Top
Best
New

Posted by hajtom 11 hours ago

MinIO is now in maintenance-mode(github.com)
417 points | 240 commentspage 4
souenzzo 9 hours ago|
The best software is the one that doesn't change.
bouk 10 hours ago||
big L for all the cloud providers that made the mistake of using it instead of forging their own path, they're kind of screwed now
tehjoker 7 hours ago|
How are they screwed if they can adopt the source and continue patching it? Writing their own would incur a greater cost.
bananapub 11 hours ago||
for those looking for a simple and reliable self hosted S3 thing, check out Garage . it's much simpler - no web ui, no fancy RS coding, no VC-backed AI company, just some french nerds making a very solid tool.

fwiw while they do produce Docker containers for it, it's also extremely simple to run without that - it's a single binary and running it with systemd is unsurprisingly simple[1].

0: https://garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr/

1: https://garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr/documentation/cookbook/system...

colesantiago 10 hours ago|
How do you sustain yourselves while developing this project?

What if the sponsorships run out?

prmoustache 7 hours ago||
What if a company change license, drop the project or goes bankrupt?

You shouldn't expect guarantee of any kind.

adriatp 9 hours ago||
I had a minio server in my homelab and I have to replace it after the 15v because they capped almost all settings. So sad...
dardeaup 11 hours ago||
Hopefully no one is shocked or surprised.
giancarlostoro 11 hours ago|
I'm both shocked and not surprised. Lots of questions: Are they doing that bad from the outcry? Or are they just keeping a private version and going completely commercial only? If so, how do they bypass the AGPL in doing so, I assume they had contributions under the AGPL.
0x073 11 hours ago||
"For enterprise support and actively maintained versions, please see MinIO AIStor."

Commercial only, they will replace the agpl contributions from external people. (Or at least they will say that)

Kerrick 10 hours ago||
I don't understand. They've seen the contributions. How can they possibly do a clean-room implementation to avoid copyright infringement? (Let alone how tangled up in the history of the codebase they must be...)
giancarlostoro 10 hours ago|||
I hope some contributors get together and sue. ;)
tempest_ 10 hours ago|||
It doesnt matter unless someone takes them to court over it.
dbacar 10 hours ago||
Disgusting. Build a product, make it open-source to gain traction, and when you are done completely abandon it. Shame on me that I have put this ^%^$hit on a project and advocated it.
stronglikedan 10 hours ago|
That can happen to any project, hence why Plan B should be implemented right alongside Plan A whenever humanly possible.
paulddraper 5 hours ago||
Open source is not a sustainable business model.

There are two ways open source projects continue.

1. The creator has a real, solid way to make money (React by Facebook, Go by Google).

2. The project is extremely popular (Linux, PostreSQL).

Is it possible for people to reliably keep working for ~free? In theory yes, but if you expect that, you have a very bad understanding of 98% of human behavior.

conqrr 4 hours ago||
They are making lot of enterpise bucks though. And they did start as Open Source. Killing it midway to serve their convenience is the issue.

There's also tonne of Open Source that isn't as popular but serving niche communities. It's definitely harder but not impossible. OS core and paid hosting with bells and whistles has proven to be a good sustainable model.

mschuster91 3 hours ago||
There's actually three ways, the third one being academia picking up the bill which is how we got the mess that is OpenStack.

Also, Debian has been around for a few decades, although I do admit that - like the Linux kernel - that wouldn't have been possible without a lot of companies contributing back to the ecosystem.

0x1ch 5 hours ago||
> Kill open source features.

> Gaslight community when rightfully annoyed

> Kill off primary product

> Offer same product with AI slapped on the name to enterprise customers.

Good riddance Minio, and goodbye!

vanschelven 8 hours ago||
Is there a good overview of recent Open Source Rugpulls in the vein of killedbygoogle.com somewhere?
zerofor_conduct 10 hours ago|
“The real hell of life is everyone has his reasons.” ― Jean Renoir
More comments...