Posted by bookofjoe 2 days ago
This section seems like a misunderstanding of how taxonomies work. Does a book about the architecture in SF's Castro neighborhood belong in History or LGBT or Architecture?
But even in the history of paper catalogs books would often have secondary indexes in other parts of the taxonomy. Instead of walking the Dewey Decimal Numbers directly in the stacks you might walk to a card catalog that itself was organized by Dewey Decimal number, scroll through that and find a reference card to that book that would say "See this other Dewey Decimal number for this book in the stacks". (Computerized catalogs make secondary indexes even more common, obviously.)
The Dewey Decimal taxonomy was never "total" or perfect, it was just often "well indexed", for paper versions of good indexing.
Like Verbatim Books, where staff can instantly determine if a book is in stock, and go straight to the exact location where it is shelved.
Or, DG Wills, which has an incredible collection, and where the staff will show you to a general section of a room, and say "If we have it, it should be somewhere around here" 8-/
Two rows of books on each shelf (one behind the other!), and you'll be on your knees, with your face next to the floor, trying to go through those books on the bottom shelves.
Bookstore organization varies widely. Dewey Decimal and Library of Congress filing systems were developed to overcome the ambiguity.
Unless they're trying to recover that $195M bond by selling $8 lattes to wandering readers, I don't think abandoning Dewey decimal is a good idea.
I wish someone would index and organize the books at DG Wills, they have some truly great books in the collection, if you can find them...
In a personal collection you're not trying to find an arbitrary volume by author or contents you're looking for a specific physical object you've handled before. "Get within three feet and then look for what it looks like" beats nearly every system at that scale. I learned this from a librarian, who organized their personal library by color as well.
I enjoyed imagining it as an older library with a card catalog system and providing decimal numbers based on cover/spine colors. (Pantone numbers post-date the imaginary date I had in mind for the creation of the library so the story involves a more ad hoc system.) The paper card catalog would even include swatches of color to help navigate.
It's no worse a system than Dewey Decimal in terms of looking up specific books [1]. It's just worse at browsing a given stack and finding meaningful connections between books, but that was a feature rather than a bug in my fictional library, for reasons explained in the story. (To maybe spoil it, the short answer: Many of the books were problematic and you don't want grouped together next to each other for fear of giving them a weight they don't deserve.)
[0] https://blog.worldmaker.net/2023/11/16/prismatic-decimal-sys...
[1] And arguably better in some regards because for instance Fiction books generally have spine colors, but never have Dewey Decimal numbers.
Somehow I don't believe you. Organizing your books by color means splitting up series. Who's going to do that?
If no one would do something for the very obvious reason I'm not suggesting that you should do the thing no one would do. Only on this site do people go so far out of their way to find a reading of a comment that makes no sense whatsoever.
New Shiny Thing! messaging drawing a crowd that will eventually realize it's still books. Just a new sorting model.