Top
Best
New

Posted by soheilpro 10 hours ago

My monitor was cutting my download speed by 75%(blog.tymscar.com)
384 points | 197 commentspage 5
nonacosa 7 hours ago|
[flagged]
enoch_hou 4 hours ago||
[dead]
thefz 7 hours ago|
I knew it was Apple even before clicking
skibble 6 hours ago||
No, it was his Ethernet adapter.
alt227 6 hours ago|||
When he plugged the original ethernet adapter straight into the laptop it worked as expected. It was the monitor not supporting that specific setup and chip.
aaronmdjones 6 hours ago||
It has nothing to do with the monitor's support. The GP is correct; the fault is in the Ethernet adapter. Specifically, it doesn't have a buffer large enough to sustain 2.5 Gbps when going via the monitor because the latency is too high. You'd have the same problem on many USB hubs and it would still be the Ethernet adapter's fault. It could have used a larger buffer or it could send more data at a time to the host so that the buffer doesn't fill up, but it doesn't.
alt227 4 hours ago||
I would say if a USB adapter works fine in a laptop USB port, then there is nothing wrong with it. If you are trying to use it in a monitor and it introduces so much latency that doesnt work, then thats a different issue. Its not a faulty adapter.
dcrazy 4 hours ago||
The adapter manufacturer sourced a part that could not sustain the product’s advertised bandwidth when connected through a USB hub. USB hubs are not esoteric. This is the fault of the adapter manufacturer cheaping out on a part.
tymscar 3 hours ago|||
I feel like I am going a bit crazy reading some of these comments. I don’t know why people don’t read the whole blog post to understand that the monitor works great and it gets maximum speeds when doing things like transferring files from my ssd. The adapter works great and I am getting maximum speeds when connected to my laptop. The laptop works great and I get maximum speeds when doing any of those things. The hub inside the monitor works great and I get maximum speeds through it even with multiple things plugged in at the same time.

None of the parts are broken. Together they don’t work as they are supposed to because of some super intricate process of how usb works when it comes to acknowledging packages. That’s why I wrote the post. The title is true and yeah, it’s sensational but that’s what titles are there for. It’s not a false clickbait.

nh2 1 hour ago|||
I think you could improve the post's clarity of outcome a bit.

While it's completely right, even when having read it fully, it isn't so easy to understand unless the reader knows some things (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50588459 and its children), namely:

* That the "packet size 1024 bMaxBurst 3" (making the 4 KiB window size) is fixed for the whole connection, determined by the RTL8156B, and cannot be negotiated higher, no matter if the monitor is in between or not.

* That this window size is large enough for the NIC---Mac connection to run at full speed, but not enough for the NIC---Monitor-USB-Hub---Mac connection to run at full speed, because the added latency makes the BDP too large.

* If possible to measure, it might be illustrative to measure the NIC---Mac latency without hub directly, to compare it with the `7.6 µs` number going through the monitor (like cibyr suggested). That'd make it more obvious that the monitor increases the latency.

And I agree with dcrazy's sibling comment that the RTL8156B in the UGREEN _is_ to blame. It uses a send window size that cannot possibly deliver the advertised bandwidth behind a hub.

Anyway, great post that shows that just because you buy a device that says N Gbit/s and delivers N Gbit/s when directly attached, you cannot be sure that it'll be equally fast when attached to a form of "longer cable".

dcrazy 3 hours ago||||
I read the entire post and enjoyed it very much. Thank you for writing it.

That said, I think you’re being too charitable to UGREEN. They shouldn’t advertise a product as 2.5Gb/s if it can’t actually transfer 2.5Gb/s to the host when the signal path includes a hub.

Marsymars 2 hours ago|||
That's been basically my consistent experience with ugreen - their products are cheap and work on the happy path, but edge cases are not accounted for.
tymscar 3 hours ago|||
You are probably right. I think the reason why I cut them the slack is because of how cheap the adapter is and that it does give me the speed when connected directly or if I go with flow control. Its a weird one
dcrazy 3 hours ago||
Yeah, this probably speaks to our relative tolerances for fiddlyness. Despite being in love with computers since elementary school, I have no desire to muck with things anymore. And I feel for the normal consumer who just wants things to work the way they say on the box. But consumers also don’t want to pay more than they need to, and these reference-designs-in-a-box are a trap for those users.
thefz 1 hour ago|||
> None of the parts are broken. Together they don’t work as they are supposed to because of some super intricate process of how usb works when it comes to acknowledging packages.

Typical Apple shit. Never had an issue with my Lenovo dock and 2.5G. Additionally, not having an eth adapter built in, in 2026, is enshittified hardware. Typical Apple again

tymscar 1 hour ago||
Nope. This doesnt work on Lenovo either. Nothing to do with Apple
alt227 4 hours ago|||
I think we are all arguing the same thing right? The adapter worked fine when used directly in a device but not when latency was high due to other devices in the chain?

I have had hundreds of USB devices in the past which dont work on a USB hub, its very common. The first troubleshooting step in basically any USB devices manual is if you are having trouble and you are using a hub, remove the hub and plug directly into the device.

The user went way over the top in troubleshooting this issue. Thats the first thing I would have tried. Its not worth the post and the title should really be something like "USB device didnt work with a hub, but did directly in the host" and it would never have made it to the front page of HN other than maybe to be mocked.

dcrazy 4 hours ago||
No, you are blaming the monitor manufacturer for the customer not getting the advertised speed out of their Ethernet adapter when they connected it through the monitor’s integrated USB hub.

I am saying your blame is misplaced, and that the adapter manufacturer deserves the blame because they designed their product around a controller whose USB implementation has so much inherent latency that it mathematically cannot sustain the product’s advertised throughput when connected through a hub. The manufacturer should have tested this extremely common scenario and picked a part that could sustain it.

alt227 3 hours ago||
No, Im blaming the user for overengineering and sensationalising the fact that a cheap USB device didnt work on a hub. That is a problem as old as USB itself and to go this far down the rabbit hole on it is laughable. There are plenty of other people in the thread that agree.

> The manufacturer should have tested this extremely common scenario and picked a part that could sustain it.

Hard disagree. Maybe if you bought a better one you would expect that, but I would expect a $15 2.5Gb ethernet adapter to not work on a hub right off the bat tbh.

dcrazy 3 hours ago||
UGREEN is one of the most common peripheral brands on Amazon. It’s up there with Anker. This is the market your average consumer is going to encounter. They’re not gonna know that $15 is too cheap to afford a BOM that can deliver the promises on the box in common scenarios like “plugged into a hub.”
thefz 1 hour ago|||
It was the crappy Apple display
imp0cat 1 hour ago||
> I wanted to have a one-cable setup ...

The root of all evil right there. ;)