Top
Best
New

Posted by ksec 1/19/2026

Apple testing new App Store design that blurs the line between ads and results(9to5mac.com)
618 points | 510 commentspage 3
elnerd 1/20/2026|
In related news, 10% of Meta ads are malicious, and they have Meta seems to have little incentive to stop it.

https://www.reuters.com/investigations/meta-is-earning-fortu...

kalleboo 1/20/2026|
Today a friend of mine literally got an ad for a prostitute on Instagram. They've just completely given up about even pretending to care.
wvh 1/20/2026||
I feel these practices contribute to the post-truth society where a user looks for a fact and gets a paid-for opinion shoved in the face instead. It should be easy for the user to discern the factual relevance of search query results, and it does not bode well if the provider of the search functionality is in on the deceit.
podgorniy 1/20/2026|
> It should be easy for the user to discern the factual relevance of search query results

Is it even possible to structure incentives in such way that this happens? _Without totalitarian dictatorship methods_ if possible please.

TheDong 1/20/2026|||
The only reason that these company mark ads at all are due to consumer protection laws about undisclosed sponsored content.

If stronger consumer protection laws are "totalitarian dictatorship methods", then no, there is no path. If we aren't allowed to have laws and regulation, only unregulated capitalism, by definition capital makes right, and so apple having more money than you means you have no recourse.

Any way to structure incentives (like "we will all agree to only buy from companies that don't act unfairly") is the same as creating an ad-hoc government regulation.

trinix912 1/20/2026|||
Put a sticky ad banner to the bottom instead of mixing it with the results?
inetknght 1/20/2026||
How about: zero ads permitted at all?
LandenLove 1/20/2026||
The most insulting aspect of these kinds of changes is the fact that Apple is generally sold as the "premium" brand. You are still paying a premium price, but you are getting the "freemium" experience anyways. And don't forget the additional 30% they take on every sale on the app store.
danols 1/20/2026||
Etsy is probably the worst I have seen. Almost impossible to see. Doubt it is even legal in EU. https://imgur.com/a/ntnNVZF
rcMgD2BwE72F 1/20/2026|
Have you reported this to a consumer protection agency? What did they say?
DonHopkins 1/19/2026||
Liquid Glass was always about blurring the line.
wkjagt 1/20/2026||
Does anyone know when it started to be "ok" to disguise ads as search results? And I don't mean making them look more similar, but including them at all, even as the top results. I'm genuinely wondering how this started because it feels like such a bad idea, but everyone is now doing it anyway because we got used to it by adding it to our list of noise to filter out when interacting with anything connected to the internet.
AuryGlenz 1/20/2026||
It happened at the same time enough users trained themselves to mentally skip over the ads.
davidjfelix 1/20/2026|||
It mostly seems like this was a response to the complex world of SEO. My perception is that SEO was seen as this pay-to-play 3rd party service that was offered by "experts" which allowed you to get the leg up on your competition. Search engines saw this as value being externally captured so they offered ads. Want to buy your way to the top? Quit paying 3rd parties to play the game and pay directly.
morshu9001 1/20/2026||
Google had sponsored links for as long as I knew about it, at least 2000. That section was at the top back then and is like that today, but there were times it was only on the right side.
Noaidi 1/19/2026||
Wow, how much greed will we all tolerate?

Apple annual gross profit for 2025 was $195.201B, a 8.04% increase from 2024.

And still, they feel they can do this? I have never seen a better sign of a monopoly in my life.

fhennig 1/20/2026|
There is no where to go to, if you still want to use a smartphone. They all do this.

Regulation is the way to go!

submeta 1/20/2026||
Do people actually browse the App Store to discover what’s new? I personally only open it when I already know exactly what I want to download, for example Obsidian or Firefox. I search, install, and I am done. I never scroll around or browse for inspiration.

I am genuinely curious how others use it. Is App Store browsing a real behavior, or is discovery mostly being forced because search no longer reliably gets you to the thing you already know you want?

supermatt 1/20/2026||
How do you test for ad effectiveness vs annoyance? Especially so for a captive audience where they can’t leave and go elsewhere?

It seems like every market leader that gets ads eventually “optimises” towards making them look like not ads. Obviously they will be more effective if people don’t realise what they are, so how do they account for annoyance (and the other negatives a user experiences) while doing these a/b tests?

akimbostrawman 1/20/2026||
>How do you test for ad effectiveness vs annoyance?

In a walled garden like apple? You simply don't, just make the test gradual and long enough until people get used to it.

supermatt 1/20/2026||
That’s the way it appears, sure. But my question is how would you do it if you did care. What metric would there be you could measure if they have no choice but to use the product.
schubidubiduba 1/20/2026||
Why would you care about annoyance when you captured your audience?
supermatt 1/20/2026||
It is a question asking how you would do that if you cared. I.e how do you measure/quantify that annoyance as a metric when they are captive and have no choice to leave.

Traditionally you would be able to measure annoyance by reduced usage, but that’s not the case in a captive market, so how do you measure it?

naravara 1/20/2026|
At a glance I don’t really see how this is meaningfully worse at differentiating.

If you saw more than 2 apps on the screen at a time the blue background might serve to distinguish ads from organic results, but when it’s the only thing in your screen-view with a few pixels of the next result peeking out from the bottom, then it just looks like they’re alternating colors from one row to the next.

More comments...