Top
Best
New

Posted by AndrewDucker 10/25/2025

ChatGPT's Atlas: The Browser That's Anti-Web(www.anildash.com)
803 points | 351 commentspage 3
frgturpwd 10/29/2025|
Am I missing something here? I used it a few days ago and it does actually act like a web browser and give me the link. This seems to be a UI expectation issue rather than a "real philosophy".
danielfalbo 10/29/2025||
I don't think the CLI one is a good analogy.

> We left command-line interfaces behind 40 years ago for a reason

Man I still love command-line so much

> And it would go on like this for hours while you tried in vain to guess what the hell it wanted you to type, or you discovered the outdoors, whichever came first. [...] guess what secret spell they had to type into their computer to get actual work done

Well... docs and the "-h" do a pretty good job.

motoxpro 10/29/2025|
The games he is talking about deliberately didn't have docs or help because that WAS the game, to guess.

I think same here, while there are docs "please show me the correct way to do X," the surface area is so large the the analogy holds up still, in that you might as well just be guessing fo rhte right command.

darthnebula 10/29/2025||
Yes, if I type Taylor Swift Showgirls I get some helpful information and a lot of links, but not her website. It isn't very different than what Google Gemini displays at the top of Google search results.

Is it a webpage? Well... it displays in a browser...

But if I type Taylor Swift, I get links to her website, instagram, facebook, etc.

Is it a webpage? Well... it displays in a browser...

This isn't Web 2.0, Anil. Things change.

bagacrap 10/30/2025|
I despise the AI mode in Google and wish I could turn it off, but at least traditional results are just below it.

> Well... it displays in a browser...

Yes, a slop browser.

Kreptaa 10/29/2025||
It's really crazy that there is an entire ai generated internet. I have zero clue what the benefit of using this would be to me.Even if we argue that it is less ads and such, that would only be until they garner enough users to start pushing charges. Probably through even more obtrusive ads.

I also need to laugh. Wasn't open AI just crying about people copying them not so long ago?

SchemaLoad 10/29/2025|
The purpose is total control. You never leave their platform, there are no links out. You get all of your information and entertainment from their platform.
pimlottc 10/29/2025||
It’s also a classic tactic of emotional abuse:

https://www.womenslaw.org/about-abuse/forms-abuse/emotional-...

bradgessler 10/29/2025||
I’m surprised 1Password isn’t trying to get into this game.

Imagine a browser that lets people define sandboxes and scope credential that an LLM may access to complete certain tasks?

I’d love to have a browser download all of my utility bills for taxes. I’d setup a browser, limit it to a few URLs, give it access to a few credentials, and then let it rip.

kkarpkkarp 10/29/2025||
Reposting on Bluesky.

I like anti-web phrase. I think it will be a next phase after all those web 2.0 and web x.0 things.

https://bsky.app/profile/kkarpieszuk.bsky.social/post/3m4cxf...

fiatpandas 10/29/2025||
1.0 - algorithmic ranking of real content, with direct links

2.0 - algorithmic feeds of real content with no outbound links - stay in the wall

3.0 - slop infects rankings and feeds, real content gets sublimated

4.0 - algorithmic feeds become only slop

5.0 - no more feeds or rankings, but on demand generative streams of slop within different walled slop gardens

6.0 - 4D slop that feeds itself, continuously turning in on itself and regenerating

glitchc 10/29/2025||
It sounds like a great opportunity to poison the well. Create a bot farm that points the browser to every dank and musty corner of the web ad naseum: Old Yahoo, Myspace and Geocities pages, 4chan, 8chan, etc.

Let's flood the system with junk and watch it implode.

hollowturtle 10/29/2025|
Tangent but related, if only google search would do a serious come back instead of not finding nothing anymore, we would have a tool to compare ai to. Sure gemini integration might still be a thing but with actual working search results
tigroferoce 10/29/2025|
You should try Kagi for this experience.
More comments...