Top
Best
New

Posted by beginning_end 7 hours ago

Detonating a pile of lead azide(www.science.org)
421 points | 286 comments
cogman10 6 hours ago|
What a mess. But this is exactly what's wrong with the US military.

This factory was built by the US government for WW2. It was operated by the government until the 60s where it was ultimately shut down. In 1998 it was later converted to a contractor operated facility and has been ever since.

We gave those companies so much money and they decided it was fine cutting corners and improperly handling the explosive ordinances under their care. We've literally given this company 4+ billion dollars, most of that in recent years with this year's spend being 270M https://www.usaspending.gov/recipient/1286c0e7-b6b5-8c72-290...

And for all that money dumped on them, what we've ended up with is the US government taking ownership of them mishandling large amounts of dangerous chemicals.

When someone talks about "waste, fraud, and abuse" This is it. This is what the $1.5T military budget is buying. Huge investments into an army of negligent private companies. No doubt they lobby well.

MSFT_Edging 4 hours ago||
Why are they not sending everyone in the chain of responsibility, from the executives and shareholders down to the managers in there with thin chemical suits?

Nothing short of permanently bankrupting anyone with power over that contractor should suffice.

The money is gone, you can't claw it back, but you can ensure the every CEO that ignored the problem has every cent they ever earn sent directly to a fund made to contain the poisons.

We do it all the time when it's a poor person. You can have your life dismantled and permanently altered over a cop having a bad day, yet these people will see every bit of protection the legal system has to offer for what accounts to gross fraud, negligence, and what should be the equivalent charges of poisoning someone's well x1000.

sidewndr46 2 hours ago|||
You absolutely can claw the money back. I don't know why people throw this out there like it's impossible. They did it with Enron, they did it with FTX. Some of the money is still out there, you can get it back.
lordnacho 1 hour ago||
Enron and FTX were situations that had built up over a few years. This thing seems to have run for decades.

Plus, those are only two high-profile examples. Do we know if this is what happens ordinarily?

switchbak 3 hours ago||||
Who is "they"? You're asking the people that have colluded with the defence industry - the ones that let this happen, to now change course and be accountable? In this administration?

"Why are they not sending" - because this IS the system - this is how it's supposed to work. Rich and powerful people do not play by the rules, that's the point.

MSFT_Edging 2 hours ago|||
I'm suspending my typical cynicism.

The US Army should be sending vans to the homes of these people to hold them to account. The house and senate should be asking top generals why they haven't sent vans to their homes.

The local police should be getting warrants from local judges to get these people arrested in whatever jurisdiction they may be in.

At all levels there should be someone itching to put them in handcuffs and make an example.

And if not, the next Luigi should have a statue immediately made of them. The depth of corruption is astounding, the system that exists to prevent vigilantism has proven it no longer serves it's purpose.

whamlastxmas 1 hour ago|||
Is the Trump admin particularly known for a lack of accountability in defense contractors?
cowlevel 33 minutes ago|||
Yes? The whole admin has been about suspending responsibilities for those who pay him and suspending rights for those who don't.
bijowo1676 28 minutes ago|||
pentagon been failing its annual audit for 9 consecutive years since 2018 (when the comprehensive department-wide audit happened for the first time)
bijowo1676 30 minutes ago||||
there is no accountability in the US government, unfortunately, because there is no competition.

all power in concentrated in two parties and DC lobby industrial complex

Spooky23 3 hours ago||||
I get your position but “evil defense contractor” doesn’t really capture it.

We’re all conditioned to hold them in deference, but the military is a terrible steward of resources, and their up and out model makes accountability difficult. Nobody is in charge of anything for more than 2-3 years.

I know from past work that they are hundreds of cancer clusters and smaller concentrations that are not reportable directly attributable to military actions and practices. A colonel says “make it go away” and a sergeant says “burn/dump” this shit.

The contractor does what they are contracted to do, and the military will conveniently blame them when convenient.

derektank 2 hours ago|||
>Nobody is in charge of anything for more than 2-3 years

This is by design and is in many ways a check on corruption; nobody is allowed to build their own personal fiefdom. Every commander will have their work assessed by the incoming commander in a few short years, and they have every incentive to report malfeasance. It’s also a necessity of the work militaries do; your organization has to be able to continue to function even if core members of the team are no longer available.

cogman10 2 hours ago||||
> Nobody is in charge of anything for more than 2-3 years.

American ordinance LLC has been in charge of this site since 1998. They are uniquely responsible.

diydsp 3 hours ago|||
> accountability difficult

I'm sure there's a huge paper trail anyone here could traverse if given access.

lowmagnet 3 hours ago||
They can classify inconvenient facts.
NkVczPkybiXICG 3 hours ago||||
But then no one would ever become a CEO :)
staplers 59 minutes ago|||
* No one power-hungry, do-anything-for-more would become CEO.. which should be the incentive.

I've considered management, leadership-level positions in the past but considering the borderline evil games my peers would play and that I'd ultimately have to participate in, always makes me reel at the thought.

cowlevel 32 minutes ago||
and so, more of these positions become occupied by people who do that naturally without moral qualms
foobarian 12 minutes ago||
I think the theory is that it's better they do that, than start armies and/or revolutionary movements
mpolichette 2 hours ago|||
We can probably cover that problem by paying them more then the average employee… maybe something exorbitant like 10 or 20 times as much…

Oh wait…

Avicebron 3 hours ago||||
> Why are they not sending everyone in the chain of responsibility, from the executives and shareholders down to the managers in there with thin chemical suits?

Why indeed.

panzagl 4 hours ago|||
This cannot be upvoted enough. Every contractor I've worked with has been understaffed, underqualified, and quick to default on any responsibility they can weasel out of. Any contractor that tries otherwise gets bought up and sat on.
hogs_get_fat 3 hours ago|||
Every government contractor isn't cutting corners or defaulting on responsibility would necessarily loose bids to competitors that are, thereby ceasing to be a contractor. If the contractor gets bought, it's because it's in dire need of rescue. (Companies with massive moats excepted - if they do shoddy work, it's by choice.)
Morizero 54 minutes ago|||
> No doubt they lobby well.

I think a lot of people don't realize that most defense contractors are mostly staffed with

- Citizens (it's hard to work/get clearance for the military if you're not)

- Ex military (~75% of the military has a relative also in the military)

- Consistent voters (~70% of veterans vote regularly)

So what does that mean? If you're a congressperson, funneling money to a defense contractor causes most of that money to go to voting citizens who will support you, and generally share similar beliefs/culture.

Merrill 1 hour ago|||
American Ordnance LLC is a defense contractor and manufacturer of ammunition, explosives, and warheads for the U.S. military. It operates as part of Day & Zimmermann.

In 1976, Spike Yoh bought the company from his father and was the CEO for twenty-two years. He had graduated from Duke University and one of Duke's facilities is named Duke's Yoh Football Center. In 1998, his son, Hal Yoh, became the company's leader. In that year Day & Zimmermann was the recipient of the National Family Business of the Year award. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_%26_Zimmermann

Three brothers (Hal, Mike and Bill) own Day & Zimmerman, a wide-ranging conglomerate with interests in contracting, munitions, staffing and engineering.

https://www.forbes.com/profile/yoh/

jordanb 4 hours ago|||
The military is now claiming that they're allowed to defy the court order temporary halting the explosion if they call it an "emergency" which they intend to do.
fooqux 3 hours ago|||
After reading the linked article, I can understand this. There's a real chance that this will explode suddenly at any moment, and with considerably less favorable weather conditions and an unprepared populace.

If I found unexploded ordinance in my backyard, there would be a similar response.

It's the literal definition of an emergency.

jordanb 3 hours ago||
They knew about it since March but sat on it, apparently until after the election.
wombatpm 3 hours ago|||
They have known since 2004 this was a time bomb.
fooqux 3 hours ago|||
Ok? I don't doubt what you're saying, but I am not sure I agree with the underlying point.

Why did they wait? Was there a change in leadership at some level? Was new data provided that changed the risk equation? Was it really "wait until after the election" or was it more standard bureaucracy that happened to align? I have so many questions.

Somehow, despite everything that's happened, I still have enough trust in these institutions to not believe that this report landed on someone's desk and they made the decision to wait and see how the election went before making the right calls. That can't be all of it.

But at the end of the day, it doesn't really matter why. The root cause analysis can wait until the citizens are safe.

bigbadfeline 50 minutes ago|||
> Why did they wait?

Because the private contractor had to pay themselves bonuses and there was no money for "dealing with the problem".

The far more important issue is that the mainstream media never mentions the contractor, every story presents the case as a sole responsibility of the US Army, which is clearly a half truth. There's a pattern here, one party gets the money, another party gets the blame - nothing good can happen when the chain of responsibility is broken, much less when the media is covering for it.

xboxnolifes 59 minutes ago|||
If you can wait over 6 months to make a decision on something like a pile of explosives, its not an emergency.
wombatpm 3 hours ago||||
Yes because the situation is so bad it can auto-detonate on its own.

Can’t move the drums, can’t open the drums. It heat, friction, and shock sensitive. And the crystal structure has changed to firm tiny whiskers that are even more sensitive.

Honestly, their best bet is to keep piling on sand. I’d worry that pumping concrete for a dome would be too much vibration from all of the trucks needed.

And let’s hope no third party state actor with drones and a grudge don’t try and trigger it.

derektank 3 hours ago||||
A necessity defense is a real thing. I’ve never heard it applied in the context of a government entity in a court order, but it might be a valid defense
toast0 1 hour ago||||
I mean, you're always allowed to defy a court order unless you're detained.

You have to weigh the consequences of defying the court order against the consequences of not defying it.

In this case, maybe an uncontrolled explosion is so much worse than a controlled explosion that it's worth the consequences of defying the court.

That this condition was foreeable and not handled doesn't make it less of an emergency.

cowlevel 29 minutes ago||
Courts are superuser. They have very few limits in what they can do to enforce the execution of an order. They can detain anyone as long as needed. They can freeze bank accounts. They can transfer money out of your bank account. They can order the production of a new batch of leaking lead azide drums.
gpvos 1 hour ago|||
They may be justified in doing so.
nielsbot 3 hours ago|||
jail time, hopefully.
euroderf 5 hours ago|||
What do you want to bet their aggregate political contributions would have sufficed to handle the stockpile properly.
cogman10 5 hours ago||
0. Because it would have almost certainly cost them less than $60k [1] to implement proper monitoring.

Proper monitoring would have cost a temperature sensor, a graphana chart, and someone to do a 5 minute monthly check to make sure the sensor was accurate. It's something that happens for my frozen french fries.

[1] https://www.opensecrets.org/federal-lobbying/clients/us-ordn...

noduerme 4 hours ago|||
Not throwing shade on your assessment, but I've left a bag of frozen french fries out by accident, and ew.
wombatpm 2 hours ago||||
Monitoring consists of counting barrels and checking for rust. Sometime after 1990 you’d have to have a death wish to actually want to open the drums.
whamlastxmas 1 hour ago|||
Putting attention of any amount and any low cost on a huge problem of negligence prevents you from later claiming you didn't know or prevents you from claiming there was evidence suggesting it was fine. Corporate American runs on plausible deniability
dualvariable 1 hour ago|||
Can we just state clearly that Republicans have their whole government philosophy ass-backwards? The idea that the government is incompetent is driven by them deliberately sabotaging the government. And then they turn around and sell it off to private companies, which invariably wind up being 10x as expensive and grossly mismanaged in the name of profits. Then DOGE comes along and experimentally tries to fire half the people who know how the government is run and we get FAA ground-stops in the middle of the day.
loeg 1 hour ago|||
> The idea that the government is incompetent is driven by them deliberately sabotaging the government.

I guess it's a cute explanation if you're a partisan Democrat, but this simplistic explanation does not address government incompetence in states wholly controlled by Dems -- California and Washington, for example.

cogman10 21 minutes ago|||
This may blow your mind, but Democrats and Republicans have had the same government management philosophy since the 90s (arguably earlier). California in particular is VERY into Reagan style government where all government responsibilities are contracted out.

The explanation is really pretty simple, both parties govern in a liberal fashion. The Republican party has excised all it's progressive members and the democrat party is just starting to rebuild it's progressive caucus.

It's why my state, Idaho, has been adopting california policies (such as charter schools and school vouchers) even though it's a Republican state.

The main difference in philosophy is what programs get funded, not how they are implemented.

derektank 45 minutes ago|||
What do you believe is an example of govt incompetence at that the state level in WA state (not at the local level, for which I can think of many)
throwaway85825 19 minutes ago||
You can start with the hundreds of millions of dollars they sent to African scammers.
cowlevel 27 minutes ago|||
It's only ass-backwards if you believe the goal is effective government. If you believe it's intended to make the government ineffective and funnel money towards billionaire donor oligarchs, it's very ass-forwards.

Btw isn't your ass supposed to point backwards? If language was consistent, ass-backwards would be the correct way around.

mathgradthrow 2 hours ago|||
I'm pretty sure that waste fraud and abuse is happening everywhere, sir.
whamlastxmas 1 hour ago|||
Socialism is alive and well in the US, it's mostly just for corporations though
Choad_20261104 5 hours ago|||
I can see at least ONE scenario where this substance was stockpiled for good reasons at first, and now the stockpiling has run its reasonable course.

Why not give benefit of doubt?

cogman10 5 hours ago|||
It's not the stockpiling that's the problem, it's responsible storage of the stockpile that has ultimately caused this problem.
Choad_20261104 4 hours ago||
yes, agreed.

as I said, the stockpiling is no longer a reasonable option. people make mistakes, and things do go wrong. I've made some. This has mistake written on at least this 20-years-later time-segment part of its existence.

nobody gets visibility when things go right with stockpiling and preventive activity.

consider prepper culture. some (old) guys I've known (RIP) spent their entire lives preparing for an event that never arrived.

I would be interested to know if they need to restock...article said nothing about that.

I have agreed in principle, but I am tempering judgement for a number of reasons. how much has the world moved on since the earliest date (1968) and today...? How much more do we know about chemistry...a f of a lot more and we will do things different going forward

responsible storage was contracted out and expertise (such as is was/is) weighed in on whether it was 'responsible'. They didn't ask you or me.

I wasn't there, you weren't there...why the polemic? why do you pivot to hyperbole?

It seems like this is just another place where rageposting has come to dominate and that's sad

duskdozer 4 hours ago|||
>consider prepper culture. some (old) guys I've known (RIP) spent their entire lives preparing for an event that never arrived.

That's always the "risk", and I doubt many of them were unaware of that. You have to prep when the bad event is uncertain, because otherwise it will be too late

sixothree 2 hours ago||
> You have to prep when the bad event is uncertain

Except this event was certain and 100% predictable.

rel_ic 4 hours ago||||
There are plenty of data points to support the level of anger here. If you haven't seen them yet, you could ask "why are you so angry" instead of "why are you being hyperbolic." The latter gaslights reasonable people.
Choad_20261104 1 hour ago||
exactly what happens with rage culture. look at how you and I are both getting demoted here...

it is UNreasonable from the get go. even my reasonable agreement is cause for rejection

OP cogman had an agenda, it appeared halfway into his rant. I called him on it but also agreed with his premise.

All i want is for people to stop assuming...

like assuming that things back then were technologically as advanced as today,

that people were as informed or as politically active back then as they are today.

that is a/THE real problem-assumptions

Choad_20261104 1 hour ago|||
It was deeply saddening throwing away all that prepper food with a 20 year shelf life he spent good money on.
jandrewrogers 4 hours ago||||
Lead azide was phased out in the 1990s. This was product they never planned to use. That site was likely selected because they had bunkers that satisfied the regulatory requirements for storing bulk primary explosives while the government decided how to dispose of them.
billfor 3 hours ago||
We phase out a lot of things and then bring them back, more recently a special type of rayon for the Patriot Missile ablative rocket motor shield, and now we have to figure out how to build special factories so we can make the material again.
realityking 3 hours ago||
The US ended domestic production of carbonized rayon fabric, not its use. As I understand the poster above, lead azide is no longer used in the DoD.
masklinn 5 hours ago||||
> I can see at least ONE scenario where this substance was stockpiled for good reasons at first,

The problem is not the stockpile, it's negligence in maintaining the stockpile.

> Why not give benefit of doubt?

Because the article?

> It appears that this lead azide has not been stored well.

Proper inspection and maintenance of stock is important to any inventory which is not immune to decay, which is most of them.

jzemeocala 5 hours ago|||
[flagged]
rightnutwingjob 4 hours ago||
In order for your thesis to hold water, you’re going to have to demonstrate how this wouldn’t have happened if government had retained the site under its sole ownership the entire time.

As if privatisation was the problem.

lostlogin 3 hours ago|||
Having allowed someone to profit, the taxpayer is left with the cost of remediation.

Privatisation is part of the problem.

SoftTalker 3 hours ago||||
Agreed. And perhaps it's just something that happens eventually no matter what you do. Many things have a "shelf life" even in ideal storage conditions.
adrian_b 2 hours ago||
This is why it should not have been stored for 22 years, instead of destroying it some years ago, when that could have been done easily and without serious danger.

So this would have never happened if whoever had it in custody would have done their duty.

masfuerte 3 hours ago|||
The government could have neglected it for free. They didn't have to pay a fortune for someone else to neglect it.
smsm42 2 hours ago||
That's how a lot in our modern society operates. Hide the problem until it's impossible to hide, then when it's so bad there are no good solutions left, block any viable solution with at least manageable fallout because it's "unsafe" and wait until it blows up randomly. And everybody feels they've done their best, and nobody suffers any consequences for the screwup except for innocent bystanders.
cosmojg 1 hour ago||
This was almost exactly what the Soviets tried to do in Chernobyl. If not for a few brave citizens literally giving their lives to go up against the party, many, many more would have died.
consensus1 1 hour ago||
This is human nature, not our modern society.
compass_copium 3 hours ago||
For everyone suggesting robots can move it:

If you work in a lab that handles chemicals that can explode like this (organic peroxides, etc.) and you find something in a state like this, the proper response is literally to have the bomb squad come out and destroy your 1L or whatever of material in place. They literally can not shift these barrels without the entire thing detonating.

analog31 3 hours ago||
My mom taught high school chemistry, and when she got her job, she moved into a lab where she did find things in this state. Notably, bottles of certain kinds of ether can form crystals that are prone to detonation.

A nearby large chemical plant had their own bomb squad, and sent it out to take care of the bottles.

jokoon 2 hours ago|||
Can't they at least use remote controlled excavators to cover the bunker with barrel of water, concrete slabs, etc to absorb the explosion and the dust?
jdiff 1 hour ago||
The bunker already is prepped for all of that from the outset, and they do intend to mist the environment with water to reduce dust.
tim333 1 hour ago||
Couldn't you try the robots at a appropriate time for detonation anyway though? If it blows up it blows up, but it might not?
jdiff 1 hour ago||
Seems like the number of barrels guarantees a speedy detonation. What would you even going to do with them once the robot's got them? According to the article, it can't be neutralized at this scale.
GolfPopper 5 hours ago||
One thing I'm curious about: I've seen it mentioned that the lead azide issue was discovered back in March 2026.[1] But at the same time, I stumbled across this from 2025: "Lead Azide Neutralization at Iowa Army Ammunition Plant".[2]

1. https://www.mississippivalleypublishing.com/the_hawk_eye/doc...

2. https://www.highergov.com/contract-opportunity/lead-azide-ne...

wombatpm 2 hours ago||
There are reports from 2004 talking about the Iowa stockpile.
Traubenfuchs 4 hours ago||
In regards to your [2]: I guess they figured out that's not possible:

> Well, there are chemical means to destroy lead azide, but they’re only useful on much smaller scale. And (it should be needless to say) they’re also only useful if you can pick the damned stuff up, open the drums, and do chemistry with the contents. This is not the case here. It would be worth your life to go into this facility and try to open one of those drums or load it onto a forklift or anything else, and the result would at some point surely be the very detonation that you were trying to avoid (and this time with people standing around it).

lostlogin 2 hours ago||
The NYT is reporting that the chemical method was viable but rejected for other unknown reasons.

Edit: I missed this ‘The documents also said that the alternative had been “eliminated from detailed study” because it required personnel to handle the explosives and would drastically increase the probability of an accidental detonation, creating an “unacceptable risk to human safety.”’

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/21/climate/army-lead-azide-b...

rootusrootus 2 hours ago|||
The conundrum: Do I trust NYT on this more than I trust Derek Lowe?
andrewflnr 49 seconds ago|||
I definitely trust Derek Lowe to understand the chemistry better.
Traubenfuchs 1 hour ago|||
Boils down to whether you trust the expert chemist or the journalists (who might have asked one or more expert chemists, might have insider information or might have made up their whole article with chatty)
gpm 6 hours ago||
> Covering it with more dirt and concrete and leaving it there is also not going to work. The chance of a accidental detonation is just going to get worse every year down there, and it’s hard to see how any work could get done around the whole facility under those conditions. Needless to say, “bury it and try to get on with your life” is not considered a reasonable regulatory solution, either.

Why isn't the answer bury it then detonate it (using the concrete/soil/... to keep the lead contained) then dig out the site and capture all the lead.

goda90 4 hours ago||
I'm picturing a giant tent with a lot of slack in the walls and negative air pressure applied with filtered vacuum systems before and after the detonation.

I imagine building a sufficiently large tent to not just get destroyed by the explosion would be an engineering marvel that we don't have time for.

strstr 1 hour ago|||
It’s an explosive. It will produce its own pressure and pop the metaphorical balloon you confine it with.

And any “real” confinement would just make it more explosive when it fails.

ajb 3 hours ago||||
I was thinking about if you arranged huge pipes leading from the edge of a large circle round the area, with huge fans sucking the air from the centre of the area through filters. Then as long as the plume gets sucked back before it leaves the circle, it still goes through the filter. But as well as the massive engineering task, it relies on the plume not rising very high.
__MatrixMan__ 1 hour ago|||
Maybe, rather than a structure to hold the tent fabric far enough away from the blast that it doesn't get vaporized, we should make a giant pile of soap bubbles. The dampening effect these have on explosions is discussed here: https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/877732
wongarsu 6 hours ago|||
It's the equivalent of about 3000-4000 pounds of TNT, or 1.3-1.8 tons of TNT. And like TNT lead azide is a high explosive, so you get very intense shock waves

I would expect piling as much concrete, soil and water around it as you can without disturbing it is useful, but containing it completely would be difficult

leoqa 5 hours ago|||
What about water? Can we instead build a sufficient perimeter and fill it with water to a depth that it’s effectively entombs it during the detonation? We can then drain the water and remove the debris?
willis936 5 hours ago||
This is a very bad idea. Water would not be contained is the worst possible thing to contaminate.
wombatpm 2 hours ago|||
It’s insoluble in water, and water facilitates the formation of HN3 gas which is about as deadly as cyanide gas.
HoldOnAMinute 4 hours ago|||
What if we used water that is already contaminated?
kec 4 hours ago||
Then you get even more contaminated water seeping into the local ground supply. The problem with this idea is the existence of contaminated water, not the specific source of contamination.
noduerme 4 hours ago||
So spraying it as a fine dust all over cropland for fifty miles is better?
compass_copium 3 hours ago|||
Then letting it seep into the water table, where it will be taken up into those plants and will be harder to remediate? Yes, it is.
skinfaxi 3 hours ago||
What will happen to that dust when it rains?
firesteelrain 3 hours ago||||
The article said the plan is to have water spraying on top to contain the dust when they detonate
Spooky23 3 hours ago|||
The disaster already happened.

The proposition is what is the best bad scenario.

There’s a former military depot a couple towns over where they dump drums of dioxin in the ground. Remediation for that entails operating a series of chillers that’s creating a wall of ice underground, and they’re then gonna be pumping water in and out of the most impacted areas for the next 25 years.

lostlogin 3 hours ago||
What happens in 26 years? Does the stuff neutralise somehow?
onlypassingthru 2 hours ago||
The solution to pollution is dilution.
lostlogin 2 hours ago||
By why is that the solution after 25 years, and not now?
jdiff 1 hour ago|||
Because continuing a process for 25 years has a much larger total effect than only running it for a few months.
onlypassingthru 1 hour ago|||
Rinse and repeat for 25 years. Presumably the ppm will be so low after 25 years, it's no longer harmful.
cowlevel 22 minutes ago||
No such thing, but presumably what that actually means is that the harm will be spread out into a slightly elevated background harm level.
dopa42365 3 hours ago|||
That's not a whole lot actually. The story seems like a nothingburger? Eventually it'll be detonated and...that's it, forgotten because nothing else came from it.
numpad0 2 hours ago||
I think they are wanting to avoid creating a plume of lead, in case there would be ways
maxerickson 5 hours ago|||
It's basically already buried. I wonder how long it would take to double the mass of the cover, and how likely that would be to trigger a detonation (lots of vibration with heavy machinery).
d0liver 5 hours ago|||
I also wonder about building up instead of down. Basically, I think you would pick a sufficiently wide area around the whole facility and then entomb the whole inner facility in a shit-ton of concrete and then detonate it. But, doing that would be very expensive and time-consuming. I kinda get the feeling that they want to blow this up partially because they actually have no idea when it's going to blow up on its own, and they want to say that it was controlled.
jefftk 5 hours ago|||
> want to say that it was controlled

Not just "say". By choosing when it goes off, you can be picking favorable weather conditions, misting, and warning people downwind (to the extent there is any wind) to stay away or indoors.

dualvariable 1 hour ago||||
All the necessary heavy machinery and vibrations could set it off and kill the people working to entomb it.

And then you get a plume of lead in the air at a random time of day, with random wind conditions, temperature inversions, etc.

This is the kind of stuff where, if you look at it funny, it goes off.

iterance 2 hours ago|||
They are on a timer. Lead azide destabilizes further in cold temperatures.
alexpotato 1 hour ago|||
Containing explosions can lead to more damage in the short term/local area due to more debris being flung about.
admash 6 hours ago|||
Because unless you're planning on having ants bury it one sand grain at a time, the vibrations of the machinery used or even the settling of the material you are burying it under would likely be enough to detonate the lead azide crystals.
Brotkrumen 6 hours ago|||
The article says that it may go boom while you try to dump stuff on it. Uncontrolled boom at random weather seems to be bad.
dumbfounder 6 hours ago||
Wait a few more years and get some drone dozers in there on good days. Maybe plant lots of trees and wait. Create a big pond over it. Seems like we didn’t put a lot of effort into this.
bluGill 5 hours ago|||
We may not have years. Nobody knows when this is gonna go, but something's gonna cause it to happen eventually as the crystals keep degrading.
lostlogin 3 hours ago||||
> Seems like we didn’t put a lot of effort into this.

We didn’t. This was run for profit and mitigation costs money.

xgulfie 6 hours ago||||
You can buy remote control heavy equipment today.
goda90 4 hours ago|||
Some are worried it might self detonate from temperature changes this winter.
nativeit 5 hours ago|||
I nominate you to bury it.
consensus1 1 hour ago|||
Burial is a long process that requires heavy equipment and moving the explosive, all of which risks detonation while there is a crew on site doing the burial. Too dangerous.
fwip 6 hours ago||
I also felt like that question wasn't answered.

But I wouldn't want to be the person operating the heavy machinery required to bring in tons of dirt and concrete and to spread it around. I don't know for sure, but I imagine the vibrations involved wouldn't be good for safety - and even if it's fine, you still are working on top of a time bomb.

thehappypm 6 hours ago|||
How do you bury something in concrete that you can’t shock even a little bit?
gpm 5 hours ago||
By slowly pumping concrete on top of the structures it's already in...
nativeit 5 hours ago||
What if the expert chemists have already thought of literally everything us armchair spectators could possibly conceive of?
gpm 4 hours ago||
I'd have a lot more faith in that if the armies approach wasn't to simply not tell the vast majority of the people who are going to be affected until the last second. And if their approach wasn't "do approximately nothing".

This reads a lot more like the people in charge are looking for the cheap and easy way out.

lostlogin 3 hours ago|||
This wasn’t the army’s creation. A private company cooked this up.
gpm 2 hours ago||
The initial situation is not entirely the army's creation. The past 9 months of lack of communication and lack of action are entirely the army's responsibility - they've been handling it since then.

It's a shitty situation they found - that doesn't make their handling appropriate.

ufmace 1 hour ago|||
Could be because, the minute they tell everyone, a bazillion armchair spectators will come out of the woodwork to demand answers to why it can't be done this or that other way and find a hundred ways to gum up the works in the courts for months or years when the appropriate experts had already correctly decided that this was the least-bad possible way and every hour of additional delay creates more risk of an even worse situation.

For an excellent example of this, see this very HN thread, which is chock-full of people doing exactly that (though minus the court cases), when the whole thread is a link to a short and clear article written by an expert in the field and world-class communicator that explains exactly why this is the best way to do it.

gpm 6 hours ago|||
I'd imagine you'd have to do it via remote control and be prepared for the eventuality that it goes boom early. That still seems worth it.
bluGill 5 hours ago||
Time is the problem. If we do a controlled technician now, we know exactly when it happens and so we can ensure that the weather conditions are the best possible.

If you try and encase this in something, the vibrations are going to happen over the months of building. If we could encase it within 10 minutes, no problem, we choose the day and either it goes from vibration; or it's encased and we're fine. The problem is, building a structure like this would take months, and at any time during construction, you risk that the wrong vibration happens the whole thing goes, possibly, on the worst possible day.

ChrisMarshallNY 6 hours ago||
I have been reading about this, and not quite understanding.

Derek Lowe is a master explainer, and I now understand.

slawton3 4 hours ago||
I left with more questions than anything else after reading this piece. Maybe that's just the nature of the event, no one knows what will happen.
analog31 3 hours ago||
Browse some of his "things I will not work with" articles, to get a flavor or for sheer entertainment. I think he's set the standard for all others to follow in science blogging. But I think he does assume a little bit of conversance in chemistry.
manwithaplan 6 hours ago||
[flagged]
DonaldPShimoda 6 hours ago|||
You can't be serious. Typos have nothing to do with whether something is explained well. In both the cited cases, the intent of the sentence is obvious to anyone with even a passable understanding of the English language.
havnagiggle 6 hours ago|||
An editor would catch such things. But I guess that's just not valuable enough to the business, idk.
rdiddly 3 hours ago||||
Seems hyperbolic. In fact it's the people with only a passable understanding of English who are the ones most likely to be confused by a typo. They're the ones we should be trying to help.

You say the meaning/intent is obvious. Know what else is obvious? Typos. One reads one's own work, spots the typo, and fixes it. What's so hard? Typos don't deserve to be defended and protected the way HN defends and protects them. A typo means someone couldn't even be arsed to read once through what they wrote. So why should I?

DonaldPShimoda 3 hours ago||
> In fact it's the people with only a passable understanding of English who are the ones most likely to be confused by a typo.

I think you're speculating from a bit of a patronizing perspective. In my experience, the people most likely to be "confused" by a typo like these are people who enjoy being obnoxious about archaic grammatical rules and wield their pedantry for clout.

To be clear, I understand that some typos are genuinely problematic because they actually change the meaning of the sentence. But none in this article were of such a nature.

> Typos don't deserve to be defended and protected the way HN defends and protects them.

My "defense" of the typos is rooted in the parent comment's remark, which I found unhelpful and condescending without purpose. It's one thing for someone to point out typos for the author to fix; it's another to respond to someone praising the article with a claim that the content of the article is fully invalidated by the remnants of a few wayward keypresses that had little to no impact on the actual message.

As in all matters of communication, context is critical. But perhaps, like the parent commenter, you find it more worth your time to remove relevant context and rail against a straw man than to actually engage thoughtfully with the ongoing discussion. I don't think that's a very positive way to participate in a community.

rdiddly 1 minute ago||
Parent comment has been flagged to death, so I can't see it. There are thoughtful and helpful (i.e. "good") ways of bringing it up, and not-so-good ones. Maybe this was a case of the latter. One thing though that should be obvious to all parties and not need saying is that a grammar/spelling/usage complaint is precisely not the act of engaging with the content of the text. It's a separate point. I would even say a lesser point, agreeing with what you hint at. And HN thinks the lesser point is boring and distracting, well fair enough, but then can we also get rid of all the comments speculating and complaining about what was or wasn't AI-written? That's just as "meta" as the English stuff.
swed420 6 hours ago|||
Typos in this age can also be a human attempting to convince the reader they didn't post AI slop, or it can also be AI attempting to seem more human.

(To me, the silent downvotes indicate some people want to hoard this little trick for themselves)

3eb7988a1663 3 hours ago||
I did not down vote you, but I can understand those who did.

Your default is to assume bad-faith. "Obviously, no human would bother to put out writing into the world. It must be a trick, where they instructed the LLM to deliberately insert errors so as to throw me off the track. Not today, clanker!"

The man has been posting for decades. Sharing his expertise in a humorous and relatable way that makes it approachable to those with only a modicum of chemistry knowledge.

swed420 3 hours ago||
> Your default is to assume bad-faith.

Inaccurate. I merely listed other possibilities besides what had been suggested. Any of them are possible, and all have happened before.

ChrisMarshallNY 5 hours ago|||
Feel free to ignore him.

I feel my world is easier to understand, because I don’t.

He’s also quite funny.

samuelselleck 4 hours ago||
Isn't this the sort of situation that all the new fancy robots could be used for? Have them move the barrels out of the liquid and clean them up.
Plasmoid 4 hours ago||
The robots can do the work. The problem is this stuff is so volatile that you're at substantial risk of it blowing up anyways. If it does detonate Murphy's Law says it will happen at the worst time such that it contaminates people's homes and causes significant damage to the nearby area.
MeteorMarc 4 hours ago||
Let the robots move it deeper underground where it can be detonated without poisoning the surface.
compass_copium 3 hours ago|||
You can not move this. It will detonate if you move it.
therein 3 hours ago||
How about building a Chernobyl style dome around it?
Analemma_ 2 hours ago||
Building a Chernobyl coffin around it would require bringing lots of heavy, vibrating machinery near it which would also detonate it.
therein 48 minutes ago||
Also true. It is indeed a tough situation.

My guess is next steps will be, injunction holds and they won't be able to detonate it. It will go off in a random unfortunate time for whatever reason and then create a pretty major incident.

viscousviolin 4 hours ago|||
It's apparently not possible to move the barrels of now crystallized lead azide, as any move can set off a chain reaction that'll blow the whole lot. It's too volatile.
analog31 3 hours ago||
My take from the article is that moving the material is what will cause it to detonate.

Anecdote: Some of my relatives are chemists. There are some more common materials that can form crystals over time, which can detonate when a bottle is disturbed. Specifically, some kinds of ether. Dealing with a lab where this stuff has not been stored properly (or abandoned and left to deteriorate) is a big problem.

lostlogin 3 hours ago||
Not the same scenario (nothing crystallised), but you have reminded me of the time my father made ginger beer in glass bottles. One got knocked and the series of detonations was very impressive.
paulvnickerson 2 hours ago||
This is awesome. I hope they post a video. Y'all finger-waggers with your critical takes are no fun.
yonatan8070 1 minute ago||
Exactly my thinking!

This whole situation sucks, and I certainly wouldn't want to get lead-posioned dust all over my home.

But since this is apparently the only solution left, we better get some epic slow-mo footage out of it!

tim333 1 hour ago||
I think we need Mr Beast with a Ferrari somewhere near the explosives and some bloke with a challenge of trying to protect it.
comrade1234 6 hours ago||
10,000 pounds of lead azide is 4500kg, so about 3200kg of lead being released in the explosion.
daemonologist 5 hours ago||
Or about 1% the annual lead emissions of private aviation in the US (leaded gas is still used in almost all piston aircraft which is, in my opinion, unconscionable). Much more concentrated, of course.
ls612 4 hours ago||
We use lead in avgas solely because we have not been able to develop a sufficiently safe replacement. The alternative as it stands now would be replacement fuels causing engines to fail substantially more often and small planes falling out of the sky at random. My understanding though is that they are close to certifying a lead-free replacement fuel which meets the same reliability standards as 100LL.
DuckConference 3 hours ago|||
They should have gotten serious about replacing it decades ago, the government is eventually going to just ban it and then any aircraft that can't use UL94 or one of the 100 octane science projects will just be screwed.
cowlevel 21 minutes ago||||
Wrong. It's used because of fear of change, which is of course stronger in aviation for the reasons you stated, but not insurmountable.
CaliforniaKarl 1 hour ago||||
What about G100UL, how have things been going with that?
istjohn 3 hours ago||||
It's not safe to crop dust the nation with lead either. It's unbelievable what we tolerate so dentists can grab a $100 burger.
SoftTalker 3 hours ago|||
> small planes falling out of the sky at random

They do that quite often anyway, mostly due to operator error.

nbernard 5 hours ago|||
For comparison, when Notre-Dame burned in Paris, about 400 tonnes of lead (from the roof) were released...
neuroticnews25 5 hours ago||
I think 300-400 tonnes is the amount of lead melted by fire, not released. This site says the fallout was 150 kg to 1 t:

https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/lead-fallout-fingerpri...

nbernard 4 hours ago||
Indeed! Thanks, I knew there was lead emitted and a casual lookup only gave me earlier newspaper articles with the far larger numbers.

These numbers are estimations: It would be interesting to know how much melted lead was actually recovered during the restoration (which I cannot find numbers for) to get a harder bound.

xattt 6 hours ago|||
About 320 car batteries or about half an American football field of lead rolled as thin as a sheet of paper.
xnx 5 hours ago|||
Thank you for the conversion to American units.
xattt 5 hours ago||
Accessibility for all!
gpm 6 hours ago||||
Enough lead to make 90 cubic kilometres of air beyond OSHA's permissible exposure level.
rightnutwingjob 3 hours ago|||
That’s a cube with sides about 4.48 kilometres long.
dead_hn_theory 5 hours ago|||
The OSHA inspector called in sick that morning.
dodslaser 2 hours ago||
Lead poisoning, believe it or not.
kristjansson 5 hours ago|||
I, for one, would be pretty opposed to aerosolizing 320 car batteries in a way I’m not opposed to e.g. AutoZone’s stockroom.

Alas, the options here seem to be few and poor

MeteorMarc 4 hours ago|||
That is what I first thought, too. Then, we used to have lead in gasoline, so this new amount will be just a small addition to all poison in the soil, allthough it will yield higher concentrations locally.
pvab3 3 hours ago||
There are simple ways to convert lead in the environment into much less toxic forms like Galena (sp.?). We've done in in the past and it seems quite practical, but I'm not sure why we don't seem to be doing it anymore.
InsideOutSanta 5 hours ago|||
For comparison, the US still puts about 600 tons of lead into the air every year, mostly from airplanes.
lazide 6 hours ago||
Notably, lead is very dense so that isn’t actually a lot of lead by volume.

It has the volume of about 400 liters of water, or 100 gallons. In ingot form, less than a single pallet, or roughly 3 mostly full 55 gallon drums.

csense 2 hours ago|
Why not set up a huge cloth dome around the site? Pressure can escape through the porous cloth but most of the particulates will be trapped.
joe_the_user 1 hour ago||
A wide variety of potential alternatives to open burning exist. The problem is they haven't been developed at the scale.

Of course, the reason these haven't been developed at scale is there hasn't been money to do so.

For summary:

https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2019-12/documents/fi...

whiteboardr 2 hours ago||
Guess the cloth would instantly become the socks in having your socks blown off.
More comments...