Top
Best
New

Posted by JumpCrisscross 10/22/2024

Meta Bans Accounts Tracking Private Jets for Zuckerberg, Musk(www.bloomberg.com)
269 points | 250 commentspage 2
kristopolous 10/23/2024||
I wonder if they're going to ban https://dictatoralert.org/ as well
zeruch 10/23/2024||
The irony here is that for a guy who loves user telemetry he certainly doesn't seem keen when the lens is on top of him.
neilv 10/23/2024||
In some cases, there might by a public interest angle (e.g., some billionaire backing a particular political candidate, with oversized influence in what's supposed to be a democracy), however, even if that were the case, the tracking of various other famous people suggests that the motivation isn't legitimate public interest.

It's more like creepy stalking, voyeurism, and abuse of power.

And, in the case of some celebrities, who as a category have been known to have mentally-ill, homicidal stalkers, it's even more tasteless, IMHO.

worik 10/23/2024|
> In some cases, there might by a public interest angle

In this case.

When one person burns so many tonnes of carbon, because greed and selfishness, this plebeian is interested

specialist 10/23/2024||
SCOTUS has long affirmed that Freedom Speeches, Freedom Markets, and Freedom Enterprises are solely for the benefit of the plantation class.
ChrisArchitect 10/23/2024||
[dupe]

Earlier: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41918334

Meekro 10/23/2024||
I don’t see any hypocrisy here - it would be hypocritical if he allowed tracking of other people’s jets while protecting his own, but as far as I can tell, this rule protects everyone. If someone made an account that announced the location of your car, minute by minute, I’m sure he would not allow that either.

The argument that it’s really about CO2 emissions is not persuasive – you could track each billionaire’s total CO2 output without also broadcasting their location in real time.

You can absolutely have a free speech position that supports a broad variety of political speech while disallowing the real time tracking of citizens – I see no hypocrisy there either.

Some people are also saying that he’s a hypocrite for tracking others while not wanting to be tracked himself. If he was broadcasting other people’s real time location while protecting his own, then that would make sense. He’s not doing anything like that, though.

kibwen 10/23/2024||
> as far as I can tell, this rule protects everyone

"In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread."

johnnyanmac 10/23/2024||
>steal loaves of bread

Nah, the rich get away with this more.

Definately a quote to keep in your pocket, though.

johnnyanmac 10/23/2024||
The argument is that this is public data for safety reasons (so planes don't crash into each other). What others do with that info is about as relevant as any other public data. Which these sites give little care of.

They barely care about harassment/stalking on their own platform that is objectively illegal. So i don't feel sympathy here.

>If he was broadcasting other people’s real time location while protecting his own, then that would make sense.

It's a bit frustrating how many people here don't understand the difference of precision in knowing plane data and car/foot data. What use is "Person is in City" to the point where they make an argument of "risk of physical harm?".

notinmykernel 10/23/2024||
The domain names `whereiszucky.com` and `whereisthatbillionaire.com` are available for only $10[1][2].

[1]https://www.namecheap.com/domains/registration/results/?doma...

[2]https://www.namecheap.com/domains/registration/results/?doma...

LightBug1 10/22/2024|
WBS ... Wimpy Billionaire Syndrome ...
DamnYuppie 10/22/2024||
I don't know how flexing their power is wimpy. It is pretty aggressive imho, "I can do what I want and you can't do a damn thing about it". That doesn't sound weak to me. I am not saying I agree with it or like it but it appears to be a complete power move.
norir 10/22/2024||
The strongest power move is to not even have to make a move.
anonymouswacker 10/22/2024||
Tracking for thee but not for me
simondotau 10/23/2024||
I can choose to not engage with Facebook/Meta at all, or not install their apps on my phone.
xandrius 10/23/2024||
And they will still create shadow profiles for you and track you regardless.
More comments...