Top
Best
New

Posted by terminalbraid 3 hours ago

Illinois Introducing Operating System Account Age Bill(www.ilga.gov)
156 points | 183 commentspage 2
saityi 2 hours ago|
Even if open source operating systems comply and add such a feature, what's to stop individual people from removing this and blocking the API requests before they install the OS? Or providing dummy responses? They're open source, after all.

Is the government going to require some sort of automated checks that verify every person who connects to the internet has this API on their OS and go after individuals that aren't in compliance?

desireco42 1 hour ago||
Why would California be dumb alone, let's show them we can be too... I don't know how else to read this.
1970-01-01 2 hours ago||
The "one weird trick" that all government hates? Stop forcing OSes to function with accounts. "User account" is an artifact of UNIX. You don't need an account to start a car, send and email, nor boot an operating system. I know it's hard to grasp, but it's true.
datsci_est_2015 2 hours ago||
> You don't need an account to start a car, …

Don’t say this too loud please, I don’t honestly think we’re too far from this reality, at least from an “Overton Window” point of view.

gruez 2 hours ago|||
What's the "user account" for an iPhone? Sure you might have to sign into icloud, but that's not mandatory. It's effectively a single user system.
1718627440 1 hour ago|||
The "User account" of the OS are the security contexts. You can say everything should be a single security context, and this is how a lot of people have been operating their MS Windows machines, logging in as admin constantly, but this is a stupid idea and comes with risks. Even when you say the OS can have a second root account, that the user never gets to use, you have two user accounts.
1970-01-01 1 hour ago||
You're conflating profiles with user accounts. "Admin user" didn't exist until Windows NT. You don't need permission to change your clothes!
thoughtpalette 2 hours ago||
Growing up, I vividly remember user accounts being important for our families personas on Windows XP. There's definitely a place for them, but there should be an option to not use one.

Unless your specifically calling out accounts that require online registration for the OS. I'm vehemently against that requirement.

albertsw 2 hours ago||
How old is root?
worksonmine 1 hour ago|
$today - 1970-01-01T00:00:00
TheChaplain 2 hours ago||
Curious how OpenBSD or Haiku will comply.
prmoustache 2 hours ago||
For what I understand, OpenBSD could just patch useradd so that the age category is mentionned in the comment field of /etc/passwd or a random text file in /etc.

Haiku could just run an automatic dialog asking you if you are minor, in Illinois or California and write a text file with the corresponding age category of said person.

These bills do not mandate that the user cannot modify that information AFAIK.

JCattheATM 2 hours ago|||
I can't imagine OpenBSD would be bothered by laws specific to a very small selection of US states.
dpe82 2 hours ago||
By adding a simple birthdate field to your account info and a system API of some sort for retrieving the account owner's age range, same as everyone else.
fhn 2 hours ago||
These people are just so clueless. All they will find is that everybody on the internet is an adult.
TutleCpt 2 hours ago||
My future OS: https://agelesslinux.org
clcaev 2 hours ago||
How will public libraries comply?
bigbuppo 54 minutes ago|
Presumably they'll burn down the libraries.
johnisgood 2 hours ago||
What is the reasoning behind this exactly? Yeah, I know Meta is behind it, but surely they will throw it out if it is absord, right... right?
thrill 2 hours ago|
“Use of this computer is illegal in the state of Illinois - your friendly neighborhood SWAT team has been notified.”
More comments...