Top
Best
New

Posted by lispybanana 10/22/2024

The Tragedy of Google Books (2017)(www.theatlantic.com)
503 points | 179 commentspage 3
mparnisari 10/24/2024|
Would it not be a viable solution to let Google scan and sell books, but force them to give the profit from the sales to the government?
DrNosferatu 10/23/2024||
I never seen an explicit mention if the Google Books corpus was indeed or not used for training LLMs…

Anyone knows more about it?

kbbgl87 10/23/2024||
> “Somewhere at Google there is a database containing 25 million books and nobody is allowed to read them.”

Greeted with a paywall on the source. Hypocracy...

tempfile 10/23/2024||
> what happened with piano rolls, with records, with radio, and with cable—isn’t that copyright holders squash the new technology. Instead, they cut a deal and start making money from it.

> “History has shown that time and market forces often provide equilibrium in balancing interests,” Wu writes.

It is completely braindead to argue that market forces had anything to do with compulsory licensing. It is a matter determined by courts in the public interest.

anoncow 10/22/2024||
Sad and criminal.
afh1 10/23/2024||
Ironically behind a paywall (and below a political ad)
LisaDziuba 10/22/2024||
[dead]
geniium 10/23/2024||
TL;DR: bye bye Google
pluc 10/22/2024||
[flagged]
datadrivenangel 10/22/2024|
Thanks Paul!
pvg 10/22/2024||
Wrong number, I'm afraid.
montag 10/22/2024||
Thanks Peter
Evidlo 10/23/2024||
[flagged]
dang 10/27/2024||
(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41917170)
More comments...