Top
Best
New

Posted by doener 5 hours ago

Open Social Web Alliance(osw-alliance.net)
176 points | 181 commentspage 3
enahs-sf 3 hours ago|
From a technical standpoint this all sounds achievable but how do you port the creator economy onto the fediverse? It’s a chicken and egg marketplace problem of simultaneously needing a critical mass of attention to attract creators and sufficient creator volume to drive content. That is the part I feel like this site glosses over.
Topology1 3 hours ago|
Even if this ever did gain traction, I would think big platforms would throw money at their creators to stay.
verdverm 1 hour ago||
Purpose and politics before any proof of concept? That's in the wrong order if you ask me, like getting government buy in to a system no one knows will work. Going to the government for handouts instead of competing is not a good look.

What has kept AP and AT from replacing social media - and how is this going to be different to address those issues? Those are the questions I want to see answered

With regards to establish companies, I would advocate for regulating algorithms, data harvesting, and targetted advertising. I think if we go after the last one, the others will lose their value and natural incentive (more ads, more money)

yipinwong 3 hours ago||
Ideology over Practicality is what I smell from this.

Doomed to fail already.

littlecranky67 3 hours ago||
Exactly. Born in the german Heinrich Böll Stiftung, an NGO close to the green party. They might want to be open, but I bet any opinion from center-right is not encouraged, and thats is why they have a governance section.

The true solution to open social media is decentralization without any governance, and there are already protocols and developments in that direction (nostr).

27m 3 hours ago||
bingo
AlienRobot 1 hour ago||
I checked the "Streamplace" platform they mentioned and it seems to be a work in progress, not an actual platform anyone should rely upon.
bloopernova 3 hours ago||
ATProto is pretty cool. One identity lets me oauth sign in to mu.social, tangled.org, pckt.blog, etc. Using said identity for logging in to prototype apps is also super easy.

Since reading The Murderbot Diaries, I've wanted something like The Feed. The ubiquitous common comms network that everything travels over. ATProto feels like the closest thing we have to it right now, or at least a distant ancestor of the feed.

ATProto also allowed Blacksky to flourish and grow, providing its users with a far more equitable place than any other social network.

ATProto is still in its infancy really. Private spaces launch next month, and I'm excited to be able to use that for my own Keybase style encrypted storage. There's an absolute fuckton of possibilities for user-owned user-portable data, even in this brave new agentic world.

ibn_khaldun 40 minutes ago||
Funny. Bureaucracy doesn't sound like the type of thing I imagine people want when I read about the "open web". At least not in the US where I doubt this will be influential.
rambambram 2 hours ago||
Cool, email and the open web already exist. I use them with a lot of joy. So what exactly is going to change in 2028?

I decided some time ago that I'm not going to waste my time and energy anymore on convincing other people to 'join' the open web. The open web is still open for everybody. People that want to join already did. People that see the benefits of the open web above closed walled gardens already see these benefits.

Trying to convince the masses? That's flogging a dead horse.

I'm subscribed to around 2000 RSS feeds from - mostly - the HN community. That's my own social media, without thirdparty algorithms. So keep on posting guys/gals!

> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?

Not everything is politics. Why build social media to strengthen democracy? Sounds ff*ing boring even to me, as someone who actively built alternatives. Why not build social media for fun, without algorithms? Why see social media as a democratic battle ground only because others apparently see it as a battle ground?

jasonvorhe 2 hours ago||
I didn't even need to actually look out of which direction this project was steered. The visuals, the selection of protocols, the "democratic" angle, the entire lingo. Checking of course confirmed all my suspicions.

Nah, it's all still permission-begging protocols. I'll stick with nostr.

AuthAuth 2 hours ago|
As a younger person who does use open social media. I dont trust these people to create a fun social media. They seem to miss the core things people want from social media. Its like the discussions about discord alternatives and most of the responses are "Just use IRC".
More comments...