Top
Best
New

Posted by Terretta 4 hours ago

UK government forced to admit it issued Apple a secret encryption order(macanorak.com)
307 points | 142 comments
natch 3 hours ago|
Apple has significantly weakened its security assurances in a way that is arguably deceptive. They used to say nobody can access your data, not even Apple. Now they say Apple cannot access your data. People will point out that your key is created on your device, lives on your device, and never leaves your device, but that is just your key. Your key is likely a KEK (key encryption key) that opens another key (not “your” key, let’s call it the actual key) that your data is secured with. There can be other parties (UK government) with their own KEK that opens a copy of the actual key. In this scenario, Apple can have no access to a KEK that opens the actual key, but they are forced to make the wording change they did, if they want to stay honest.

I say the statement is arguably deceptive because it presents the same feel of assurance that the old one did, to most people.

Note John Ternus in a recent event (WWDC keynote if I recall correctly) used the old wording. I think this was a slip-up (I’d hate to think it was a calculated lie posing as a slip-up).

happyopossum 1 hour ago||
This is just not true. Apple's current platform security white paper clearly states what you're complaining they took away:

"many Apple services use end-to-end encryption, which means the user’s iCloud data can be accessed only by the users themselves, and only from the trusted devices where they are signed in with their Apple Account."

And: " If a user chooses to turn on Advanced Data Protection, their trusted devices retain sole access to the encryption keys"

Also, there's no need to make suppositions such as this: > Your key is likely a KEK (key encryption key) that opens another key (not “your” key, let’s call it the actual key) that your data is secured with.

The details of keys are clearly outlined in the same white paper: "Most iCloud data is first encrypted on the user’s device, using device-generated iCloud keys, before being uploaded to iCloud servers."

So no - there's no layer of keys that Apple or the UK or whatever can use to bypass e2e where it's enabled.

kps 56 minutes ago||
> "If a user chooses to turn on Advanced Data Protection, their trusted devices retain sole access to the encryption keys"

The implication is that if a user does not “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection, then something else also has access to their encryption keys.

Users in the UK cannot “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection.

TimTheTinker 39 minutes ago|||
> if a user does not “choose to turn on” Advanced Data Protection, then something else also has access to their encryption keys

That's exactly the case. Without it, Apple Support, anyone with a valid warrant/subpoena, insider threats, successful phishers, etc. could access iCloud data.

Previously, Apple did not support E2EE for user data in iCloud, but later added it - that's what "Advanced Data Protection" is, after all.

But I believe when it was introduced, it was a news item (not from Apple, but from industry watchers) that it wasn't available in the UK, likely because of UK laws that harm privacy. It is the foremost surveillance state after China and North Korea, after all.

GeekyBear 15 minutes ago|||
So exactly like local disk encryption on Windows devices?

By default, Microsoft has a copy of your laptop's encryption key and will hand it over in response to a warrant.

> Microsoft Shared BitLocker Keys With FBI, Raising Privacy Fears

https://www.techrepublic.com/article/news-microsoft-bitlocke...

s3p 2 hours ago|||
This isn't related to the article, and it's not true? iCloud ADP still exists in its original form, there was no modification allowing 3rd parties access to ADP decryption keys.
bspammer 1 hour ago|||
ADP no longer exists in the UK

https://support.apple.com/en-us/122234

GeekyBear 4 minutes ago||
It still exists, but U.K. users cannot turn it on if they have not done so previously.

From your link:

> Users in the UK who have not already enabled Advanced Data Protection will no longer have the option to do so.

arpinum 1 hour ago|||
iCloud ADP no longer exists in the UK.
mahboi 51 minutes ago|||
They claim E2EE for certain services. "Your key is likely a KEK" - What makes you think this? That would straight up not be E2EE.

They're also clear that much of iCloud isn't E2EE unless you have "Advanced Data Protection": https://support.apple.com/en-us/102651

midtake 2 hours ago|||
The on-device private key material has to be a KEK anyway, otherwise it wouldn't be usable on all your iCloud-linked devices.

I still trust Apple in the USA at least. When I enrolled in advanced data protection, it did say nobody not even Apple, not just not Apple. It may be that they need to tighten their contractual language everywhere to deliver a uniformly semantic sentence.

elAhmo 2 hours ago|||
Didn't they also deceptively say that those things that Apple cannot access only apply to local content, but if you have an iCloud backup (which pretty much anyone has), then Apple has access to that.
TacticalCoder 53 minutes ago|||
> People will point out that your key is created on your device, lives on your device, and never leaves your device, but that is just your key. Your key is likely a KEK (key encryption key) that opens another key (not “your” key, let’s call it the actual key) that your data is secured with.

The near exact same deception has been put in place by Google/Microsoft/Apple with passkeys. It used to be, before passkeys, that people really could have a secret hidden behind an actual HSM, impossible to copy.

But they teamed to come up with passkeys that can now... Be copied from device to device. A secret, safe behind a HSM, replaced by something that can be copied.

What a win for security.

And all the idiots are cheering: "buuut buuuuuut buuuuuut it is CONVENIENT".

Yeah.

chunky1994 2 hours ago|||
Where exactly do they say this, where is this wording change?

https://support.apple.com/en-us/102651#advanced

"This specifies no one, not even apple." I.e they don't store the keys you use for e2e encryption. They've systematically been against introducing backdoors here. Now, is it possible they have and they've been lying through their teeth? Surre, but its unlikely they would be so brazen.

calibas 1 hour ago|||
I think that's just for Advanced Data Protection, which apparently isn't offered in the UK. Here's what the page says about the default Standard data protection:

"Your iCloud data is encrypted, the encryption keys are secured in Apple data centers so we can help you with data recovery, and only certain data is end-to-end encrypted."

gmueckl 2 hours ago|||
Not sure about the extent of UK investigative powers, but I would assume that FISA in the US could indeed force Apple to lie to keep a change secret.
throw0101c 1 hour ago|||
> Not sure about the extent of UK investigative powers, but I would assume that FISA in the US could indeed force Apple to lie to keep a change secret.

Under what provision of FISA could the US government order Apple to stop doing end-to-end encryption?

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveilla...

It's one thing to say "hand over what you have access to on user X", it's another for "re-architecture your system to break E2E".

dboreham 1 hour ago||
I think we're well past assuming that laws apply to governments at this point.
equinoxnemesis 1 hour ago||
Someone claims a specific law would allow the government to do a specific thing, this claim is rebutted, and then it becomes "how naive to think the law ever mattered." Just reflexive abject cynicism. No the US government isn't perfectly lawful, yes the content of the laws does nonetheless matter a whole lot. Nuance.
fn-mote 1 hour ago||||
I believe FISA can force silence but not lies (“compelled speech”).
gmueckl 1 hour ago|||
The legality of the FISA order to Lavabit is untested. My understanding is that that included restricting documentation changes to not reveal the key handoff.
qeternity 1 hour ago|||
Correct. This is why warrant canaries work.
chunky1994 1 hour ago|||
Does FISA force silence/lies about backdoors? I am not versed in any FISA cases being tested in court against e2e practices.
dboreham 1 hour ago||
It doesn't need FISA. Somehow (I have theories..) all media were prevented from disclosing Epstein information. For decades.
sandworm101 2 hours ago|||
Well, if Apple provided the KEK to the UK government then Apple is capable of generating another KEK for its own use. That means Apple can in fact access customer data on its own, just after a couple extra steps.

(Yes it is theoretically possible to create a complex encryption scheme whereby the UK government posses the only copy of a key that is in turn needed to generated a duplicate KEK, but I find it hard to believe Apple and the UK government have organized such a dance without a simple backup for the day the magic UK key gets lost/corrupted.)

hrncn 2 hours ago||
Given the legalese these extra steps are all that matters. Keep in mind that Apple could just update the software to do whatever it wants it to do, too. It's not like Apple customers are in control of what runs on their phones.
SoftTalker 1 hour ago||
This is what it boils down to for me. Whatever Apple claims they are doing today, and even what they are actually doing today, could change tomorrow. My phone just got an iOS update overnight. Do I know what changed? No I do not.

The thing about a secret is that once someone else knows it, it's no longer a secret. It's at best a confidence.

slopinthebag 2 hours ago||
it appears apple has done this in response to government interference which they cannot even legally disclose. what would you have apple do here?
jimbob45 2 hours ago|||
Came to say this. It actively hurts Apple's revenue to make these changes and not be able to market themselves as privacy leaders. They wouldn't make these changes unless they had to.

It's one thing if your company never tried to be privacy-first and you went above and beyond what the government requested but there's no evidence of that here.

buckle8017 1 hour ago||||
Exit the UK market and reveal the letter in a US court.
stouset 56 minutes ago||
This would be better for their UK customers how, exactly?
leafingensemble 44 minutes ago|||
I contend it is better to refuse than to be complicit.
KoolKat23 23 minutes ago|||
Apple leaving the UK won't go down lightly, MP's will shit themselves for real.
joe_the_user 2 hours ago|||
If Apple gave the user unconditional control of their own devices, they wouldn't be able to comply with these orders. But they never want to do this nor would the cellular providers permit this.

But I don't think we should reason based on "put yourself in mega-corp's shoes, they absolutely have to X thing". Rather, we should ask what people can do.

coldtea 1 hour ago|||
>If Apple gave the user unconditional control of their own devices, they wouldn't be able to comply with these orders.

They could be trivially given orders not allowing them to sell devices where users "have unconditional control" too, so it's not like that's a magic technical solution that bypasses the legal/political demands.

stouset 50 minutes ago||||
Can we please just cut this kind of stereotypical, childish response from HN discussion?

Presumably you want to use this device with literally any online service, who is still subject to the laws of the governments under which they reside. Presumably you want to install software on this device which must abide by the laws of the governments under which you reside. Presumably you want to purchase this device from a store which has to comply with the laws of the governments under which they operate.

The central issue here is the government, and that is something the people can change if they care enough.

If you want to totally own the phone and software you can: buy a Librem. But for god’s sake please stop constantly whining that other companies don’t all offer products under the exact obscure terms you specifically demand.

leafingensemble 27 minutes ago|||
The comment is very reasonable.

The tech companies do above and beyond what is legally required to make their customers accessible.

Prior to TCNs Apple was going to scan icloud anyway. It does indicate at least some integrity that they changed plans and refused to decrypt ADP.

Encryption is legal in many countries. Not in the UK of course. But in countries where encryption is legal, it is the decision of OpenAI, Microsoft etc, to keep data unencrypted. Certainly this is very bad for the user.

joe_the_user 34 minutes ago|||
Could you please stop name calling?
mahboi 48 minutes ago|||
Nothing is forcing the user to use iCloud
fweimer 3 hours ago||
Primary source: https://investigatorypowerstribunal.org.uk/judgement/1-mr-vi...

The key finding seems to be that the media learned of the technical capability notice through confidential security briefings, and not a leak (“one of those irregular verbs”).

The contents of the note remains secret for now.

exe34 2 hours ago|
"I give confidential press briefings; you leak; he's been charged under Section 2a of the Official Secrets Act".
Y_Y 2 hours ago||
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotive_conjugation
peterclary 2 hours ago||
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0751832/quotes/?item=qt0174103
puppycodes 2 hours ago||
Sorta thought this was alreay common knowledge? Unfortunately the UK has never respected privacy or free speech as a right.
mctt 2 hours ago||
Yes! From the article; "The existence of the order was already public knowledge and continuing to pretend otherwise was obstructing the proper consideration of the legal challenge."
leafingensemble 52 minutes ago|||
It is to some extent known that the UK has never respected free speech.

This knowledge is muddled by the custom and practice of the UK government to gaslight the world, by describing the UK as a free and open society and also condemning other countries for censorship and human rights violations.

Hence you get a form of doublethink in the UK, where it is true that there is no free speech but also true that there is free speech.

mahboi 47 minutes ago||
"Free speech" means you're free to say or think whatever you want, provided it follows their rules. You also have freedom from hate speech, which is not speech. Suppose you don't like sending money to Israel, that's hate speech, they'll free you from it.
leafingensemble 23 minutes ago||
I hope this is sarcasm, worryingly I think some people might endorse it.
mahboi 17 minutes ago||
I was saying from the perspective of the UK govt, but yes plenty of its citizens endorse it too.
logicchains 2 hours ago||
>Unfortunately the UK has never respected privacy or free speech as a right.

England's a rather old country, and doesn't actually have any kind of constitutional mechanism that protects citizens' rights against the government. There is a bill of rights, but there's no court with the power to strike down laws that violate it, so it's essentially toothless. More modern countries tend to have supreme courts with the power to strike down rights-violating laws, e.g. the US, Japan, Germany and India.

RobotToaster 2 hours ago|||
One of the problems with introducing a written constitution in the UK is that it would be unconstitutional to do so.

The current constitution is an unwritten common law constitution, but its main point is that parliament can do whatever it wants, and as such no parliament can bind a future parliament.

They tried making it so that calling an early election needed a 70% majority in the fixed term parliament act, but when the government of the day wanted to call an early election they simply repealed it instead.

The closest we've come is the human rights act, which works around this by saying that as far as possible all future legislation should be interpreted as to comply with it, but parliament can simply override it by explicitly stating so in legislation, or repealing it.

tsimionescu 1 hour ago|||
All countries that created constitutions faced this "problem", including the UK back when Parliament was founded, against the divine right of the King and the aristocracy.

That is to say, there is no real problem here. The UK population, or Parliament itself, could just decide to create a constitution that binds future decisions, in violation of the old constituion, and the courts would anyway not be able to stop this.

Of course, the same would be true in the future - if a future Parliament/massive part of the UK population really wanted to do something that this proposed Constitution doesn't allow, they would just change the Constitution, or abolish it, or whatever they want. Any constitution is ultimately just a piece of paper, and can be ignored.

viklove 1 hour ago|||
> parliament can do whatever it wants, and as such no parliament can bind a future parliament

So parliament can't do whatever it wants.

MomsAVoxell 2 hours ago||||
Alas, it's kind of up to the people, not governments, nor the courts - which are there to serve the people. A people has to affirm the right - but so many of us just assume it. That has been exploited by the police-state'ers who control the secrets, and thus everything.

And anyway, free speech isn't possible in a system keeping secrets. The corruption of any organization, including government, begins with its secrets. A truly free well organized people keep no secrets nor tolerate it of their governance.

We speak of democracy; what form of democracy is operating behind that secret wall? The 5-eyes conundrum is a reality - there's a superstate which exists beyond all common public knowledge about things, and which operates to give itself reasons to exist.

If there is a use for AI, its to replace all systems of secrecy, which is anathema to the creation of a model in the first place.

Citizens of all nations, not just the 5-eyes encumbered pseudo-democracies, need to demand the universality of human rights be affirmed by all who wish to rule.

hedora 2 hours ago||||
We should all demand our governments incorporate existing international human rights charted into our constitutions. The EU one is a decent start.
kps 35 minutes ago||||
> constitutional mechanism that protects citizens' rights against the government.

The UK mechanism is elections.

The US mechanism is elections followed by waiting 50 years for the stacked Supreme Court to turn over.

foldr 2 hours ago|||
While there are some advantages to the US model, it also leads to a lot of obscure legalistic wrangling over an old document that's full of ambiguities. And of course, the protections that the document supposedly offers often turn out not to materialize, or to be revocable, once the 'right' people are appointed to the supreme court.

On the whole I prefer the British approach here. If you want abortion to be legal, pass a law making it legal, rather than trying to conduct a courtroom seance with some oldentimes dudes. It's to the discredit of the US system that important issues such as affirmative action, gay marriage, abortion, etc. cannot (in practice) be decided by legislation at the federal level, but instead must be decided by a series of court decisions which by this point are really just a parody of legal reasoning.

AnnikaL 9 minutes ago|||
I think this glosses over the role of states in the U.S. system. For instance, it's true that gay marriage was legalized nationwide by a court case, but a bunch of states had already legalized gay marriage before that happened. (Though some of that was state courts.) This is also how abortion law works since Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health; in California, we voted to encode a right to abortion in the state constitution 4 years ago [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_California_Proposition_1

logicchains 1 hour ago|||
It's not just "the US model". Brits have some of the least protection from the government of anywhere in the developed world, you can go jail just for refusing to tell the police your phone password. Compare it to other countries with strong supreme courts like Germany, Japan, most of the EU, Israel or even India; the British approach has clearly led to the government having far more totalitarian control.
foldr 1 hour ago||
> Brits have some of the least protection from the government of anywhere in the developed world

This is hyperbolic. Negative news stories about the UK just get a lot of coverage at the moment. Check out some of the things that people are getting arrested for in France and Spain, for example.

The legal situation with phone passwords and the Fifth Amendment in the US is somewhat ambiguous at the moment. Americans have in fact been jailed in some instances for failing to hand over passwords after being ordered to do so.

drnick1 58 minutes ago||
Why would anyone trust Apple instead of running GrapheneOS and their own hardware for backup? A Pixel 10a is ~$500. Relative to an iPhone, that leaves hundreds of dollars for your own hardware/storage, even at today's prices.

I assume that people who have "something to hide" are already all running their own infrastructure, so this seems like a mass surveillance exercise more than anything.

drum55 43 minutes ago||
Graphene is nice enough but the user experience just isn’t as comfortable, which counts for a lot.
jen20 39 minutes ago||
> Why would anyone trust Apple instead of running GrapheneOS and their own hardware for backup?

The delusion in this kind of question is utterly wild.

mahboi 38 minutes ago||
I've also always wondered if they can mitm even their e2ee. Just hand some user fake public keys for all their other devices from the very start. There's no public key ledger or anything to keep them honest.
tavavex 42 minutes ago||
The UK's government is pretty insane when it comes to mass surveillance. Almost every nation is expanding their model of it, but why is the UK so overt, intense and uncompromising in their attempts, at least by Western country standards?
natas 1 hour ago||
https://pine64.org/devices/pinephone/
slopinthebag 3 hours ago||
can anyone justify the idea that governments can keep these orders secret? it seems to me that a government trying to hide this kind of thing is doing so maliciously and should not be holding power over it's citizens, who deserve to know that this kind of thing is happening.
chunky1994 3 hours ago||
The steelman is that if forced to make this public, then bad actors/criminals and their enterprises can take steps to remove/expunge their operations from their existing locations so that nothing is found. Often these investigations take place over the course of years so they need to be able to keep production orders secret or else they will lose the investigative progress they have made.

I don't agree at all with the thesis, and surely there could be after the fact revelation/foi requests made possible, but govts don't like to cede power to their citizens in general.

cassianoleal 3 hours ago|||
This doesn't seem to be connected to an active investigation though, but rather just standing powers to break encryption at will.

If it was for an active investigation, one would think it would be targeted to those under investigation.

gadders 2 hours ago||||
I guess an analogous thing would be the operation against EncroChat and their phones [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EncroChat

rightnutwingjob 3 hours ago||||
Is it not true that if bad actors become aware they can, in fact, take steps to mitigate the risk?

What are you not agreeing with?

chunky1994 3 hours ago|||
I don't agree with the thesis that this needs to be forever secret. Every law I've seen keeps the secret requirement indefinite.
Computer0 3 hours ago||||
I don’t agree that I care
synarchefriend 2 hours ago|||
If we don't install a little camera in everyone's home, bad actors can exploit this loophole to engage in all kinds of criminal activities.

The question is whether making law enforcement easier is worth the sacrifice of everyone's privacy. The optimal amount of crime is not zero.

exe34 2 hours ago||
We need to agree on an optimal level of crime with the syndicates, and let them issue permits for individual crimes.
Joker_vD 1 hour ago|||
That's what fines and the barrister fees essentially are, ain't they? Even then, there are some hard limits. "Mike, as soon as you've used the gun, drop it on the floor. Don't be caught with it on you... Remember, Mike, we can square everything, witnesses, and so forth, but if they catch you with the gun on you we can't square that."
u8080 1 hour ago|||
007: loicense to kill
exe34 24 minutes ago||
Close, it's from Terry Pratchett.
thaumasiotes 2 hours ago|||
> I don't agree at all with the thesis, and surely there could be after the fact revelation/foi requests made possible

I don't agree with the policy either, but come on. After the fact discussion causes exactly the same notional harm as contemporaneous discussion: people learn what you're doing, and move their records somewhere safer.

hedora 2 hours ago||
The same argument applies for secret laws, which usually go hand in hand with secret surveillance programs.

If we discussed why the court found some person guilty, then people would just avoid breaking the law.

betterunix2 3 hours ago|||
I do not think there is any justification, but it is not hard to think of reasons that are less malicious than you suggest. For example, Apple has made privacy and encryption part of its marketing strategy and news about governments ordering Apple to decrypt data and hand it over undermines their business. The government would likely prefer a non-adversial relationship with Apple and not undermining their business is obviously part of that.

We can debate whether blame should be assigned to the government for doing this in secret or to Apple for overselling encryption and creating a situation where complying with these orders threatens their business. We can also debate whether or not the government should care about the business impact of these orders.

JoshTriplett 1 hour ago|||
> We can debate whether blame should be assigned to the government for doing this in secret or to Apple for overselling encryption and creating a situation where complying with these orders threatens their business.

Apple is not overselling encryption. They are selling functional encryption, as opposed to broken backdoored things pretending to be functional. Governments trying to introduce backdoors should find themselves assaulted and harried at every opportunity.

The concept of a "Technical Capability Notice" should not exist, under any circumstances. The concept of "you must do work to let us get into your systems" should not exist. Not in secret, not in public. Never.

ndiddy 3 hours ago|||
I think it's important to make the public aware that if your threat model involves keeping your activities private from the government of your country, sending anything sensitive over the internet is risky. This is regardless of how much a provider claims to care about your privacy, or how much they brag about encryption technology etc.
augment_me 3 hours ago|||
In surveillance capitalism, order and control is achieved by an informational assymetry.

Google understood this early on. When the user does not know what the algorithm does or how it works, there can be no discussion or ideas on how to make it fairer. It does not make sense to tell the population about this, as it will cause unrest.

sublinear 2 hours ago||
Today is an early day too for something in the future. The "discussion" about the algorithm is inevitable.
bflesch 3 hours ago|||
Yes they can because it is a monarchy.
autoexec 3 hours ago|||
You can bet that the NSA is already embedded in Apple and able to access anything and everything they want. Local law enforcement and other agencies may be left crying about how they want that data too, but that still leaves us being spied on.
viktorcode 2 hours ago||
I bet it is not so, and I would like you to present any evidence to the contrary.
autoexec 1 hour ago||
@3:51 https://cdn.theguardian.tv/mainwebsite/2013/7/8/130708snowde...

See also : https://www.theverge.com/2013/6/6/4403868/nsa-fbi-mine-data-...

Note that none of this new. Men with guns and gag orders show up to companies in the US and take over parts of their offices to set up shop, splice into their network, install their hardware, and take whatever they want. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

tokai 3 hours ago||||
How to explain FISC then?
tgv 2 hours ago|||
Ah, perfidious Albion. Charles surely is a lizard, just like his mother.
InsidiousWombat 3 hours ago|||
You are completely correct, nothing more to explain. They want power because they are the government, that's only justification they need, everything else PR "ye we will totally use it against bad guys and not against guy that made govt look bad"
joe_the_user 35 minutes ago||
I could but the justification is secret too. /s

I mean, once secrecy is a standard thing, every other part of a (now-supposed) democracy can be and must be bent around it. It's true that if someone just isn't allowed to say X, they might be able to give X away by saying "I'm not allowed to say something" and so that kind of statement has to be outlawed if you are order unwilling people to keep secrets.

latentpot 34 minutes ago|
Cough

Blackberry

Cough

More comments...