and no susceptible to outside influence) is as much a part of the problem as the school environments you seek to blame.

As the part of three kids in 5th through 9th grade, the phone ban is an unqualified good, in my opinion.

hypfer 6 hours ago||
[flagged]
JshWright 5 hours ago||
Could you clarify which part of my comment was an "insult"?

I appreciate the deep dive into my profile, you're definitely correct that I don't use GitHub much.

Personally I think having three kids in middle/high school is probably a bit more relevant to my "authority" than my choice of code repository for personal projects, but I'd be interested to hear more about why you think that's relevant?

Do you have any reflections on the actual experiences I shared in my original comment?

hypfer 5 hours ago||
No one was talking about your kids. Your kids' experience is valid input

I've quoted the problematic statement in my previous reply.

I am not interested in engaging with you any further, given that this is just classic sea lioning.

JshWright 5 hours ago||
Well, you're the one who brought up "invalidation". You are attempting to invalidate my original comment, which is based on my experiences as a parent, by pointing out I don't use GitHub. I'm just curious how that connects back to the original point...
hypfer 5 hours ago||
Don't throw punches when your foundation is as weak as it is is my point.

Don't throw punches in general, as that is.. well. not very nice. But definitely do not throw them if reality is how it is.

There are valid thoughts clustering around the idea of how a negative bias can also lead to negative outcomes. But that's not what you said. And that is also not what the goal of the communication was.

The goal of the communication was to protect the system. That might be conscious or subconscious but it doesn't really matter.

andelink 4 hours ago||
What are you going on about? I see nothing even remotely resembling “punches” being thrown by JshWright
chneu 5 hours ago|||
>Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.

How about people learn to work with the people around them instead of running away to online communities?

Online communities are not all positive. They can bring many negatives, many of which are phrased as positives because they make people feel good whole atrophying or deskilling them.

hypfer 5 hours ago||
I mean this reads genuinely ignorant, but falsely pretending it's good faith, at the very least, "learning to work with what is there" is quite resource-intensive, and with that could be seen as an unfair disadvantage for a certain type of kid.

Because they're not just busy doing homework and assignments and all but also have to juggle a much higher mental load on top.

The internet and internet communities are no silver bullet either, but "well just don't do that" is not doing the valid needs of various members of society justice.

___

It might be easier to empathize with the whole problem cluster if you view the problem like you view people with physical disabilities. Those too don't get told "well just fit in, lol", but have support systems in place.

"Nachteilsausgleich" is a very german term that comes to mind there.

Of course, it's not the same. But it helps for the mental model.

The correct solution wouldn't be the internet but - as I said - "school environments that work for all kinds of people", but - also as I said - I do not see that happening any time soon.

Maybe selectively in some schools due to some teachers making it their personal mission but certainly not on a systemic level. It is however a systemic issue.

spiresofagartha 6 hours ago|||
honestly, i see it as a good thing if not everyone does it. i was one of the only 'online' kids back in my school time and i liked being able to get the phone and talk to my friends when i was bored, but if everyone does that, no one will talk face to face
n0on3 5 hours ago||
They will be fine, and imho better for it. They’ll still do whatever they chose after school, but this way they’ll also learn how to deal with people that are not exactly a choice and they’ll have space to get a bit bored and, you know, think.
mmooss 1 hour ago||
Are you still using your phone all day? You think it's just the kids?
groundzeros2015 3 hours ago||
Impossible to establish causality here.
aczerepinski 3 hours ago||
This is a good start. Now do Chromebooks.
livinglist 1 hour ago||
Growing up in China we were not allowed to have phones in classrooms, although we still came up with ways to bring and use it at risk of being confiscated by our teachers. Bringing an extra fake model phone was one of the ways. Fun times.
TacticalCoder 6 hours ago||
Definitely banned at my kid's school: not only the phones go into a locked locker at the beginning of the day but in addition to that if the phone even rings (phonecall, alarm, anything), it's a warning. First warning: phone is confiscated and moved outside the locker and the kid has to go pick it at the end of day and explain what happened. Second warning: parents have to come get it. Third warning: kids cannot, ever, take a phone to school.

My daughter got a first warning and a few days later I received a letter citing a law article (about how phones cannot be used during school hours).

It's great IMO.

codingdave 6 hours ago||
That doesn't add up - not only because phone usage is a question for district policy, not law. But also because someone else calling your phone is not your fault.
jvvw 5 hours ago|||
It depends on the country whether it is law or not, I would imagine.
DocTomoe 5 hours ago||
I would imagine that any such law would be in violation to FCC rules interfering with lawful use of the radio spectrum.
Apreche 5 hours ago||||
It is your fault. You should have turned your phone completely off before putting it in the locker.
wat10000 4 hours ago||||
Someone else calling your phone is not your fault. Your phone ringing is 100% your fault.
buellerbueller 5 hours ago||||
Leaving your phone on while it shouldn't be, however, is your fault.
bcrosby95 5 hours ago|||
...turn it off?
Aerroon 6 hours ago||
You think it's great that if somebody calls your daughter's phone that you can get into legal trouble (fined) over it?
charlesabarnes 6 hours ago||
If the parent is allowing the student to bring a disruptive device to school, they are entrusting the student to responsibly silent or turn off their phone.

If the risk of fine helps the parent reevaluate the trust, I personally don't see the harm

Reubachi 5 hours ago|||
Like anything else, the intentions are probably altruistic, and this discussion is probably missing context. But your last sentence is saying "I am OK with leaving the legal repercussions of my child up to a vague number of untrained people, as a risk-reward tradeoff of giving my child a way to contact me."

how many staff/positions are required to monitor these devices and their "law-breaking" offenses, which thus are (according to OP of this chain) to be reported/acted on?

What staff is further respnsible for parsing out whether or not an "alert" was something the child had no control over? IE; a weather warning or amber alert.

charlesabarnes 3 hours ago||
School staff is usually not untrained when it comes to this topic. Usually implementation of these rules at schools include many hours of direct instruction and supplemental instruction throughout the year. The state's implementation of the laws vary state-to-state as far as staffing requirements.

A child needing to contact their parent during the school day is not a new or abnormal occurrence, what is new and abnormal is the parental desire to have a cell phone with them all day. In my observation, this desire wasn't really there before the events of 2020

Aerroon 5 hours ago|||
How is a phone ringing inside a box in a room on the other side of the building disruptive?

The phone is taken away from their possession it means that they must make sure they don't make a mistake before handing it over. Even if they remember afterwards they can't fix the mistake. Considering kids go to school on thousands of occasions that's a pretty low tolerance for mistakes.

I've forgotten something when leaving home more than 3 times over the duration of the previous 12 years. I guess other people are just better than me and don't ever forget anything.

bcrosby95 5 hours ago|||
You're making assumptions about the location of these lockers.

At my kid's middle school they're literally in the library.

charlesabarnes 3 hours ago|||
These rules are not just applied to high/secondary schools. This is also a problem with elementary schools as well which has lockers/cubbies located in the classroom.

Also, kids aren't dumb. They know how to follow rules once the expectations are in place. The idea is to leave the phones at home entirely, allowing them in the locker to accommodate for the edge cases is a concession that has tradeoffs for the child's parent.

miika 5 hours ago||
If work places would ban phones from toilets, I wonder why much that would improve productivity :) I bet people spend way more time in toilets now comparing to 20 years ago.
atleastoptimal 4 hours ago||
Least surprising result ever
andai 3 hours ago|
I remember my reaction to seeing an iPhone in school. It must have been 2010.

"Oh. This thing is designed to make you retarded."

More comments...