Posted by DeepLogin 3 hours ago
If only it were that simple to define what a job is and which jobs are “worthy” or not of being reserved to humans.
I’m against dreamy proposals like this one because they miss the forest for the trees. Like previous technologies, AI can do lots of things that humans don’t really care about automating. But deciding which things won’t be subject to AI hinges on personal preferences, class interests, and even market pressures. It’s not something that can be reasoned about on a global scale, and trying to push this agenda might sow even more division among humans than we’d think at first glance.
Compared to the, sadly too common, current hellscape of some underpaid and over worked person who comes by and does the bare minimum (if that) in a rush before hurrying off to their next client.
This thought is likely to be revolting to many people, but most of them are going to compare it to a reality that may not exist: They want infinite human caregivers with infinite patience and infinite money to pay those caregivers, but sadly all of those things are finite.
AI and automation are often second-best solutions to some idealized version of reality, but when the idealized version isn’t attainable pragmatic people start accepting the second-best solution. There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though.
Part of the reason why so many governments have banned single room occupancy housing (the other part is a selfish desire to not allow “those types” to live nearby).
A society that is willing to leave the care of people in the "hands" of machines seems so uncaring to the point of not caring for people at all. I'm fully expecting that the sort of society that will leave human care up to automation would just as easily run people through furnaces instead. After all, no one cares enough to look after them so why keep them around at all?
> when the idealized version isn’t attainable pragmatic people start accepting the second-best solution. There are a lot of unpragmatic people who will get very angry at the second-best solution for existing, though
If you wanna talk about unpragmatic versus pragmatic, it's clear what the actual pragmatic choice is, isn't it?
I don't think that many people will have a problem with a robot cleaning wounds, changing bandages, preparing meals because you can't, etc... if it does a good job. Care here is just making sure your wound heals properly. A nurse can also provide psychological care in a way machines can't, but does it have to go together with treating a wound? Some people don't need psychological care, they just need a new bandage, others have a body that needs no intervention but may need psychological care.
It would even be more efficient! Imagine if a 10000th of the money put in AI would go to caregiving? And it wouldn't even be a bubble that risks bursting, eating the pension you'd need to pay for that robot, and it would be at least somewhat useful!
You'll likely need human contact.
Providing full-time care for seniors is incredibly demanding, both physically and mentally. There is a limited pool of people with the requisite mindset and aptitude to do it well. Better renumeration, while certainly deserved by those people, won't automatically increase the size of this pool, it may simply attract more ill-suited people to the profession.
And even with the most compassionate and skilled carers, needing to rely on other human beings for your physical needs results in a loss of dignity and independence. It also creates a power imbalance that will always make abuse or neglect a possibility.
Done right, automated care offers the possibility to provide high-quality physical care that is more convenient, private and dignified for the recipient than needing everything to be done by a human. It also allows for that pool of skilled human carers to focus on higher-value support without being spending the majority of the time addressing basic physical needs.
How much do you think we spend on both currently? Total global AI spending was estimated to be about $1.5 trillion by Gartner in 2025. The US alone spends $1 trillion on Medicare, and the home care industry by itself in the US is roughly $300B. And those figures don’t capture the millions of hours family members spend caring for relatives. Globally, spending on care is almost certainly larger than spending on the AI buildout (though perhaps not in some regions like China, which notoriously provides little support for the elderly).
A lot of parallels to the debate on tariffs and free trade: People really don’t like when something new disrupts the work they do. They do like when it disrupts other companies’ (and therefore, other people’s) work and makes the things they need cheaper.
When robots become reasonably competent, caregiving should be near the top of the list for the type of jobs they should be used for, both for ethical and economic reasons.
Complex and varied physical skills, understanding and managing human emotions, and broad medical knowledge.
No takesies-backsies!
1.) The basis of the world economy is labor. Assuming we take AI industry claims about potential impact of the technology seriously AI threatens this arrangement without offering anything new to replace it. Letting a handful of extra-national businesses threaten the world economy is stupid.
2.) AI improves through access to high quality training data. Using AI internally funnels your company's institutional knowledge, proprietary data, and processes into the training pipeline for the AI tools you use. You are now paying to improve the tools your competitors use and building an existential threat to your business by setting the stage for your AI provider of choice to vertically integrate into your industry segment once sufficient training has been achieved.
3. Letting extra-national organizations operate the computer security equivalent of WMD with no oversight is a ludicrous national security threat.
4. On a warming planet with aging power distribution infrastructure and significant and growing local and regional water availability issues, massive increases to either power or water use is deeply unethical if not outright negligent. Doing both simultaneously solely to profit a handful of investors beggars belief.
5. The financials are fucking unhinged. If investment figures are to be believed the AI industry would have to capture 100% of the economic output of France, or if you prefer Ireland, Belgium, Sweden, Austria, Norway, and Denmark combined. Annually. Just to break even.
It’s not perfect, but still better than anything else we’ve tried.
My dad has a full set of the Oxford volumes. It takes up two rows in his bookshelf.
What a weird omission. It been a word for decades (centuries?)
2025: parasocial
2024: manifest
2023: hallucinate
2022: homer
2021: perseverance
2020: quarantine
Quarantine, hallucinate and parasocial are particularly good ones! Those words helped people contextualize and navigate their changing world in those years.
"Human" on the other hand, doesn't seem to fit the mold. It's like making 2020 be "health".
What about "agent"? What about "p(doom)"? What about "slop"?
At least in the AP write up of Collins' word of the year they cite a year over year change in usage ("mogging" usage increased 210%).
Also striking that we can so effectively apply it to human perception of relationships with LLMs, when it first really entered the non-professional zeitgeist a few years back to describe one-way relationships with social media stars.
Having said that, I think "human" is the right choice. I also wonder: is it not the case that despite this word evolving for thousands of years, we're even now adding weight to what it means?
In 2019 "quarantine" meant something different than what it meant to me in late 2020. When a word's meaning changes significantly in a year that's an adaptation that generally is helping people navigate the world.
Pre-2023, human was mostly a distinction from animal. Now it’s mostly a distinction from robot
Dictionary.com's 2026 Word of the Year Is Maxxing
https://www.dictionary.com/word-of-the-year (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50474081)
Collins' Word of the Year 2026: mogging
https://blog.collinsdictionary.com/language-lovers/collins-w... (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50474363)
Oxford Word of the Year is still open to voting!
https://www.cambridge.org/news-and-insights/human-is-Cambrid...
I wasn't there (no, not like that, I wasn't born yet), but my understanding is that the 1960s movements - there were several - are often reduced to a near caricature of being about drugs and sex.
They were a reaction to the horrors of war both real in WW2 ending 15 years earlier, and perceived as the Cold War developed. Escapism intertwined with wanting a giant reset switch on where "the establishment" had taken - and was taking - civilisation, produced a cultural shockwave that germinated a whole bunch of cultural revolutions across the spectrum from equal rights to music.
I get the sense something is stirring right now. Voting down data centres is not the end of the discontent. People are openly annoyed about war (again), about wealth inequality (again), about concentration of power and wealth into the hands of the corrupt few (again), but now are looking at the adoption of technologies over the last 20 years and wondering: what did we do?
People started abandoning social media some years ago. Already Facebook is seen as a place for boomers, not young people. TikTok was described by some younger, cooler people than myself the other day I was eavesdropping on as "boring" and "pretty stupid". And then there's the grassroots "indie web movement" that is starting to try and break out and blossom a bit.
You can see how that, and this deeper cultural touchpoint with what it means to want a real connection to other humans can drive us somewhere interesting, but I don't know where.
From an AI standpoint, I'm pretty clear with my own take on the output of a lot of this stuff: I can't be bothered to consume what you haven't been bothered to create. I'm not interested in AI-created content for the most part, and even when I'm creating something myself (code, reports, whatever), using AI I'm using it as a drafting and copy-editing tool, not as a stand-in - I push everything through a huge amount of my own editing, not because I'm a luddite, but because I add value. So do you, so does everyone else.
I'm biased because of course I like my own hot takes, but I can imagine this being far from a niche view over the next few years.
Tied to this, I see so much claudeslop in my day-to-day that I have started policing myself for it, almost constantly. I am really sad and annoyed about that fact. Yes, language is a pattern and is arbitrary in a sense, but having it stamped into conformity feels like newspeak. This is only one aspect of a larger "everything faster, better" impulse that cannot continue.
I see it happening all around me here in Florida.
People are getting out more than ever and engaging with their local communities. Even my small lakeside neighborhood of about 50 homes has its own monthly meetup now.
The Orlando dev meetup keeps growing, and it’s not just recruiters. There are multiple subgroups now, with something going on every week.
The best way I can describe it: getting together in person is still free. Look at the election. Billions of dollars were spent trying to sway the system ($500M from Elon alone), but money can’t physically move people.
The more corporations squeeze the internet for money, the more people will just walk away, and there’s nothing they can do about it.
I also cannot share your optimism of a revival of the Sixties spirit. I obsessively collect books about the counterculture, and it is clear that people were then brought together into real-life communities through quaint things like live-music scenes or sheer boredom (not much else to do). That spur to real-life socialization is gone now. Live arts have been hollowed out by increasing rents, recorded music has become a matter of personal listening through earbuds instead of a communal practice, people have plenty of addictive slop to consume. While people do complain online about a dearth of real-life social opportunities, that usually doesn't translate into any actual revival of such. Personally, I suspect the world is only going to go further into tech addiction and isolation, especially as the developing world comes increasingly onboard through affordable and plentiful mobile data.
> And then there's the grassroots "indie web movement" that is starting to try and break out and blossom a bit.
I'm sorry, but this is pure fantasy. I have followed indie-web stuff closely over the last decade (yes, people have sought a revival for that long already), and it has not been going anywhere. It is a tiny, tiny community and will eventually sputter out, as the browser becomes less and less a familiar tool to broad society in the age of dedicated apps.
Young people didn’t want to be sent to the meat grinder for imperialism. Yes, the context was the Cold War / domino theory, but Vietnam was, specifically, a massive—probably second to none?—issue for counter-cultural movements.
Just one example, the hardest part about memory is designing it to be stable enough to form a self identity, but flexible enough to change and grow. After working on that, it's incredibly clear to me that changing our self story and attitude works and will change our brain - it has to or we'd basically die. Whereas before that was a vague help self thing that I wasn't sure about either way.