Top
Best
New

Posted by shioyama 10 hours ago

Frostbite: A new CPU architecture discovered, designed and verified by AI(architectlabs.com)
560 points | 297 commentspage 2
notorandit 5 hours ago|
I would like to know about Mr. Torvalds' ideas about this architecture.

He's been quite critical because hw architects don't talk a lot to software developers.

odo1242 46 minutes ago|
It seems like this hardware architecture would need it's own kernel / applications? Porting existing x86 or arm applications to "interaction nets" would be pretty hard to do performantly.

The architecture doesn't even have a program counter or call stack, any application running on it would basically have to be programmed in Vine.

dwroberts 9 hours ago||
Feels like the visualization is doing a lot of heavy lifting, because the explanation sounds quite mundane (randomly rewriting interactions between two points in a program graph?)

It is also written as if this is a new idea for programming languages, but modelling things as a graph of nodes is like 101 stuff?

amluto 5 hours ago||
I note that the kernels they tested are computation-heavy tasks on essentially fixed- and small-sized working sets, possibly even tasks that are efficiently representable without state that gets used an a priori unknown number of times. (LZ4 decode is a bit of an exception - you don’t know how many times a given position will be copied in the usual streaming decoder, but there may well be a different decoder in which you figure out what future tokens look at an output byte before you emit and discard that byte.)

I wonder how well their design works on the kinds of programs that build large data structures and slowly mutate them, or whether their current design even works at all for such problems.

(Don’t get me wrong: lots of useful problems clearly fit their model. And even if there are problems that don’t, I imagine that much of the compute part of a memory-heavy problem would still work well on something much like their design.)

Roark66 5 hours ago||
That is a very nice use of AI. An exploratory project that would take a team many months and would never get funding in such scope is being done much more efficiently.

As to the architecture itself, it is promising, but it is hard to say if it will not suffer from difficulties in writing software for it.

It reminds me of one British computer that had physical hardware nodes, each connected to few adjacent ones. With no time synchronisation, each running independently, communicating through ports to adjacent nodes only, and so on. It died outside of academia, because of the difficulties in programming it and progress on classic architectures.

As we are close to the limit of miniaturisation and at the same time experimenting becomes cheaper I wonder if novel architectures will have their another heyday.

wcoenen 7 hours ago||
The description of interaction nets reminds me of Wolfram's attempts to model physics as "hypergraph rewriting". Is there a link between the two?
metalsiliconYT 2 hours ago||
Reminds me of CGRAs/dataflow processors which are what most AI inference accelerators are at some simple level.
adastra22 10 hours ago||
Why would you hold off evaluation criteria? This isn’t LLM training.
OJFord 10 hours ago|
It's similar: they don't want it designing an architecture that overfits to exactly their 25 evaluation workloads, it's supposed to be general purpose.
mtimpe 4 hours ago||
This is interesting but as far as I can tell there isn't a call stack or program counter. A source level debugger for Vine is a requirement and if it doesn't already exist would represent a substantial engineering project. Also, values can leak if a wire isn't connected properly or a net could get stuck if nodes were waiting on each other in a loop or for a value which never arrives. It's the equivalent of deadlock or a memory leak, and they should reproduce reliably, but they are a new kind of bug class to learn and deal with.
titzer 6 hours ago||
Hmm, interesting. Interaction nets are basically dataflow graphs for pure programs. But AFAICT they do not model stateful computations or control dependence for termination. I don't see how they addressed those problems in the IR, but I only had a few minutes to read the first part and skim the second parts.
yubblegum 2 hours ago|
Wonder who designed Vine. Is that an AI creation as well?
More comments...