Top
Best
New

Posted by garycomtois 2 hours ago

Please Use AI(shawnsmucker.substack.com)
490 points | 188 commentspage 2
Chinjut 1 hour ago|
Hypocrite didn't even use AI to write this lovely poem.
JSR_FDED 2 hours ago||
Beautifully expressed. Using AI to remove even more opportunities for human contact is a tragedy.
delichon 1 hour ago||
OK, but you could write the same thing as "Please read books". Many times I have learned things from reading I could have learned, e.g., from a crotchety old neighbor in return for interacting with him.
dietr1ch 1 hour ago|
Yeah, but no one has a book on pretty much anything at their fingertips that you open and find a hopefully good chapter on what you wanted.

With books you needed to consult people on which book to read first.

cortesoft 32 minutes ago||
No, you go to the library and find the book. That is what I did before the internet.
NoGravitas 7 minutes ago||
And there's someone working at the library who can help you find the right book to meet your need, if you talk to them.
mchl-mumo 41 minutes ago||
Oh to be human!
patates 1 hour ago||
If AI is not that special, just a tool, then treat it as such.

If AI is special, unlike any other tool, why aren't you using it that much?

I personally don't think it's anything special, and if I knew I'll die soon and were planning my last trip with my child, I'd use AI, just like I'd use a credit card, or my phone.

It allows me to spend more time with other people, getting boring tasks done much quicker.

Waterluvian 1 hour ago||
We're optimizing the soul out of being human.

I don't think it began with AI. We repeatedly catch the car we're very deeply programmed to chase. We want to minimize discomfort, risk, suffering, adversity. We want to maximize safety and comfort. We want all of our kids to make it to adulthood. We want to disinfect the planet of all diseases. We want our bodies to survive a career. We want our families to survive every winter. Those goals are all completely sensible.

But parents, for example, have been here before and recognize that optimizing these sensible goals have a consequence of missing the richness in the journies we no-longer need to take. So have those who have grappled with social media addiction or the withering effect of sedentary careers, or even the little things like waiting at the radio for your favourite song, your finger hovering eagerly over the record button of your cassette player.

I think this is going to be the supreme challenge. We're wired to seek the destination of comfort, but we lose the journey to reach it. It was easier when we had no choice. But we're doing a great job optimizing the soul out of being human.

yanis_t 1 hour ago||
Or just use AI when it makes sense, and call your friends too. Why do we have to over-dramatize everything?
happytoexplain 1 hour ago||
I don't see anything over-dramatic. He's writing about a real problem affecting real people, and he's not exaggerating. Just because you believe you are balancing things properly doesn't mean everybody should just shut up about it.
frozenseven 52 minutes ago||
>a real problem

Like him not getting his way? If you don't want to use AI, then don't. But I'll use it whenever I want, thank you very much.

Zambyte 1 hour ago|||
Many people don't know "when it makes sense". This highlights when it does not make sense.
pandoro 1 hour ago|||
The problem is that we have incentivized efficiency over authenticity even in our inter-personal relationships. It's a systemic issue. It makes it very hard for most of us to resist the sirens of "let me just rephrase this important message so that it sounds more elegant/well-written/relevant/...". In the current cultural and societal context you need to swim against the current to _not_ be using AI for everything. So I don't think this is over-dramatization. Overall, on a societal level, we truly are moving in a direction where we are robbing ourselves of real, authentic moments by using AI because it's "convenient/efficient/easy/etc...". Even at work.
almostdeadguy 1 hour ago|||
I think its fascinating how many people in tech think there's a clearly defined and agreed upon "right way" of using this technology that everyone knows and abides by. Paul Graham, for example: https://x.com/paulg/status/2058871512451412457

It's like we memory holed the last 20 years of social media that was supposed to be all upside; just democratic, global connectionism, empowerment, etc. I have too much exposure to people using AI in various, even sometimes subtle "wrong ways" to really agree.

theideaofcoffee 1 hour ago|||
The same predictable comment comes up whenever there is a piece that isn't sanitized, blunted technical documentation. Why write long form literary pieces that take effort to digest when you can get a cliffs note. Why write poetry when you can write a tweet. Why have anything resembling anything with humanity when there are summaries and machine written slop.

This sort of comment plays exactly into the thrust of the piece.

gordian-mind 1 hour ago|||
"Ten scenarios that I invented in which AI is making my life miserable."
honeycrispy 1 hour ago|||
Or you could use AI to explain to you how you missed the point.
solenoid0937 1 hour ago||
I'd have thought people that are technologists at heart would have understood the benefit of the next Industrial Revolution but all anyone wants to do is whine about it.
peesem 1 hour ago|||
even if this stuff is the "next Industrial Revolution", the Industrial Revolution was famously Not Good for many, many people
honeycrispy 1 hour ago|||
I see this false equivalency argument everywhere. Just because one revolution had one effect does not mean they'll all be the same.
happytoexplain 1 hour ago||
Nor does it mean people negatively affected at the time were wrong to fight for the quality of their family's lives. Anybody would do that. Also, the unfolding of inevitable changes can be managed by governments to reduce harm (they just usually don't because that would mean a slower increase in profit, directly or indirectly).
randusername 1 hour ago||
Reminds me of that silly Adam Sandler movie Click (2006).

In that movie only the protagonist had the magic remote to fast-forward through existence. It was a tragedy of self-destruction.

But what if everyone gets the remote at roughly the same time?

layer8 10 minutes ago||
Vernor Vinge’s “bobble” series provides a variation of that scenario: https://www.goodreads.com/series/57273-across-realtime
cpt_sobel 1 hour ago||
This movie hit harder than my highest expectations from an Adam Sandler movie.
alf42red 53 minutes ago||
After skimming through this, I want to write a post about how others are living their lives wrong. It must really feel great to be right about things on the internet. How do I start? I guess I'll just ask AI ...
g-b-r 28 minutes ago|
8 years after making that account you finally decided to use it to write that, congratulations
jdw64 1 hour ago|
I am truly envious of people who have the luxury of a supportive environment that allows them to write a post like this.

For my first dev job, I was made to set up a sole proprietorship just so the company could illegally dodge minimum wage and severance. I didn't get mentored; I learned through constant abuse. It was only when I first used AI that I realized the people around me were teaching me garbage and my books were completely obsolete.

I envy that this person was surrounded by people who cared. Before AI, trying to learn programming just meant dealing with insults. They can stay in touch with their network because they were respected. I had zero people in my environment for intellectual discussions or programming.

It really shows how your environment shapes your relationship with tools. I have a love-hate dynamic with AI. It frustrates me that my manual coding skills are degrading, but I'm incredibly thankful for the easy access to knowledge I never had. At the end of the day, reading this just makes me envy those who get to live and work in a warm, respectful setting.

g-b-r 32 minutes ago|
Buddy, I have no idea what happened you, but I never heard someone linking learning programming to insults.

It seems unlikely to have happened to anyone else, ever.

"Before" AI there was internet, and before that often just your room, your computer, and tinkering with it for years before meeting anyone else with the same interest.

And trust me that there are many books better than AI.

I'm sorry for your experience, anyhow

jdw64 23 minutes ago||
[dead]
More comments...