Posted by LetThingsBeDiff 21 hours ago
Ask HN: I have been unemployed for 2y. 15 years of experience, US. What to do?
In Jan 2025, I quit from a mid-size insurance tech company(1000+) after working there for almost 4y, because I was tipped off the they were about to start layoffs and they did. Well, since then I have zero luck finding any job in SWE.
At this point, I have massive gap in my resume that I can't explain to recruiters, I can still code (C#/.NET/AWS) and learned the AI, but who cares if date of my last employment is Jan2025. What should I do ?
If you have an alternative path (something completely different from SWE or SWE adjacent) that pays "well", I would like to hear.
I don't know the OP's circumstances. What I am about to say is meant as advice to others and not a criticism of the OP.
If you suspect that you may be the target of a layoff, DO NOT SIMPLY QUIT. In this scenario you are a potential liability to your employer. They will almost certainly pay you to leave if they decide to part ways.
It is always easier to find a job when you have a job. Maybe you think if there are layoffs and you are retained that it will be a miserable working environment. Fine. DO NOT QUIT. After a round of layoffs you are relatively safe and you can use that time to find another job.
It is very likely that layoffs are going to continue as companies restructure because of AI. Have a plan. Keep your wits and hold fast.
To expand on that: you need to tell potential employers about your AI-powered SaaS or whatever startup that you've been working on for the past two years, how much you accomplished just by yourself with the help AI agents, how much you learned about using AI effectively, etc. That you just couldn't get enough traction in sales and funding and the area you addressed is now being broadly up-ended by AI, so you are looking for a more regular job
On the side you obviously need a demo of what you've built over these two years, but Claude can help with both brainstorming what your startup actually did and building it retroactively. In the process it will force you to actually start using AI for real which will be a nice bootstrap for your eventual real job.
LLMs have also brought down immensely the cost of investigating these claims.
At this point, every hiring manager has seen every way a candidate can use AI to lie about their abilities and accomplishments, so it won't work anyway.
It turns out that people do still appreciate honesty. OP thinks that taking two years off for care-giving is a red flag to employers. I assure you it is not!
But then when everyone defaults to lies to fudge the system out of desperation to get through the door, then the problem compounds and the inevitable backlash hits the honest people too, and we devolve to a low trust society (if we aren't already there) where everyone will only get in via personal connections(nepotism), OR, have to do a complex 7-stage song and dance in front of robots, just to prove we're worthy to be seen by a human, and then get rejected anyway, for people without connections.
I've been unemployed for 6 months now and already working on a career change. Not that I don't like developing SW anymore, but I'm tired of the nonsense processes and rituals plaguing our industry for the post 10+ years, that keep getting more and more kafkaesque and humiliating as time passes by. It's not worth it anymore. And I have 30+ more years of this shit. My priority is ensuring I can be putting food on the table till retirement, not staying employed in my beloved hobby I fell in love with in 1999. Those days are gone.
It's not an easy path but I hope you make it and get where you need to be.
> getting more and more kafkaesque and humiliating as time passes by
Just... don't set sail hoping the sand is smoother on the other shore. It's probably just different. I've pivoted more than a couple of times in my life. As stupid or cliche as it may sound, your perception or ability to stand them will change more than the stupid things around you.
> large gaps are always gonna be trigger subconscious red flag in recruiters' mind
It's worse than that. The initial sorting and filtering is now done with AI in a lot of HR departments. The bias is built into the model even before a human gets the chance to review it.
Not sure how it is these days but I remember a time when women had to struggle with this, trying to cover the gaps caused by them "daring" to have children, or moving the gaps around so it looks like the children are older and won't interfere with their work duties anymore. I always consider the intention, not just the execution.
These white lies are everywhere else. People dress above their means (even wearing a suit to the interview can be a white lie, but it was expected of you), buy a car or a phone they can barely afford, even talk in comments like they're smarter or more principled than they really are. This thread is full of people sitting in a safe spot, preaching to those who are drowning about principles they themselves probably sidestepped when they needed to grab an opportunity. I have a long rant about people who think they got where they are purely on their merit and nothing else, and who magically group everything they're ever done in the "correct" category.
I will judge a person selling their soul to make another million. Not the one who does it to feed the kids, or not break down themselves.
I'm fully aware of that. A friend of a friend was a data scientist. Was unemployed for a year then converted to becoming a dental technician. Different challenges but at least when it comes to getting a dental technician job after studies, you don't have to go through a completely different 7-stage interview process at every dentist office. That's what grinds my gears the most about the SW profession now.
>It's worse than that. The initial sorting and filtering is now done with AI in a lot of HR departments.
Actually I trust AI models more than I trust the tech understanding of recruiters where I live. Only proper tech companies like Apple, have recruiters with actual technical knowhow, but most recruiters where I live are just below-average humanities graduates who used to work as receptionists in hotels or selling shoes, and now they get to decide if I'm fit for an Embedded SW dev position, because this job is not taken seriously here in Europe so they just hire whoever will work for cheapest to fill these roles. So sorry, but I firmly ChatGPT can figure out a job fit way more accurately than this lot of dancing monkeys.
Yeah bro, just go apply in person, and remember to wear a sharp suit, use strong eye contact and a firm handshake, like everyone used to do. If this fails, then just use your industry contacts to get you through the door. /s
A few years back I was on the job market and my dad said I should call up City Hall and see what they were hiring for. In Los Angeles.
I'm so glad my siblings were all there to laugh at the ridiculous suggestion, but they also know that my dad's advice for the last 40 years has been the same "hit the pavement and shake hands to get a job" spiel.
If you've got a family to feed and a clock that's running out I will never fault you for doing whatever is necessary to get food on that table.
I don't think they should lie and I don't think they should give up on software if they don't want to, but they probably need someone sympathetic and experienced but not personally connected to them to help them evaluate how they present themselves and what weak points may be holding them back. That can be painful and embarrassing but ultimately enlightening if you can stomach it.
At that point, they'll have areas they can improve and maybe a better idea of where they should be seeking employment, and the realities of the current market. Unfortunately, that might mean accepting less than they're accustomed to.
Building a working demo and creating website with help of llm is a good example of what to do I believe. There is 15 years of experience to build upon, so author has much better chances of getting hired than some fresh graduates. Maybe not great pay but for sure better than no qualification blue collar jobs.
I hope that it is helpful in giving the OP and maybe others reading a different perspective and maybe let them think about other ways to approach the problem and how they might do that.
It's crazy to me that the advice being spurned here is "Don't lie, also after 2 years maybe there is something personal that is holding you back" and the response is "Just vibe-slop your way out of this, and lie about yourself". Yikes.
Start your project now (if you haven't already), your value comes from the project and what you did and learned along the way.
Register your company and bring your app online. Be ready to demo it. Try to create something interesting and get people to sign up, even for a free app. So many people on Reddit are trying to build a SaaS and have all the pricing figured out with zero users and zero interest from potential users.
In your startup you're not limited in your AI tools like you may be in a large org with IT gatekeepers so you can operate at the bleeding edge.
Also, if you're working right now and you think you're failing behind in tech and AI, start your side project now. You'll have less time to work on it (naturally) but if something happens to your full time job you can immediately fall back on the project and register your startup and focus on it. Try to build something impressive and ambitious and create tools that carry over into corporate work. That's your value.
This isn't theory, this is what I did. I took a year off to work on my AI dev skills (I have 15 years exp in data so I wasn't exactly starting from scratch) and now I have an app with around 750 registered users and it's still growing. This app is the main thing that got me interest from recruiters and interviews.
Exactly. These days you need to lie not to get an unfair advantage but to not be penalized when going against other people who lie.
There will be a point where you have to show skill. The lying only gets you that far but it helps you go past the “paperwork” filter. You get to where you have actual eyes on you and can earn your spot instead of getting cut by some HR/AI quick scan.
Even just using LinkedIn Premium's "cater your resume to this job" feature creates automated lies. I unfortunately don't think there's a way out as there will never be agreement amongst ourselves to be honest and ethical when you're facing such life-altering situations.
And you do not really want to do it, since you realize it will have consequences for your health. And you're right, it probably will.
The problem is - its very unlikely for you to win without it. And having a sufficiently large pool, and we have it now, there will be A LOT of people using steroids.
They will simply outcompete you. So, you may like it, dislike it - this is your opinion. And you may be even right that this will have consequences. I'm not syaing anyone is wrong.
But the fact is that you will very likely to lose for people who opt for steroids. Not necessarily, but very likely.
There are limits to how much you should lie, but fake it to till you make it is proven to work again and again.
The reality is that competence is a better path to success, including at the highest level, but it's harder, and it's not sufficient without demonstrating your impact and building relationships along the way. This doesn't mean giving up your values, but it does mean acknowledging that others perceptions of you is ultimately necessary, and it's not wrong to invest specifically in that perception above your mechanical work.
And the last thing I'll say is that you've got to find a way to avoid negative psychological loops and blanket judgments of the world. Ultimately if you are not bringing a constructive mindset why would someone pay you? If you're hung up on how others are getting ahead with embellishment and nepotism (or any other professional injustice you've experienced) then you're just wasting energy and mental juice on things that are completely outside your control, and can only serve to hurt your chances of success.
But it's kind of beyond our personal behavior. It's how much the overall economy is growing or shrinking and how much human labor is needed and stuff like that.
Your odds of success are 0 if every HR filter fails you for seeing that gap. Your odds of success are non-0 if you can actually pass that artificial hurdle and have a chance to show your skills.
As a matter of principle, doing this is not the most moral thing. But if the alternative is your family starving it’s a price worth paying. It’s clear OP tried it the other way for a couple of years with no success, time to change something.
I think that is true in that you may minutely increase your odds of passing a stage in an HR pipeline, but it places you on a path to long-term failure.
The opportunity cost here is immense. Right now we have a world of opportunity, where people with the right skills, domain knowledge, and insight can have outsized effects and earn a lot of money. Following the race to the bottom only worsens you're personal outlook, like farriers competing on hoof trimming in 1926.
References: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_03/sr03-046-508.pdf
~99.9% of most peoples CVs are entirely fiction.
This is disconnected from the reality OP’s facing. There is no opportunity cost when there is no opportunity. 2 years on the bench and staring down the barrel of being penniless is proof of that. Hard to sit on a high horse on an empty stomach.
You write a nice story about the ideal situation of people with skills making money hand over fist, that this man is obviously not living in, and has by now years of trying and failing to capitalize on that mythical “opportunity”. Everybody has a plan until they’re punched in the mouth.
The opportunity cost is a small price to pay now for some peace of mind and financial safety for the family.
You could be a trillionaire and instead you chose to pay the opportunity cost for doing whatever you do now.
I think we're just at different stages of grief. The software market has changed, irreversibly, but many remain in denial. They think language skills and framework experience are necessary and they can earn a living based on that.
That's denial.
They're angry at the broken hiring system. Looking for ways to game it. Maybe giving up.
Eventually we come to accept that the skillset that supported our lifestyles is very quickly becoming a commodity and the remaining positions are being filled from an ever-increasing global supply. CV tricks, white lies and massaging the truth can only get you momentarily ahead in a losing position.
Unless you can become a top tier .1% frontier researcher, the only option to maintain the conditions you are accustomed to is to pivot, to become knowledgable and eventually an expert in a domain and to become somebody that other like to work with in that domain.
> The opportunity cost is a small price to pay now for some peace of mind and financial safety for the family.
There is no more peace of mind or financial safety available as a software developer unless you can accrue enough to become independently wealthy. There's no job, no role that's immune.
If OP didn’t mention that he burned through all his savings and is in a bad situation I wouldn’t have suggested anything.
Think of it this way, if your clean green electricity gets cut in winter, it doesn’t look like it’s coming back soon, and your fingers are already turning purple, do you fire up that crappy old polluting coal stove, or do you freeze with your principles intact?
> CV tricks, white lies and massaging the truth can only get you momentarily ahead in a losing position.
You keep saying this but provided nothing to support it. And you can’t because you can’t possibly have this kind of data beyond anecdata. Also if almost everyone else is already doing it since forever, does it mean that they’re all in a losing position? To me it looks like OP is already in a losing position, I really doubt a decent job will somehow put him in a worse position “long term”.
> There is no more peace of mind or financial safety available as a software developer unless you can accrue enough to become independently wealthy
That’s exactly the job OP tries to get, but at least any decent dev job, from a position of having no savings and no prospects. If you thought waiting at home is better than having a job you’d quit yours, burn all your savings, and live day to day musing about opportunity costs you’d rather not pay.
You’re taking your line of thinking very far without any basis or argument to support it. You’re correct that the principled approach is to be fully transparent, but the rest is conjecture to support something reality shows every day to be otherwise.
Interesting take. I don't understand why that would be the case, and you aren't supporting your position at all beyond just stating it, but interesting nonetheless. Especially because earlier you said:
>> because almost everyone is doing this kind of embellishment
Too keep consistency with what you said earlier, you're claiming that everyone is putting themselves in a losing position. I'll go for a second past the ridiculousness of saying everyone is somehow in a losing position. It's obviously working for most people so it's probably exactly what the poster needs right now.
They need a life raft my friend. They are drowning and need to do something to say afloat. And you're here not only offering no actionable advice, you're preaching for a ridiculously rigid position they can't afford to take, with no trace of an argument why that would even be the correct stance, while struggling to maintain consistency between the ideas in your own comments.
I can't give the poster any concrete advice. But in the words of 2Pac, "it's on us to do what we gotta do to survive". Or if you want something more high brow, you are permitted in time of great danger to walk with the devil until you have crossed the bridge. The poster looks like they're in danger and in need of some help now, not looking to swindle to become a billionaire.
Please stop acting all high and mighty, making someone who's already down feel even worse for putting a white lie on the CV just to get to the interview, so they can get the chance to prove their value.
But then that gets too real. It's easier to stick to what we know.
It's so much junk, I don't care at all whether you just did it to "get past HR", I just don't have the time to deal with it so I will mark your application as "Pass, and reject this person for other roles in the future".
Warm introductions are probably the only way round this.
The manager needs to make sure the HR part works. With one recent role where I received mostly obviously fake CVs, I found they had updated the role description to be very buzzwordy. After I rewrote it to be much more "this is what we do and how we do it and this is what we expect from this role" I got fewer but much better candidates.
Is blacklisting candidates legal? Still a shitty thing to do.
(Not saying the applicants are being immoral or anything like that, but can't agree with calling the recruiters shitty)
Dishonesty will bred dishonesty.
And I agree with the person you're replying to, I'm hiring a human not an AI meat proxy. I won't explicitly blacklist them, though the rejection reason will stick with them if they apply for other positions.
a) have a press trail of a successful startup launch with big name clients and/or acquisitions
...and...
b) are looking for a generic mid-low tier corporate IT job like OP
...is zero obviously.
So there will be no competing candidates who look comparatively better, and it will still look better than someone who clearly sat at home doing nothing.
I think many people are ultimately looking for an excuse to not try, so they can sit at home and post comments to HN/linkedin and get validation for the narrative they tell themselves about how 'external forces' and 'situational bad luck' are responsible.
But if this thinking is true, then the only reason you ever had a job in the first place was also situational luck...which to me sounds like a self esteem problem more than anything. Sure, it could be true you never had anything valuable to offer and lucked into jobs before, but I would guess you did have useful skills at some point and the market evolved while you didn't.
There's a million good, sincere ideas in this thread and yet I would guess OPs problem isn't a lack of paths for moving forward. My guess would be it's a lack of motivation to step outside of old comfort zones. OP doesn't need advice, he needs a therapist.
> So there will be no competing candidates who look comparatively better, and it will still look better than someone who clearly sat at home doing nothing.
You underestimate how many developers are looking for every diminishing low level role. Your no-worse-than-the-rest puts you in a raffle at 1:1,000 or 1:10,000 and worsening odds.
That's if the whole recruitment process isn't compliance whitewashing for a candidate already selected via personal relationships.
> I think many people are ultimately looking for an excuse to not try, so they can sit at home and post comments to HN/linkedin and get validation for the narrative they tell themselves about how 'external forces' and 'situational bad luck' are responsible.
Ironically, I think the GP's advice to create an AI-powered SaaS is just this - avoidance. Avoiding the difficult things like improving soft skills, going to meet people where they are and in industry events, creating relationships that may lead to opportunity.
The idea that you can sit on your laptop and prompt something to get you a job is comforting and comfortable, but it's not realistic. Maybe 1:1,000,000 will have a breakout hit project, but then like you say, they won't be competing for the low-level jobs.
Where? Is there a an employers' "who wants to get hired" IRL meeting in every city?
But there are ways to get into contact with those in industry. If you're lucky, you may have family contacts or friends. Following that, ex-colleagues is the next most likely warm avenue. After that, your into the longer tail of ex-alumni and other contacts-of-contacts.
Industry meet ups/conferences are often a good way to reach people who work in your area of domain expertise. The OP may find that their experience in insurance/financial services is now more valuable and saleable than that of the technologies they use. If they can demonstrate that they understand that domain well and that they are adept in the use of LLMS, they may find demand for their services there.
They may have to cold contact (or try to find a warm path) to people they'd like to work for and ask for feedback outside a formal recruitment process on how they're perceived and what they'd need to achieve to get hired by them in a hypothetical. Although not an immediate path to work, it serves as both a learning opportunity and a chance to developer a warm connection for the future.
A lot of people in industry want to help people. It's not a zero sum game. But you need to put yourself in a position where someone can help you, and sometimes one warm connection is enough.
None of this is easy, particularly after two years unemployed. It can be very disheartening and requires swallowing a lot of pride. But it's worth investing effort in building relationships, now more than ever.
Going to meetups to find a job is like taking up yoga classes to find a wife. It's just out of touch advice that might work here and there if you're lucky but it doesn't scale.
If you want to land a job, then you need to be where the employers are, not where the employees are, and meetups(where I live) are mostly employees.
Obviously there's 10,000X more than that. This is what I mean about looking for excuses not to try.
Also, sure, get yourself out there too in addition to proving competence by building something.
I think you're making my point for me here, because to a rounding error, none of those software businesses were prompted into existence and happened to catch fire.
Maybe 1:1,000,000 will erupt from a purely vibe-coded project that someone influential happens upon, but the rest all required the application of lots of soft skills and domain knowledge, sales and marketing, networking and interaction with others.
That's always been as or more important than actual development even in software businesses, and now more so than ever.
They're also the skills the OP and developers at large now need to master to remain relevant in the jobs market.
> Also, OP is not going to form strong enough relationships by schmoozing at events within the next few months before pizzeria desperation hits. He's not in college. He needs to look at this like a sales process where he is the product.
Your approach resigns the OP to be a fungible developer in an over-saturated market and near-certain failure.
I agree, but you cannot vibe-code your way past HR. That ship has long sailed.
Myworry for the OP is that it’s very easy to sit in front of a prompt box, and feel productive, convincing yourself you’re making progress. It’s much harder to reach out to former colleagues, ask friends/family/contacts for help, approach employers directly, or attend industry events and find ways to offer something useful.
I don't want to read in 2027 that the OP reached three years unemployed, thinking they’ve tried everything, when everything they tried involved sitting at a keyboard.
Reconnecting and having calls with former colleagues can also yield something. Not every time, maybe it’s 1 in 30, then it means you have to talk to a lot of people and ask for referrals a lot (“do you know anyone you think I should talk to?” yields results)
Building up a fake resume and persona with AI will NOT get you past that gate.
On the other hand, I've found people to be quite sympathetic to life stories, career breaks, etc.
Bonuspoints if you come from a direction that gives your current crew imposter syndrom. So lie about training your own, specialized local savant "topic" AI.
Because if so, then you have missed the fundamental shift in the market. Millions of unemployed developers can do that. It's no longer a high demand skill that commands the salaries you're accustomed to.
The skills that are now valuable are (apart from the very hard technical skills at the frontiers of AI) are the domain knowledge and soft skills to successfully work in teams and implement software solutions that are actually used.
There are still plenty of companies that hire on an interview and a handshake after chatting with the owner.
Find those companies. If the company has HR you're starting off on the wrong foot already.
But that's not what I came here to say. Rereading the submission, we don't know where in the pipeline the candidate is being rejected. They imply that the two-year gap is causing rejections at the top of the funnel, so their resume gets discarded. But does that really mean they've had zero technical interviews in that two-year period? How are they preparing for the technical interviews? What types of companies are they applying to? I think we need to have more context before we can really give good advice.
After a few years at a place I confessed a resume fib to my manager in a review meeting. He laughed and didn't care. Point being, yes some will be pedantic but if you're there after awhile and they're happy then chive on.
Before I had this in place and on my linkedin, I got almost no interest. Once I had it in place I started getting tons of interest. It still took a while to get a job, but I did.
Nobody wanted to see a demo
I see the system is falling in pieces:
1 No tax contribution for that last 2 years, no pension and I guess no luxuries. 2 All the savings of a lifetime gone, so stock market will be affected negatively. 3 Retraining programs are saturated, 4 Regulations to keep up with the novelty changes are left to destiny 5 A huge hungry wave of graduates (so not experienced) will keep coming each year only to find out the reality (Experienced employees are unemployed, so in most of cases you need to work underpaid or get in line for pizzerias).
Concerning...
Apply for jobs from there.
If nothing else it gives runway to find the right job.
At the same time, tighten belts.
I'm now in that proverbial pizzeria job and love it. I get my rocks off contributing to open source projects and hanging out on HN.
Hundreds of thousands of unemployable SWEs working in dead end jobs while contributing for free on OSS.
What a sad end to this profession, once a high end job now reduced talented engineers to working at McDonald's, Pizza places, etc.
I guess this is where the new jobs are going.
And if this is the future of SWE then SWE is the dead end job not managing a pizzeria.
But for the OP being a 2y unemployed senior engineer, assuming he is 40+, he probably cannot make rent alone working at the average pizza place in the US.
Although it is not nothing, it is a dead end job by US standards and by itself.
Many in the comments know it is temporary.
Good luck keeping that job and dealing with the expectations of software companies when it comes to hiring.
I’m in the same boat as the OP and I could not get any company to agree to do all their interview stages on the same day, had to be an hour here, and hour there. 5-9 stages and random rescheduling by executives who wanted to interview everyone in case they were hired but had more important shit to do frequently.
The industries hiring process has been a new gate to upward mobility, or even getting back in if you fall below the line.
For yhe brainstorming part, just find a startup that became successful in the last 6 months and rip off their site/app with some differences using AI. Then you can say that you choose to stop your startup because the other one was better positioned in the market or better funded to scale. This gives a good explanation and makes it easy to quickly build the prototype.
Don't try to make up for your lack of luck with an equal lack of integrity.
This is your solution, HN?
Just lie?
Why not actually build something yourself!?
Instead of twiddling your thumbs for two years and hoping for somebody to hire you?
Why would a successful company want to hire a lying sack of potatoes that's done nothing in the past 2 years?
If you're a great coder, prove it.
I'm in a similar situation, no one asks about my toy projects
We're also asked to lie. You ever apply to a b2b finance company and get asked why you want to work here or what the company stands out to you.
So many employees are bad, and often all you have to go on is the employee’s word that they did good and their verified dates of employment.
Who said anything about building a toy project?
Build something real.
...and we wonder why there are no jobs! Mostly there's nobody left to even recognize talent or have time and energy to grow it.
But the problem is the front door in hiring is broken. Entirely. I didn’t receive almost ANY replies from hundreds of sent out resumes - I have household names and big public high scale launches and wins on my resume, but no FAANG and no degree.
I got 2 job offers. One was through a manager from 8 years prior who was working at a place. One was a recruiter who found me on LinkedIn. I got engagement when someone physically actually knew me, they were actually hiring, and my skills overlapped.
My honest advice is to apply places and try that dance, get yourself in front of people, real people, and mainly 1-1. Work everyone you have ever worked with. If you’ve reviewed their PR, they need to know that you need a job. Be kind and genuinely catch up with them if you want to, but they are your PRIMARY resource to get a job and you can’t let shame get in your way.
Corporations in general are BROKEN right now in massive ways and the industry is going through a crisis. It will likely become better but whatever you have to do to survive do it.
Finally, it seems like solutions architects seem in demand lately, anyone who can help customers with solutions - SWEs can tend to do well if you have some people skills.
And i suppose if you are shy, well then i guess you are just screwed.
You have two options:
A) Display you are trustworthy by having a consistent employment history and a degree (what it really proves is you showed up at a university for 4 years and crossed your Ts and dotted your Is).
B) Rely on personal connections that already know you are trustworthy or are willing to take a chance of you.
The third case is having a random person deciding to take a chance at you. Which feels the riskiest one of all for the person doing the hiring.
I don't think of it as nepotism - if I know someone sucks from working with them, you better believe I'm making sure I warn everyone if I see them in the pipeline. It's not about pulling friends, it's about pulling people you know are good.
If you've worked for a few months on a team with a competent, decent and reliable person, you'll give this person a huge preference over someone unknown, even if on paper the unknown looks better.
Well yes, "trust" is the entire point of nepotism and why its a thing.
I feel especially sorry for a lot of the English speakers in Sweden right now. The job market is tough even for locals who speak Swedish, but Sweden has a lot of immigrants who only speak English and work in the tech sector, and the market is absolutely brutal for them from what I have seen on my LinkedIn feed. Lots of people I have worked with over the years have been unemployed for over a year and are really struggling to get hired.
It wasn't long ago anyone could follow the route of acquiring competences, get a job after a few applications and 2 rounds interview.
An HR sourcer will receive 1000s of resumes for a position. All very similar, all completely qualified for the position . How would she select one? How would she make that scale?
Then, an HR would get 100 of those candidates for an interview. If only just to ensure it's a human, it's who they say it is and can actually work in the position [people lie on ATS about having Visa/permit]
Then the hiring manager gets 10 people to get to the technical interview process.
It just doesn't scale. And everybody is using AI in both sides. And nothing guarantees you are hiring a lemon or a diamond.
So the referral route jumps all that. When someone you trust refers a person, it IS a shortcut to the technical interview stage, and sometimes even more. Sometimes you even can take for granted what they put in their resume.
I’ve stopped doing that (except a couple projects in the few k stars range just chugging along with minimal maintenance) because any idiot can now drawn me out with a few instructions at a slop machine. That door is officially closed for all but a few extremely lucky people whose projects really blow up.
The hiring system has always run smoother on personal connections. Nepotism denotes taking unfair advantage of a particular subset of connections, the familial. Note the difference.
Re meritocracy, I'm not sure that it ever existed in its idealised pure state. (Not unlike "free market" and a couple of others.) This very forum is chock-full of laments about the pathologies of supposedly meritocratic hiring practices of times past.
Typically the term nepotism also denotes close social connections. I meant it more broadly to mean getting a job based on who you know instead of your abilities.
Wikipedia defines nepotism as: "Nepotism is the act of granting an advantage, privilege, or position to close friends or relatives in an occupation or field"
I have never encountered it used to mean anything other than familial connection where someone who is objectively unqualified or inexperienced gets a job/role.
Hiring someone one has worked with in the past over randos where both meet the minimum qualifications for the job is not that.
If I get a friend of mine to work for the company he still has to put in CV, still has to prove he can do the job.
Only bonus he gets is that I know the person and can back him up on the fact he is good to work with and since I work there that candidate will fit in the team more likely than a random person.
Meritocracy is there and people like to blame their failures on “nepotism” or “meritocracy” or anything else that is beyond their control to feel better.
The hiring manager gets the weight of your opinion that this person is good.
Without that then the hiring manager is basically hiring the person that is best at pretending they would be good at the job. The best actor in the interview. That is hardly a meritocracy.
And as an on again, off again hiring manager: hiring is such a crap shoot that I'd weight what someone I trust is telling me about a candidate much higher than any signal gleaned from the interview process. There are a million things day to day more important than how a candidate performs in contrived interview situations. The only way to really suss that out is if someone you trust has already seen them perform in those situations. That's not nepotism.
Hiring people today in tech is just as bad as trying to be hired. The last role my team had open was getting hundreds of applications for every one application worth considering. We were trying to fill the role through our personal networks at that point mainly to get out if the death loop of reviewing LLM slop resumes.
Are you going to get your idiot friend a software engineering job that they have no ability to succeed at and damage your own reputation?
Of course not.
This is Goffman's front stage / back stage. If everyone is putting on the same front stage performance, what matters is knowing what is back stage. Knowing what is back stage with a person is what it means to "know" a person.
Meritocracy doesn't mean some kind of fine grained MCAT exam and then you are just hired based on a sorted list. The system isn't broken because it is not that.
If you feel sorry for yourself, yes you are screwed. Even introverted people need to learn to fake being social.
Do words still mean anything?
Using personal connections to get hired isn't nepotism.
I guess you could argue about how close a friend qualifies, but it seems inherently about using personal connections.
> The favoring of relatives or personal friends because of their relationship rather than because of their abilities
But that specific professional vouching is good for the employer. It's adding trust to the process.
I see this same kind of exchange constantly about "eugenics". People get really really upset when there's something that's very obviously eugenics but also very obviously a good thing.
Now personally I think it would be great if we could also get OTHER forms of trust to work, but it's harder and not free.
Side note - the word “meritocracy” was popularized as a humorous pejorative intended to point out that what people call “merit” generally originates from social advantages, especially rich parents. Merit is a system that feeds itself, not one that is particularly good at finding raw talent or potential. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meritocracy#Criticism
You must be new here.
It is going to get ugly and fast for many when the people skills many in SWE have neglected for technical skills suddenly becomes invaluable for even obtaining basic jobs that 10 years ago would have gotten a new phone call every day. The real shit show is going to be that we've essentially murdered the physical aspect of any of it so you are starting at negative if you aren't a tweet star or forcing yourself into some quality job hiring events.
Also, maybe local small business? In the same way that you found the pizzeria, is there maybe a local chain of dentist offices or veterinarians or something? Corporate hiring is totally broken, but "finding good people" is still a top problem, especially for medium sized business (50-100 employees, 5-10 locations, across 2-3 states).
Can you get a shitty IT ops job that can beat the pizzeria salary? And help repair your resume hole?
Best wishes.
There's always a chicken/egg problem trying to break into a space like that. Once you have clients, you usually end up with TOO much work. But until then, you're starving. It's very much feast or famine.
My advice is this:
1. Pound pavement! Knock on the doors, talk to people. Do all the networking. You will likely be laughably ineffective at this at first, but it's still useful to get the practice reps in so that when you get in front of the right person, you'll be polished. I got my first big client after taking a lawyer out to lunch, buying him a couple of scotches and straight up asking if he had any clients who needed engineering work.
2. Embrace the Pareto principle and Focus on the whales. Small jobs/clients are almost a complete waste of time. They're the one who will give you trouble over your rate, payment issues, manipulative scope changes, etc. And... they just don't have the pile of money to throw your way.
3. Don't actually chase the whales directly, figure out who are the people who will refer clients to you. These are the people who are INSANELY valuable and often don't even realize it. Treat them well, NEVER make them look bad, and keep the relationship fresh.
Once you're in the space, there's other skills you need to learn in the vein of that "fuck you pay me" article. However, I would never recommend someone trying to break in to the space to not eat a shit sandwich with a smile to get their foot in the door.
Oh, and one more thing: you'd be surprised how long it takes for a lead to develop into a job. In my world that was often 6+ months. So patience is key.
Me and two of my colleagues left our relatively cushy jobs to start a tech and business consulting company, focusing mostly on mid market and enterprise sales. It is a kinda niche service (building internal knowledge graphs, ai integration etc).
I think our biggest shock was realizing that every single client would take several months of talks if we wanted to get reasonably paid and ensure a successful project.
Assessments, discovery, getting the buy in of every relevant stakeholder takes a lot of time, dinners and compromising.
Price negotiation is its own challenge, and until you have a few clients you also have a weaker negotiating position. This means you are probably getting squeezed in your first contracts. 3-4 long deals fell due to prospects trying to buy us out as employees in the end of the sales process, wasting hundreds of hours of work.
If everything goes well then you are going to have some back and forth with legal teams before it gets signed.
Companies also go on their own time, and you are not going to be top priority for any of the people involved in the process.
Took us about 6 months of talks to close our first client. This also means we need to have sales running all the time, and capacity planning is incredibly challenging. Failed deals hurt a lot, since there was a large time and money commitment involved.
Honestly, i would not be able to do this alone, even as a reasonably well connected person. My main advice is to not start a business alone if you can. The only reason we survived is because my co-founders are great at their jobs.
Now that we are at least close to breaking even it feels good, but the first months were AWFUL.
One nitpick is that you should be open to some small guys for your first few gigs. Yeah they suck and will probably pester you for the next few years after you're done, but they will give you experience and legitimacy. Just take the hit as the cost of getting off the ground
I just got started as well after floundering for 2/3 years. learn sales. learn sales. learn sales.
which means learning who to target, your messaging. if you target the wrong person - after all its people that buy not companies.
My last 4 months of paid work was consulting and all the clients decided to go with AI based results because they were “good enough” and getting by on a 20 dollar subscription.
It’s also experiencing a glut of out of work engineers competing for everything now.
And yes, my English is not the best, but for whatever reason, my teammates - mostly from midwest US and Californians - have never complained!
Is it really broken? I haven't heard about companies having trouble with filling positions with people they are largely happy with, so hiring seems to work as intented.
If by "broken" you mean "frustrating for cadidates", then it's a different matter. But, it could be argued that the job itself (cushy, high-paying, low stress office SWE job) is more than enough compensation for the frustrations required to get it. Similarly (but much more extreme), Navy Seal candidates go through recruitment process that is actively built for breaking their will. But, those who perservere, get rewarded with an elite and prestigious posting.
Firstly, most employers don't specifically target "best". Partly because "best" is hard to define, and includes measurements across multiple axles. And partly because it's impossible to know you have just seen the "best" so leading to paralysis.
Typically companies thus target "good enough" and for lots of positions there are several candidates that fit that bill. Sure they'll choose the one they think will be the best, but there's no way to know for sure.
Secondly, and speaking generally here, for most of us, this is probably a good thing since it's very likely there is a better candidate than me out there somewhere. If companies only hire "the best" then all us "second best, still good enough " folk would struggle a lot more.
Of course we all think we are the best possible option. Because we value our strengths and devalue our weaknesses. But objectively what are the odds that out of hundreds of applicants we're the actual "best"?
This doubly so when so many high quality people are looking for jobs?
This is the (unfortunately named) "secretary problem": how do you decide when to stop interviewing and make a hiring decision? It's possible that the first person you interview is the best candidate you're ever going to find, but you don't know that. At the same time, you can't just keep interviewing forever, hoping that you find someone better than everyone you've seen so far. But you can never be 100% confident that you've found "the best" - you just have to get to the point where you're happy that someone is better than the others.
The unfortunate reality is that the first candidates to be interviewed won't ever get an offer, because there aren't enough data points to make a decision yet. Which can be comforting if you've ever interviewed somewhere and thought you did well but they went with someone else - you might have just been too early in the process.
This doesn't follow in any way. Sure, the offer the first candidate might receive will be delayed, but if you're looking to fill a position in 1 month and the first candidate you've seen was still the best you saw in that month, you'll of course make him an offer.
And I am saying this from experience - we've often hired our first candidate for an interview in my team. Though I will admit that we don't follow much of the practices I read about and have heard from other friends, so maybe we are not typical in this either.
It got so bad I opened every interview with “You will be required to travel to San Francisco to meet with the founders, they will pay your travel expenses, is that an issue?” - and click hung up. Once had this happen 4 consecutive interviews.
I did approximately 32 interviews and maybe 8 were not NK.
There were times when that actually was the case, can you imagine?
from one of my favourite bloggers, his other stuff is very worth reading.
My take on it: the standard recruitment process is completely broken. Don't even start doing that. Sending applications to a job advert is an exercise in futility and will destroy your mental health.
It's always about who you know. You have to go find people who are in a position to employ you, and impress them. This isn't difficult. They don't want to interview the stream of idiots that HR have approved any more than you want to jump through the hoops HR think are relevant. They want to employ someone who they know and like. So go to meetups, small business networking events, tech conventions, anything that will attract the kind of boss that you want to have. Talk to people. If you can, present something.
Highly highly recommend the OP and anyone else in this spot reach out to whatever network you already have; past coworkers/managers/etc and to try and attend any kind of related events to grow your network of contacts.
It also doesn't hurt to be know as the person who can "get things done" as I've established a reputation with my contacts that I can jump in and solve whatever problems need solving.
I am currently employed, but in 15 years of my total work career, I have met 0 people who are in a position to employ me in an IT role, including my close circle of friends.
Everyone else is either:
1. Not in a position to make a hiring decision, e.g. not a director
2. Doing worse than me - aka unemployed
3. Just not in the IT industry at all
> So go to meetups, small business networking events, tech conventions, anything that will attract the kind of boss that you want to have. Talk to people. If you can, present something.
Where's your evidence that these meetups and conventions aren't 99% filled with people trying to 'network' and looking for a job just like you?
There are several parts of the process, which is roughly the same in every large tech company: 1. The decision to open a role: this is ultimately up to finance 2. The final decision of what kind of profile to hire for a role: this is the recruiter manager, often but not always the one who will manage you. 3. The decision on the process: generally HR.
In most companies, the recruiting manager will review resumes, but only after a first pass by HR.
Network is especially useful to 1) know what is actually expected (2 vs 3 discrepencies) and to bypass the first filter of HR. Even if you don't know the recruiting manager, if you know somebody inside the company they can do a referral that will in effect bypass that filter.
That's who had to make a decision for my last role. It was a director vote to open up a position in the first place.
And it wasn't even a senior role, it was just a standard analyst position.
I've also had a couple roles that started in-office with a later transition to remote, which I found quite nice since I'd already built bonds and trust with my colleagues.
I don't think this is true. It's definitely a horribly inefficient and demoralising way to get a job - you'll have to send at least 10s of real applications (not just click-to-apply or whatever), and maybe hundreds. That's potentially thousands of hours of just being rejected or ignored.
But I have got two jobs just by sending applications.
Far more efficient to use recruiters though, at least in my industry.
Because of it I was quite sick of even looking at programming jobs and even coding. Now 2 years later and I'm a plumber, the demand is good and the work is dirty but rewarding as you help people directly.
I'm looking to get into an electrician apprenticeship next year and hopefully one where automation is encouraged to put some of the coding skills I've developed to use because the pay just scales better better and the work sounds more fun.
Started coding again half a year ago, helping friends and family with websites and bots. Now even working on some personal apps to replace annoyances I find.
I still miss working from home and working together in a team with a deadline, but the trades also have their pros. Good luck OP in whatever you choose to do!
I participate in an organization that is full of "life refactoring" stories like this. I see people rebuilding shattered lives, on a daily basis. Later this morning, I'll be attending a gathering full of these stories. Many of these people are now quite wealthy (and many are not; but quite happy). I go several times a week.
That said, the modern tech hiring scene is a nightmare, compared to when I was young. In my case, I relatively recently, encountered bald-faced ageism, but that's only one of many pretty awful stumbling blocks. Young people also have a fairly bleak landscape. I'm grateful that I came up in the industry, when I did. I had many fortunate breaks.
Ironically, plumbers are people that will likely be unaffected (or will be helped) by the advent of AI. I know many tradesmen.
You are replying to someone who is talking about pivoting away from the software field and into the trades. You really think plumbers are going to be unaffected?
If knowledge fields are decimated by AI, the pay rate for plumbers and every other trade are going to trend towards zero. Nobody wins if AI drives significant job destruction.
The die is cast.
Who will buy their services in a K shaped economy?
You're set for the next 2 decades. Especially with that electrician transition planned.
Are you sure that plumbing and similar handy things are not maintaining a "broken system"?
I think programming and plumbing problems are mostly similar in this sense - both require you to solve practical problems. Solutions often nor perfect nor stable and simple, but right in current situation.
In software engineering, you typically own the code you wrote for the lifetime of your employment.
This has really profoundly different effects on your brain. A plumber can finish a job and never think about it again.
That said, there are some new coworkers who are way better at interacting with clients, but worse at the actual job who seem to also be doing alright and getting better.
I'd say sticking to it for long enough wanting to improve and letting your boss and coworkers help you out when needed makes things doable, even if you don't have a talent for it.
A cheap investment: quality knee pads and kneeling mats. Use them diligently. Pay attention to posture while working to keep the pressure off the knees as much as possible. They'll carry you thru a career if you take care of them. Walk every day to stretch your legs out (Maybe get a small dog to enforce your daily walk!)
Plumber apprenticeship opportunities for a 40 year are nonexistent as I understand it
I am curious - and I apologize if somebody else asked- but why did you quit your previous job because you heard about potential layoffs? Even of you had been laid off, wouldn’t keeping the job you had be better or more secure while you had it?
There is a reason that recruitment and a lot of what falls under HR needs to go via tooling with where LLMs are.
I genuinely don't understand this, is this a non-U.S. thing? If a company goes bankrupt and everyone looses their jobs, are the former employees also supposed feel ashamed that the company didn't work out, that they should have been able to predict the future more accurately or something?
- Layoffs are normally partial and are often used as an opportunity to cull low performers.
- A lot of people who were fired for performance also say they were "laid off".
- leaving voluntarily signals that you feel that you have options, which is a mark of a high performer.
That’s anywhere from 1200$ to 4000$ a month depending on the state you live in.
At the very least, the obvious question "Why did you quit?" needs to be answered.
Let me give you some harsh feedback.
You can't have "learned the AI" and still think coding in C#/.NET/AWS is a valuable skill. It's not; the AI codes better than you. It also codes faster than you can read it.
My strategy has been focusing on orchestrating highly automated workflows that can deliver software at breakneck speeds. I only focus on the business domains, security, and software architecture.
Try this to start: check out the /wayfinder skill from Matt and build something you could never have in the past. Extra points if it's something you can sell to a small business. A system for your local gym, for instance. Give yourself a single week.
Coding is not a job anymore. It has evolved.
A blocker exists here. I've personally talked to VPs and managers that are simply behind and refuse to acknowledge this is true. If you're applying to work and state this in an interview, they will immediately decide they need someone else, someone who can code better than AI every damn day. You cannot talk your way into a job after you say this and the decision-maker disagrees. Some things simply cannot be helped.
/goal exists for encouragement loops. If someone just needs an encouragement loop they are not hiring right now. The job is much more than coding and always has been much more than that.
But I'm very senior and so I haven't been predominantly a coder for a long time now. I keep things on the rails and headed the right direction, grease the rails, cajole teammates and stakeholders, etc.
examples: Managing your calendar, responding to emails from your students (with human in the loop review), sending invoices, following up on unpaid invoices, writing/updating your website, creating/managing your yelp/google business accounts, emailing past students for referrals, etc etc.
All of these things are very interesting from an "AI Orchestration, AI Software Factory, MCP to integrate several source systems, etc" perspective that can make your 2 years of unemployment really shine.
And the good news - you don't have to lie and say "I was building with AI the whole time", you can say "I made a career change to math tutoring for X reason, learned everything needed to run the business manually, then I recently started automating all of it like a Forward Deployed Engineer would do, and here's where I ended up so far".
You're narrowly defining coding as "writing lines of a programming language by hand." But coding, or programming as it is better called, is about creating software. It is about creating a program. A task for a computer to do. And whether it is done using English, Fortran, or assembly it is absolutely still a job.
So while you're right to point out that C# is not as valuable a skillset as it was before and people are concentrating more on higher level business and architecture requirements, the end of your post is outrage bait.
But even this is short-lived, and the writing has been on the wall for years. Hopefully you invested hard in companies that will grow as AI diffuses into the economy so your assets can throw off more income than you earned in the gravy train years of SWE. If not your livelihood is going to drop, even starting a business is unlikely to succeed as everyone else has AI to help them so you coding skills give limited advantage there.
This is represented by code too though. Or at least some form of written documentation.
Sure, you won't use anything lower level than typescript for it normally, but for complex relations and constraints, code built on your own abstractions (and with types) is still easier to reason about and make robust than some non-technical person vibecoding in English without any good workflows or collection of skills (that they actually know how to use).
Agreed, "coding" is not a job. But software engineering 100% is, design 100% is, and devops 100% is.
> check out the /wayfinder skill from Matt
How is the OP supposed to know what this means? Seems like borderline psychosis to think this is just known. Personal experience has been people who use these tools are kinda low skill, too.
Looks interesting.
Where is this mythical AI? I have not found it yet. I'm not doing C# with AI, but whenever I make AI code something (and yes this is with frontier models), both the quality and the quantity are visibly and significantly worse than a human engineer's. The code is frequently brittle and abstraction-breaking, and the tests are simply garbage. And I know this isn't specific to me because I also see this - consistently - with what other engineers send me to review too.
I would more readily buy "code quality doesn't matter now that we have AI" than "AI codes better than you."
Michelangelo's David took years to complete, many studies and iterations. The patrons that paid for it wanted the perfection such an artist could provide - that was not something to be rushed.
Software that is ergonomic, intuitive, fast, and maintainable takes time. To use the analogy - chipping away at granite is a slow and tedious process, mistakes in planning or approach are difficult if not impossible to recover from.
Taking time to do it right sometimes is the only way to achieve quality.
The problem is that, in the real world, people are neither competing for maximizing the code quality score, nor are they spending remotely the same amount of time with vs. without AI. They're spending a small fraction of the time with AI than they otherwise would have, and their goal is to ship the product. Hence why they commit bad code.
To put it bluntly, I've literally seen engineers who used to send excellent pre-AI code suddenly start sending trash for review when they use AI. And, when I push back and point out the problems and they actually put in the effort to improve it, their code quality improves to (or beyond) what they (or I, for that matter) would've written without AI. I don't know how you could get a more fair experiment than this.
So, to answer your question directly, no. (No for other reasons too, but this is the only relevant one.)
I simply don't believe you.
For personal projects where I have a deep understanding of what I want to build and genuinely care about the quality, even Fable can't touch me. Of course, AI would get a working system done 50x faster, but personal projects aren't about speed for me.
You don't care at all about (c) maintainability or fragility?
One of the biggest problems I see is LLMs duplicate sources of truth they have no business duplicating... all the time. E.g. if an internal constant in some code is X then they just hard-code X in fifty other places far away and code based on that. And it's not just constants, they often duplicate entire pieces of logic too. So everything is fine and dandy when the code is fresh, but the next time the original is updated, the rest of the code breaks, because nothing forces this update to update too. Of course the garbage tests they produce never test such hidden assumptions either.
And this is before I get to other things, like (d) test costs and (e) the limits of test matrices. That "inline assembly" you just inserted now requires you to test everything on older CPUs that may lack newer instructions. And on other architectures too. That's a huge cost and this kind of thing exponentially grows your test matrix. Or, more likely, you end up with a breakage on some CPU because you didn't care.
If you have unlimited tokens i guess this is pretty much true these days. I've noticed opus write write and remove the same piece of code in a session. They prefer to write a lot, a lot of defensive checks in python etc.
At my company I have around 4000 GitHub copilot credits per month. I cannot afford to just let the LLM finish a whole project by itself using just spec documents. I did that once, ran out of tokens and then found out i couldn't understand what was going on.
This will probably change in the future but right now I need to work with what's available to me
I'll be blunt: Claude Code using Fable High. But, it's not the only one, you can't hardly swing a stick without hitting an AI that is great at coding. If by coding you mean "produces working software". If your definition is "produces code that doesn't offend my sensibilities", then that's a different matter, and also likely something that a human expert developer likely couldn't accomplish either. ;-)
Or are you saying that the "mythical AI" is mythical because people are using it without putting in any effort, therefore producing poor results? If that's the core of your argument, it sounds like the mythical AI could be out there and you'd not know it because those around you are, to coin a phrase, using it wrong.
I'm kind of struck though that your experience seems to all be second hand (people are using AI and submitting bad code); do you not have any first-hand experience with using claude code and fable?
I'm saying that most code I see AI generate is frequently bad, in ways that nobody disputes, not even the engineers who sent me the code to review - they themselves previously always avoided those exact problems when they used to write the code by hand.
> Or are you saying that the "mythical AI" is mythical because people are using it without putting in any effort, therefore producing poor results?
This also happens.
> If that's the core of your argument, it sounds like the mythical AI could be out there and you'd not know it because those around you are, to coin a phrase, using it wrong.
If you hired a brilliant math PhD who always wrote bad code and you had to keep reviewing every single thing they did and getting them to rewrite their code until it met the quality bar every time, and they never learned from their mistakes from one project to the next so this was a persistent issue, but they were so fast that even micromanaging them let you achieve a better outcome faster than you would have alone, what would you call that? That's what AI feels like.
> do you not have any first-hand experience with using claude code and fable?
I certainly do. But for anything meaty I frequently end up rejecting most of the code they produce before they get to other reviewers, and even then, I frequently have to do more work on them by hand. In some cases I've quite literally had to restart a project half a dozen times from scratch - with different approaches each time - in order to reach results that I'm not disgusted with.
Note that I'm not claiming to be an expert in using AI by any stretch - I'm still very much learning - but that I'm not really seeing these mythical results from others either.
And shrinking the context bloat while maintaining intent and debugability is also something you'll have to get better at.
Even the experience of using a Terra-type model vs using Opus requires a different workflow because one can just go on longer and make reasonable decisions most of the time.
Kind of like driving a car doesn't require you to know how to do basic fixes on the road anymore.
Hahaha I spent hours yesterday attempting to build a solid multi tenant api with Claude code in .net. I refined it for a couple of hours, came up with a plan (wrote it to markdown files), used Opus and Sonnet to write it and used code review. It was a disaster. Loads of code but loads of terrible decisions, bugs and suboptimal data design.
14 day session expiry, active org ID in the cookie, single tables with nullable keys instead of splitting it up...I can't recall the other issues and bugs as every review for about 4 reviews in a row threw up 1-3 problems (and I don't have my laptop to view the git log)
It often just straight up ignored any hard parts of the plan.
The tests were brittle and slow despite running the tests for every change it didnt stop and fix it. When challenged it was sassy like "I think 15s isn't too bad"
Something 'super intelligent' trained on billions of lines of code should not need every single aspect of every single module explained. A secure Auth and multi tenant system is hardly novel
It basically generates so much code it hopes you won't notice all the issues bugs and footguns. Just like bullshitters like who don't shut up hoping you can't keep track of their bs
Again, it'll happily produce lots of code quickly to pacify people who want to stick their head in the sand and pretend lots of code which looks like it ticks some boxes must be correct. It seems to excel at that (I've been using Claude for various other small projects in different languages btw, this isn't my only experience with it)
"Fast, cheap, good - pick two" seems still to hold
This is all obviously false. Thinking that "coding is not a job anymore" is as delusional as being anti-AI.
But I guess this is what the industry wants to hear: sycophancy towards AI and hatred towards human programmers.
The best coder in the company I work for just said "I haven't opened an IDE in a couple months". He was a die-hard JetBrains guy, now he's talking about letting his subscription expire. I'm in SRE, and so I'm not a day-to-day coder, but I've been coding for 40+ years and it's really obvious in SRE.
I can imagine some corner cases where coding is still a job, but for the general case I think there's a good case to be made today, and can absolutely see we are on a trajectory where it's only getting more true.
If anything, coding may be something we do to FURTHER our job.
The buzzword everyone is looking for is "high-agency."
No, not those agents, but yes, those will be essential.
Basically employers want someone who will start something from scratch and take it to the finish line all by themselves. So my advice, which others have echoed here: Build something useful -- end-to-end -- from scratch -- with AI -– on your own -- that you can show off as soon as possible.
The key point is, "high agency" is by definition not something you can just put on your resume; It is something you show, not tell.
Yes, you need to do this even as you go through the absolute hell that is a job search. But trust me, this will a) help get a much better job, and b) help in the long run throughout and beyond your career. This will be the most valuable skill in the near future.
A few other thoughts:
0. Get a $100 Pro subscription. Either GPT or Claude, doesn't matter much, but you do want access to Fable or Astra. The volume and variety of things you can get done in that quota is astounding. Codex offers a free quota with Astra if you want to get a sense of things.
1. Target a domain you are already very familiar with. You can draw on your long experience as an engineer, or any personal interests you may have. Say a Math tutoring web app that your students could use. This will sharply cut down the time to MVP.
2. Being an end-to-end thing, this will necessarily be something multi-disciplinary. Think of it as doing a one-person startup, so you're going to be forced to do everythig: design, frontend, backend, infra, and maybe even GTM stuff like marketing. Yes, you may not know most of these things, and obviously won't be great at them, but with AI, everything will be good enough.
3. This conveniently also helps explain the gap in your resume. Nobody needs to know you did this in a few months vs 2 years unless they ask.
4. Even when using AI, keep your hands-on skill warm. Most companies still do old-school leetcode interviews.
5. As an extreme backup this might even become something you monetize yourself.
Hope this helps, and all the best!
They're mostly interested in things I've already done in the past that involved large amount of users, which automatically filters out all those high agency projects.
Getting many users for your projects would be an option, but I see two problems there: - finding users requires a set of skills that is completely orthogonal to software development, so you'd need to learn those skills on the side - finding users is getting harder and harder, as your new project is the 100th release of the day
Besides, if you manage to build a good project and find users, you might not need a job at all. But let's say there's a 10% chance that happens. Then there's a 90% chance you go into your first interview as someone who failed to get a project off the ground, which is kind of the opposite of showing high agency.
And the odds of success are probably closer to 1% or smaller.
When scanning resumes, I would look for interesting projects and then on inteviews, drill down deep on one or more of them to see what the person actually did, how they think about it and how they worked with others.
Unless it's a senior position, I wouldn't care about the customer/business aspects or even if they were the creator/leader or not. I hired in one country where they had a rigorous math education but the professional projects weren't a good fit. But they had interesting things to say about the technical aspects of open source projects they worked on. That's better than having to project someone's aptitude. I also let my engineers assess technical ability, of course.
If they failed to launch at all, even with all the generous free-tier options out there, I'd agree that would be a concern. But at least in Silicon Valley and many tech circles, a failure is considered a badge of experience as long you gave it a proper try.
Yes, we now have to build orthogonal skills, but that is also kind of the point. Not only does it show adaptability and capability with AI, we need to be building proof of competency that could also become a source of revenue. Because I feel like these days counting on getting a job is like having hope for a strategy.
I totally feel the discouragement you're facing, and sorry if I make it worse, but this may increasingly be the only path left for us and at least you're farther along than most. Because a) what else could you be doing instead? and b) 300 paying customers is non-trivial and may even become a source you could grow.
The funny thing about people is even though anyone can, so few do.
That is what they are looking for.
Impossible to prove, trivial to lie about. Take note how many genuine startups lie about their recurring revenue or partnerships.
Let's say a candidate even sends you IRS statements, tax returns, corporate filings, bank transfer records.. How can you, as an interviewer, verify that those records haven't been fabricated? Or even if they are 100% legitimate, how can you verify that the clients who purchased their services haven't been coerced in some way? Aka getting a few dozen friends or family to subscribe to your app while never ever using it once. That candidate could show, say, $1000/month recurring revenue for 3-4 months, while having 0 genuine users. And just for the record, a LOT of startups use this method to boost their early traction. A lot.
From my experience of interviewing candidates, I can conclude, nobody cares about your pet projects.
I was one of the few, who'd even look at a candidate's CV more than 5 minutes before the call, let alone, follow links and explore candidate's GitHub.
The hardest part is getting past the first stage, because it has nothing to do with your actual experience or skills. Latter stages are a lottery too, but at least you know the rules and can prepare. Hence the advice somewhere above to get in front of people who are already in the industry – is the best advice.
Given that, I used to always make it a point to glance at the candidate's GitHub or pet projects and bring up any that seemed interesting, at least to make them feel seen.
But things are changing, and these are not pet projects. These are complete, working end-to-end products that (ideally) you've gotten actual users for. Maybe even paying users.
At which point, it could actually become a revenue source, and hence, an alternative path.
A very close friend of mine was in a similar situation. He was laid off at Tesla and then took six months just to recover only to find out that gap in his resume met a wall with every recruiter conversation he had.
At the time I was running a company (Prebacked, roughly a startup accelerator). You're making a good deal of noise, but not a good deal of money.
Jeff (not real name) called me up and said "I'm coming to work for you". I told him I would love that and needed all the help I could get, but had no money to pay him. He offered to work for free for a time. He said,
"I'm going to work my ass off for you, and I'm going to do a great job. And when I do, you're going to give me a kick-ass reference when I go job hunting."
He did work his ass off. He did do a great job. He met some folks at our program and helped with a cool contracting project with Google, and he flipped that experience and my referral into employment at Apple, where he's been making a killer salary ever since.
There are a lot, lot of people who could use your help (many on HN!) but not be able to afford it. You need references and a closed gap, they need SWE help. Go do a project.
If you think a trade like that might help you get on your feet, please DM me. I'm one of those. I also have been told my network is... rather elite, if if not me then I could think of probably 100 people who could.
Is this even legal in the US though? I feel like the DOL would take umbrage with this being below minimum wage. I feel like even trying to classify them as an intern / contractor would be a… delicate situation (maybe contractor with fee waived… maybe)
Volunteer somewhere while you are looking for a job.
This works for MANY reasons:
- it keeps your mind occupied and avoids "doom looping" when interviews don't work out or you are waiting for new interviews
- it makes you feel good to help people
- there is a strong chance that you will either meet someone who can help you find a new job OR you find some new career path/startup idea you didn't expect
You would be ASTOUNDED at some of the crazy things that people do b/c they don't have a tech background but need to get things done. And if you help them, you better believe that word travels fast if you are good with technology and can actually make things happen.
You can also be more targeted in your volunteering. e.g. your odds of getting a high paying tech jobs might be better if you volunteer via the church or social organization in your upper middle class town vs a lower income area. But again, you never know where the opportunities are so it's good to try both.
In closing, who would you rather hire:
- Candidate A that has a two year hole in their resume
- Candidate B who spent two years volunteering and has great stories about implementing tech for charity roups
I worked with a guy that did free software services for his church. Worked with another that offered his services for the local school districts sports teams. The idea is you look for places that otherwise couldn't afford paying someone to do the work.
Heck, you could even ask family/friends. Back in 2019 a friend approached me and I designed a timer program with Arduino + C# back-end + Vue front-end to use at his job. It was for a metal fabrication company to automate coordination of metal parts in their casting oven (forgive my ignorance on the proper terms here). Last I checked, it was still in use.
You could probably start a business just calling local contractors and asking them what kind of help they need with their business.
e.g. being the guy that manages the Calendly or Google Appointments for several contractors would probably be a pretty good gig.