Top
Best
New

Posted by liotier 10 hours ago

How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more than 40k staff(element.io)
608 points | 290 commentspage 3
rs999gti 6 hours ago|
> rolled out Matrix

So a Teams or Slack alternative?

varispeed 3 hours ago||
Does it have a backdoor built in?
testtestmetest 8 hours ago||
Fun fact Matrix was made by employees of a company accused (probably accurately) of being a mossad front company.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdocs

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matrix_(protocol)#:~:text=The%...

Edit (downvotes within literally 3 seconds lol)

troyvit 5 hours ago||
> In 2005, Amdocs was suspected of industrial espionage when it hired a private investigator who allegedly spied on a Globes journalist. In 2009, the South African State Security Agency suspected Amdocs was being used by Mossad to spy on South African citizens

Is that what you're referring to? If so it's pretty weak and doesn't connect the actual people who created Matrix to being a part of the alleged front company. Reading the rest of this post it seems there are plenty of better reasons to throw shade at matrix than tenuous connections to Mossad.

testtestmetest 5 hours ago||
Someone below provided pretty exhaustive reasoning as to why Amdocs is very suspect.
troyvit 2 hours ago||
Everything I saw there came after my comment, but I read it and everything I see was unsourced and still doesn't tie the people behind Matrix to the rumors about Amdocs.

Say what you will about Mossad they usually build stuff that is more well put together than how Matrix is represented here, even if they are the bad guys.

e12e 2 minutes ago||
I don't know, depends on the goal. If matrix is like their beepers, it stands to reason group chat keys would be hard to keep confidential.

Not sure where I stand on the "it's Mossad" - matrix doesn't seem like false flag FOSS to me.

opticnerve 2 hours ago|||
https://web.archive.org/web/20201028233021/https://samba.nob...
notenchange 7 hours ago|||
Do you have any credible sources for the accusation you mentioned?
normis 6 hours ago||
It's right there in the links provided by that commenter.
notenchange 6 hours ago||
No, it’s really not. One of the links does indeed state that this company was involved in the creation of Matrix.

But where are any credible sources for this company being connected to Mossad?

Zigurd 5 hours ago|||
Amdocs has been accused/rumored to be involved in multiple espionage scandals. Oddly, the most reporting in the US on this was on Fox News. I was considering using Matrix in a project I was working on, and I was aware of Amdocs reputation, but the Matrix people spun out of Amdocs long ago.

It is more than a little plausible that Amdocs would be involved in spying. They handled the most useful data: CDRs.

The Daytona database created by AT&T labs was a database of tens of billions of CDRs which created a queryable connection graph of all Americans. Probably the biggest database on the planet at the time. They brought in punchcards and nine track tape from exchanges all over the country literally on semi trucks. They also created query and visualization tools to monitor how Americans are associated with one another. Pretty dark stuff.

Anyone aware of that part of telecom history would think Amdocs is sus.

glenstein 4 hours ago||
Fascinating background. May I ask how you became aware of that history? Wondering if this is in a book or just kind of general industry knowledge.
Zigurd 4 hours ago||
At the time Daytona was being actively built I heard rumors through academic and industry connections. Later on, a consulting gig took me to what was left of AT&T labs and I got to talk to some people who are previously involved. It was a secretive project, but the building lobby had a banner celebrating some anniversary of the project, which I thought was pretty funny, like "remember that time when we made a social graph of all Americans decades before Facebook?"
glenstein 6 hours ago|||
That's what the other article is for:

> In 2009, the South African State Security Agency suspected Amdocs was being used by Mossad to spy on South African citizens.[21][22][23]

So between the two links, what's established is that Matrix was created within Amdocs and that Amdocs has been suspected by at least one state security agency of being connected to Mossad.

abc42 5 hours ago||
Some specific reason why you would believe the South African State Security Agency? South Africa is known to be rather anti-Israel.
testtestmetest 5 hours ago|||
South Africa's supoort for Israel is the reason Israel has nuclear weapons. They're definately not anti israel.

Israel has been caught spying by many countries including the USA, I dont think one has to be anti israel to make such accusations.

notenchange 5 hours ago||
Sorry, but this comment cannot be taken seriously.

You are trying to pretend external diplomacy and policy from pre-apartheid South Africa, has anything to do with present day South Africa's external relations and state policy. That's just not a good faith argument. Not in the slightest.

testtestmetest 3 hours ago||
South Africa absolutely had healthier ties with Israel pre oct 7th, and some of South Africas largest enterprises are owned by Zionists. There are many in South Africa that miss the good ole days and absolutely support Israel in their pursuit to recreate a society they're nostalgic of.
glenstein 4 hours ago|||
I love invoking mysterious third parties to note in the passive voice that this bias "is known" to them and expecting that to count as authoritative. Charges of bias are themselves just as liable to bias as anything, so I would expect you to hold yourself to the same rules as the other commenter who was asked to substantiate their claim with sources.
kachnuv_ocasek 7 hours ago||
Whoa, their ticker really is DOX?
pwndByDeath 5 hours ago||
I've been testing out XPRS, very clean UI with built in encryption, the ability to use whatever network path you have without a central authority.

You give up on some consistency guarantees due to latency, but meh

rwmj 9 hours ago||
Given how much time I spend "verifying my device" and other issues with simply making it work, and multiplying that by 40000, I feel very sorry for them.
codedokode 8 hours ago||
Yes it is awful. I do not even understand how I can "verify" a temporary browser session which gets destroyed after a log out.

Reminds me of WhatsApp vs Telegram. In Telegram to log in from a new device, you just enter the phone number and the code. In WhatsApp you need to scan some codes, do other things, overcomplicated.

tomstockmail 6 hours ago|||
In the Element client, Element X on android, you scan the QR code and enter a series of emojis. It's slightly more involved than telegram/Whatsapp, but I would not be surprised if they do something similar in the future.

What is slow is the syncing after that, which I understand depends on a variety of factors.

codedokode 4 hours ago||
By the way I do not really need the history and I believe it should be disabled by default - like in real life conversations where there is no history - so I do not understand why syncing needs to be slow. Cannot you just fetch last 10 messages when the user opens a room?
danelski 8 hours ago||||
Telegram doesn't have the E2E encryption apart from the private chats bound to a single device. No wonder their process can be simpler.
tcfhgj 6 hours ago||||
> I do not even understand how I can "verify" a temporary browser session which gets destroyed after a log out.

why shouldnt you be able to do that? Even WhatsApp does it

pbmonster 8 hours ago|||
You do realize that in both those cases, private crypto keys are being transferred to the new/temporary device?

There's really only so many ways you can do that securely.

rwmj 8 hours ago||
[dead]
polytely 9 hours ago|||
real problems like that at this scale will probably result in it being improved which seems like a good thing to me
harrouet 8 hours ago||
It is painful but that's what makes it secure.
Zak 7 hours ago||
It could work consistently across clients and stay working without being less secure.
magahugu 8 hours ago||
Long time enemy l element and matrix user here. Indeed the verification process of new sessions is complicated. Something they'll surely address as they grow (until no security advantage is left...)
rsanek 6 hours ago||
> “Sovereignty” can have a different meaning for different people and organisations, so the Commission started by pinning down what it means for them. Their answer spans five dimensions: resilience and business continuity, vendor diversity, control over their data, ownership of the platform, and leverage in procurement - the ability to negotiate with, or walk away from, a supplier. That last one is easy to forget, and arguably the one that bites hardest when it's missing.

I wonder if Mistral models also have a tendency to output this kind of verbiage or if they decided not to use a sovereign LLM to write this post

notenchange 7 hours ago||
Well, leave it to the bureaucrats in Brussels, to spend a year, and several tens of millions (low estimate) in a decision and implementation that ends up deciding the best path to take was: Matrix.
ezst 5 hours ago|
I'm more of an optimistic. With Element finances drying up, and holding to that last one string, it could be what ends up killing the failed experiment that matrix was, so we can finally move on to something that works. "We tried hard, gave it all, and even us couldn't get it to work"
Arathorn 5 hours ago||
i'm sorry to disappoint, but Element finances aren't drying up :)
sailfast 6 hours ago||
So they’re using a paid enterprise product from a company that doesn’t support their normal collaboration workflow so folks will continue to use Teams but get spammed by IT about how they can use this new tool?

How much did this cost would be my next question. Is anyone using it?

dannysilo 8 hours ago|
https://slashdot.org/story/26/10/02/1743247/eus-microsoft-te...

> The European Commission's rollout of Element Pro as a self-hosted alternative to Microsoft Teams has received harsh criticism from officials, with users citing poor usability and calling the tool "absolute shit."

It doesn't seems they're enjoying it

arnonymous 7 hours ago||
Teams is such a shitshow. I always join meetings by using an incognito browser, pasting the link, and staying in browser. If i try the app, or logged in browser it fails, without giving any useful error or message to work with.
codedokode 5 hours ago||
Interesting that Zoom (sorry I did not use Teams) uses popups when you try to join from the browser so I have to manually open that popup blocked by my browser. While in a browser version of Element I can make calls without any stupid popups and having to reject suggestions to install an app.
FinnKuhn 8 hours ago|||
I'm sure you will find more than enough users that would also describe Microsoft Teams as absolute shit, but it is also not intended to replace Teams, but offer an additional channel for more sensitive communication that you wouldn't want to have via Teams.
CalRobert 8 hours ago|||
Some people hate change.

I'm astonished people can deal with using Teams.

Arathorn 6 hours ago|||
Fascinating to see folks signing up to HN just to post this :D

The OP literally includes a video & quotes from the actual EU officials running the project which directly contradict whatever anonymous source Politico used.

arthur-st 7 hours ago|||
If it's described as absolute shit, they may have just found a peer platform to Teams.
rurban 6 hours ago||
They were just the typical Microsoft shills, similar to Munich. Ignore them. Teams is the absolute shit, Matrix is ok.
More comments...