Top
Best
New

Posted by ritzaco 5 hours ago

Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong Place to Fight Piracy(techstackups.com)
380 points | 114 comments
trentnix 3 hours ago|
Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.
squarefoot 1 minute ago||
Agreed that DNS isn't the place to act, but "prosecute pirates" too can be weaponized in so many ways. Today is a soccer match, tomorrow will be a Freudian slip during a live interview a politician or other prominent figure doesn't want to spread for more people to watch.
bluecalm 2 hours ago|||
Yeah but "prosecute pirates" is not feasible because a lot/most of them are located in jurisdictions that won't cooperate (Russia, China to name two). We could shut down Internet access to them until they cooperate but that has a lot of other negative consequences and it seems piracy is a small price to pay in comparison.
cowlevel 2 hours ago|||
If they want to shut down Russian internet they should do that instead of beating around the bush.
icantevenhold 1 hour ago||
Who is “they”?
contubernio 40 minutes ago|||
I don't know if it is accurate or not but the quad9 statement takes some trouble to indicate that much pirate hosting is based in Europe.
dolmen 34 minutes ago||
Russia is not in EU, but part of the territory is in Europe.
locknitpicker 2 hours ago|||
> Every attempt to “fight piracy” that isn’t “prosecute pirates” is just a backdoor to suppressing speech a government doesn’t like.

I'm afraid this has nothing to do with "suppressing speech" cliches. This is more straight forward than that: a judicial system is enforcing rules that are in place to benefit corporations even at the expense of everyone.

It just so happens that once the infrastructure is in place, it can be abused for other purposes.

trentnix 1 hour ago||
> This is more straight forward than that: a judicial system is enforcing rules that are in place to benefit corporations even at the expense of everyone.

To my eyes, that's precisely the government suppressing speech it doesn't like. Speech is so much more than just the modern political moment.

xhkkffbf 2 hours ago|||
This is well said. Too many people want to wink and let the pirates off easy. But that just encourages more piracy and harsher measures. If we want artists to be able to earn their living with their art, we need to give them the ability to be treated fairly by the public.
dolmen 23 minutes ago|||
> If we want artists to be able to earn their living with their art, we need to give them the ability to be treated fairly by the public.

It appears that nowadays the front of the fight toward content censorship is in the live sports domain, ahead of music and movie industries. Artist were much less directly involved anyway than the companies exploiting their author rights.

Also, digital artists are now pushed out by AI.

ronsor 2 hours ago||||
Perhaps copyright law should start treating the public more fairly first?

Piracy is mostly a self-created issue nowadays.

ajjahs 2 hours ago|||
you can argue that stealing from Disney for example is more ethical then paying them
bigstrat2003 1 hour ago||
You can argue it, but you'd be wrong. If we grant for the sake of argument that it's unethical to pay Disney, then the ethical action is to not consume their content. "I still want this, but don't want to pay for it" is not an ethical stance.
DocTomoe 54 minutes ago|||
I think after several 'lex Micky Mouse', that argument doesn't hold much ground anymore. Unjust laws must never be followed.
nvme0n1p1 46 minutes ago|||
[dead]
criddell 3 hours ago||
That sounds nice, but it isn't correct. A lot of piracy fights are civil in nature. If you sue somebody for infringing on your rights, you probably aren't trying to suppress speech.

When Quad9 fails to resolve malware and phishing sites without trying to get the bad guys punished, they aren't a tool of the government.

Are there some examples where a piracy prosecution was clearly trying to suppress speech?

dolmen 17 minutes ago|||
The civil orders make ISP and DNS resolvers build techincal infrastructure for enabling censorship. Same for filtering access to content based on users age that require deanonymizing users.

This just opens the door for content censorship applied to other domains when governments shifts for the worse, beyond live sports or music/movies as the technical infrastructure is now deployed.

badlibrarian 34 minutes ago|||
Mainly as counterexamples. A federal judge decided that Diebold used DMCA “as a sword to suppress publication of embarrassing content” and held it liable for knowingly misrepresenting infringement (2003). Another judge decided that Scientology's primary motivation was to "stifle criticism and harass its critics" (1995).
michael-sumner 4 hours ago||
https://quad9.net/news/blog/au-revoir-france/

https://blog.cloudflare.com/quad9-withdrawal-from-france/

skrebbel 1 hour ago||
Is this a ridiculous decision by the French court because the judges lack competency, or is this a defensible position, ie judges correctly interpreting a ridiculous law?

I feel like that’s two very different situations and a lot of writing about bad court decisions such as this one don’t specify which it is. The courts don’t operate in a void, they try to apply the law.

So in other words, should our ire be directed at the courts or the lawmakers here?

dolmen 12 minutes ago||
The judge just applies the law which leaves implementation detail to the courts.

The main problem is the law that opens the door to wide scale censorship. The people to blame are representatives who voted the law, not the judges.

rdtsc 35 minutes ago||
> Is this a ridiculous decision by the French court because the judges lack competency, or is this a defensible position, ie judges correctly interpreting a ridiculous law?

That's the thing, is there anyone who can disqualify an incompetent judge? Seems like there should be a process. It's like having a surgeon who doesn't understand basic anatomy in charge of performing surgery ("what's this squishy bit here, let's remove it, doesn't seem important").

skrebbel 15 minutes ago||
No but I mean, which of the two is the case here? Is this like your surgeon removing a random squishy bit, or is this a competent decision about a stupid law?

I'm not asking how to disqualify the judges, I'm asking whether we should want to. It's easy to point the finger at the courts here, cause they made the decision, but if French law leaves no wiggle room then it's not the judges' fault.

Fe2O3 4 hours ago||
Dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50195959

Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994

8by3 4 hours ago||
Not a dupe as its an opinion piece by someone else, somewhat hilariously named

AL Smith, https://techstackups.com/authors/alsmith/

But the sites font looks like AI Smith, which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI before looking up the authors bio.

peri-cl 4 hours ago|||
> "which I assumed was a cheeky way to say it was written by AI"

Well, it is written by AI. It's egregious.

ritzaco 4 hours ago|||
yeah sorry this was an AI summary; I do find them useful for stuff like this when the information is all out there already but scattered in different places, but wasn't expecting it to get to front page!

Al(ice|en) Smith is indeed my agent and a reference to AI/Al looking similar in some fonts and agent smith from the matrix.

tfrancisl 3 hours ago||
Why upload it to HN at all? If you didnt bother writing it, and seemingly didnt bother reading it, seems pretty irresponsible to just post like this.
cowlevel 3 hours ago|||
You get benefits, like karma, and a small chance of a job interview.
ritzaco 2 hours ago||||
I read it, found it interesting, and posted it, fully expecting it to get 0 upvotes like most other stuff we make (human written, AI-assisted, and AI generated).

I would never post something without reading it. I know some people hate AI just because it's AI. Personally I found this one interesting after reading so I don't really care how it was made. I do agree the AI cliches are annoying, but so are typos / bad grammar and that doesn't stop me enjoying stuff if the substance is there, which I think it is here.

A get the AI to write a lot of drafts, and most of them I discard, this one I let through.

But of course HN has good tools for people to flag or not upvote if they disagree. In this case, it seems like others found it interesting too

LeBit 4 hours ago||
It is not a dupe
rileymat2 4 hours ago||
One thing is not well explained, if they can’t reliably detect french users, how can they leave france?
jeremyjh 3 hours ago||
It mostly means having no legal entity or property in France that French courts can render judgments on. So they will geoblock as a basic compliance measure that doesn’t fully work but they avoid exposure by staying out of France.
jacquesm 3 hours ago|||
They're Swiss (Zurich HQ), there is a lot of reciprocity between Switzerland and France when it comes to legal affairs, and one day Switzerland may want to join the EU so this isn't all that clear cut.
fanwood 2 hours ago|||
Living in Switzerland, I don't see the country joining the EU anytime soon if ever
jacquesm 2 hours ago|||
Ever is a really long time. Sweden and Finland also never wanted to join NATO.
voxl 1 hour ago||
The EU might not exist if you're working "ever" time scale.
jacquesm 1 hour ago||
But it does. And Sweden and Finland did join NATO. All it takes is for the right circumstances to come about. Interestingly, the EU still survives (for now) in spite of lots of money and effort spent to try to break it up even further.
voxl 1 hour ago||
Using what is and what happened as an excuse to prefer one future over the other is not a good way to make decisions about the future, is my point. You clearly have a preferred future, but that doesn't mean anything. You have no evidence your future is more likely than Sweden never joining the EU
jacquesm 1 hour ago||
What makes you think I have a preferred future?
Grombobulous 2 hours ago||||
You don't have to be in the EU to have enforcement reciprocity with EU states.
KellyCriterion 2 hours ago|||
You will, forcibly. Not today, but in the future.

I know, there is a lot of debate ongoing between the opponents. But you have one big rock around your neck:

UBS

And Im pretty sure, somewhen in the future, a bailout will be required - and this could be done then only with EZB, as SNB is too small, and you will "happily" join. (and in that moment, there wont be any "international" white knights from abroad other than the EU/EZB, so you will be on board ;-)

mdasen 3 hours ago||||
I think it's partly about risk and what will get a prosecutor off your back and what a court might say "c'mon, they've done enough."

By geoblocking users in France, they've probably blocked at least 95% of French users from being able to access their services, if not closer to 99%. By not having any nexus in France, it does reduce their exposure. Yes, Switzerland and France might cooperate on things, but going after Quad9 via Switzerland would involve convincing Swiss authorities that a) France is correct enough that Switzerland should want to comply, b) the steps Quad9 has taken aren't enough, c) France should get to enforce this against a company that's completely extra-territorial.

Yes, Switzerland could still side with France, but it definitely makes France's job a lot harder. Even within a country, people often "forum shop" for a district or judge they think will be more favorable. Forcing France to get the Swiss to agree means getting a second party to also be so strict (or want to cave for diplomatic reasons).

As you say, it's definitely not clear cut. It does make it harder. It does reduce their risk. It makes it more likely that France will just declare victory and move on. Sometimes it's about making it not worth the fight. Would a French prosecutor's career be better served trying to get Switzerland to agree to essentially enforce French law worldwide against a non-profit? Especially when they are geoblocking most French users already - basically complying with the ruling as much as technology realistically allows? I think they'd probably find that their efforts would be better spent elsewhere. If Quad9 were still serving DNS queries from France, a prosecutor would have a much stronger reason to go after them in Switzerland. At this point, it just feels like a prosecutor would see it as a waste of time - like worrying about the cost of an array offset in a loop when you're doing a network call every loop, the network call's cost is just going to be so much greater and you should be spending your time on what matters. That said, people aren't always rational.

It doesn't get them in the clear for certain, but I think it does reduce the risk substantially.

jeremyjh 2 hours ago||
There is no prosecutor, these are not matters of criminal law. These are civil cases. Under the Lugano Convention, Canal+ can ask Swiss courts to enforce French judgements. That is why they can't just ignore this order. The question would become, after they geoblock but French people use VPNs to continue to resolve these domains, can Canal+ get a Swiss court to give even a single solitary fuck about this crap French law? I'm skeptical and I think its unlikely they'll pursue it that far.
zephyrthenoble 3 hours ago|||
No offense, but if you know any Swiss, you would know that's unlikely
jacquesm 3 hours ago||
I know plenty of Swiss. Some of them are really happy being 'inside but outside' and others would see Switzerland as a model of how the EU could function if they set their mind to it but they realize this will not happen from the outside. But there are many areas where Switzerland and the EU are currently not very compatible. Time will tell, I think in the very long term it is inevitable, in my lifetime rather not. Even so, for practical things like legal issues like the one we are discussing I would not be surprised if a Swiss court was sympathetic. It is called the "Berne Convention" after all...
senorrib 2 hours ago||
I'd wager a 1000:1 that Switzerland doesn't join the EU in our lifetime.
carllerche 2 hours ago||
I would take that wager! $1000 says Switzerland joins the EU before I die.
mytailorisrich 2 hours ago|||
That actually illustrates something about online services. Often (if not most of the time) companies develop them without considering at all that they must still be able to abide by the national laws of each and every country their users/customers reside in... and that's hard. So when something happens the simple option is to geoblock the country.
jeremyjh 1 hour ago|||
That isn’t necessarily the case though. The only countries they MUST consider are ones with civil judgement treaties like the Lugano agreement that applies here. They don’t have to care about laws in Iran or Russia unless they have entities or assets there.
mytailorisrich 54 minutes ago||
Ultimately it is a commercial and risk (commercial, legal, "bad outcomes") assessment. Even if in principle you should care about all the countries your service is accessible from, in practice you probably mostly care about countries that can come after you one way or another if you rub them the wrong way and countries where you have a non-negligible customer base (because countries can also block you and you lose business).

In the case of DNS, if you must customise by country it is probably not viable. So IMHO a unique global DNS service ultimately only "works" if countries don't care about it. As soon as they care the s hits the fan.

cowlevel 2 hours ago|||
Isn't that the obvious thing to do
Charmunk 3 hours ago|||
Was wondering this to. The article explains why geoblocking France IP's isn't sufficient, then goes on to talk about how it will stop working for French users, without explaining how they do that other then based on IP
burnte 1 hour ago|||
This way the French authorities have a much harder time holding Q9 liable for problems since they'll have no legal nexus within France. They won't be able to block all French users, but they won't get in trouble either.
nonethewiser 3 hours ago||
Could Quad9 still get fined because they inevitably will handle French traffic sometimes?
bruce343434 4 hours ago||
A self hosted recursive resolver fixes this. Have the courts take it up with ICANN
smolder 3 hours ago|
Better yet, let's vote to keep people out of office who have stupid ideas like battling ICANN.
cowlevel 3 hours ago||
Better yet, let's vote politicians out of office and vote ICANN out of power too. They are not any better, e.g. they make money by spamming the root zone with gTLDs. Don't know who you'd replace it with - OpenNIC is just as bad.
qalmakka 3 hours ago||
One thing that drives me nuts is that your average European Government (look at Italy or France) is absolutely open to implementing draconian laws with borderline authoritarian censorship in order to save the profits of football leagues. It's absolute madness, and it's a reflection of the corruption and how football got too big and too powerful in Europe.

There's nothing bad with football, but having it take >90% of all sport revenues and mindshare is unhealthy

pragma_x 2 hours ago|
I don't have the context here. Is FIFA learning bad media-licensing habits from the NFL or something?
debugnik 1 hour ago|||
Spain for example has granted La Liga and Movistar the right to demand ISPs block any IPs they ask for during matches, even if those IPs are reverse proxies shared with many unrelated websites and even services like Docker Hub.

So far, no one I know who pirates matches has run out of options to watch them, but us who don't care have to use VPNs to keep using the web as usual.

warkdarrior 2 minutes ago||
> no one I know who pirates matches has run out of options to watch them, but us who don't care have to use VPNs to keep using the web as usual.

Using VPNs is a small price to pay to help your fellow Internet users.

asdff 1 hour ago|||
The real orwellian org is actually probably La Liga.
kindkang2024 1 hour ago||
Unaffordable costs for Quad9, or fighting for justice at the expense of others' deaths...

They seem to share a common pattern:

Knowing what is ‘right’, yet bringing wrongdoing forced onto others.

Better to go back to unknowing.

ketzu 3 hours ago||
Seems at least the "geoblocking is enough" part should be legislated at a higher level, even if you agree that dns blocking is the right solution. Long and expensive fights in every country to get that recognized are stupid.
hvs 2 hours ago|
There is no "higher level legislation" than individual countries. They are sovereign. You are talking about treaties and the history of them and copyright isn't great.
draygonia 2 hours ago|
The only pirates I have a problem with are the ones who make money off of their sharing (charging for access, ads on their site, etc).
0x1ch 1 hour ago||
While not on topic, this did make me curious how the scene will adapt in the next five to ten years. Storage has been abundant for trackers and pirates alike, but that just isn't the case anymore. People can't really just "seed" forever and add a few 6TB drives to their desktop or NAS, that's a $1k bill now.
asdff 1 hour ago||
Sure they can. It’s more expensive but not showstoppingly expensive. It is still far cheaper than it was historically when piracy was perhaps an even bigger force. Imagine what a few 6tb drives cost you in 2005. Now keep in mind today cd quality rips are still the same size as they were in 2005.
blahyawnblah 2 hours ago|||
It costs money to make things. You think people should be able to freely bypass paying to use a product?
draygonia 58 minutes ago||
If the creators don't have a stake in the sales revenue, I'm completely for it (i.e. They were already paid for their work). Companies can take a hit, creators shouldn't.
asdff 1 hour ago||
Sites aren’t hosted for free you know
draygonia 1 hour ago||
I'm not opposed to completely voluntary donations being used to fund servers. One site had a meter that would turn off donations once the monthly goal was met.
More comments...