Top
Best
New

Posted by udit99 10 hours ago

Why is the sky blue?(explainers.blog)
378 points | 136 commentspage 3
Darkphibre 5 hours ago|
I always loved this question when I played the 'Why' game with my kids: They ask why, and I'd ELI5. Then they'd ask why, and the process continued until I could excitedly say "We don't know for sure!! We think it might be XYZ, but we're still exploring that frontier."
thot_experiment 3 hours ago||
the pupil asked, why is the sky blue? the master answered, because the sun is yellow, and the pupil was enlightened
archildress 8 hours ago||
Anyone else immediately think of this commercial?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PbKsC4GCT5k

*Since blue is the shortest wave length...*

retroflexzy 8 hours ago||
Back in my youth, after the Internet became common but before Wikipedia, I tried to discover the answer to this and came away disappointed again and again. Every article I could find simply stated "because light scattering", and barely much more.

How does scattering work? Why does light scatter? _What does scattering even mean in the context of light?_

erikdkennedy 8 hours ago|
Yes! This is exactly why I wrote this article :)

Any other questions give you the same disappointment?

beders 5 hours ago||
How can light "bounce off" something if it doesn't have mass?
numpad0 8 hours ago||
Funniest memory re: Rayleigh scattering: in anime show Aldnoah Zero, the uber-genius protagonist mansplains about it to a high profile girl, basically completely out of blue. An impostor of the girl later appears on an in-universe pirate broadcast, making an agitating environmentalism talking point using a technically incorrect explanation of the phenomenon that isn't consistent with the fact. The ever-right protagonist immediately notices it, having enlightened the girl previously on that exact topic, and it leads to actions.

Like, dude, as if anyone would care about such a highly technical point, like eg some React framework quirk or race condition mitigation for specific generation of Intel procesdor or a semi-well known edge cases with btrfs inode behavior, even if I had been on that exact camp.

manojlds 4 hours ago||
So are there animals that see a violet sky?
TuringNYC 8 hours ago||
Brilliant explanation and beautifully presented. I wish I had a technical writer who could write up our business case this well!
erikdkennedy 8 hours ago|
I'm the writer of the article, and happy to chat. Email is my username at gmail.
liquidise 8 hours ago||
Your blog layout, particularly on desktop, is brilliant.
erikdkennedy 7 hours ago||
My day job is UI design, so I especially appreciate this

(Is there something in particular you're referring to? I feel like sticky nav and sidenotes aren't particularly unusual?)

zkmon 5 hours ago|
Okay, why does visible light have that range of frequencies?
smegger001 5 hours ago|
because they are the frequencies that pass though water most readily, and we are made of mostly water
jet98 5 hours ago||
that's interesting. I thought it was because our sun's spectrum has the most energy in visible light band - therefore we evolved to see the light which can give us the highest SNR.

Can you be more specific?

nostrademons 2 hours ago||
The sun's spectrum doesn't have the most energy in the visible light band, though it's close. Most of the energy is in the infrared band:

https://sunwindsolar.com/blog/solar-radiation-spectrum/?v=0b...

Both the "because that's what the sun emits" and "because we are mostly water" explanations are incomplete. There are plenty of other animals [1] that can "see" infrared.

The real reason is simply because that's how we evolved. That's how the "because those are the frequencies that pass through water" explanation comes into play: vision first evolved in aquatic animals, so frequencies that don't penetrate water wouldn't have been all that helpful to their survival and reproductive success, and so wouldn't be selected for. But that's incomplete too: salmon are one of the top IR-sensing animals and they live in water, so when there's an evolutionary need to select for IR vision, it happens. The reason we "see" in the visible light range is simply that that's how we've defined "visible".

There are some physics reasons as well, notably that most mammalian body structures emit heat, which would blind an animal that relies on infrared to see (notice how most of the animals that can see infrared are cold-blooded reptiles, fish, and insects), and that most of the high-resolution biochemical mechanisms that can convert electromagnetic waves to electrochemical nerve impulses operate in the visible light range. Structures that convert infrared radiation to nerve impulses are more complex and more costly to support, so unless there's a clear survival benefit for the species, they tend to get selected away.

[1] https://a-z-animals.com/animals/lists/animals-that-can-see-i...

More comments...