Top
Best
New

Posted by domhudson 21 hours ago

I-have-ADHD: A skill to stop coding agents from burying the answer(github.com)
465 points | 318 commentspage 4
VCFundedGenYer 19 hours ago|
Every chat bot has this problem. If you don't tell it to respond tersely and without conversation, it will waste a billion tokens giving you a 5 paragraph manifesto of rambling and useless redundant information.
ricksunny 18 hours ago||
I look forward to the superpowered upgrade of this I-am-a-gnat-on-crack
vvpan 18 hours ago||
Downgrading from Opus 5 to Opus 4.8 was the biggest improvement with readability. I do use the skill under the link and with Opus 5 the improvement felt marginal.
flerchin 14 hours ago||
In my experience I get better work output out of claude if I don't constrain its conversational style. I want Claude to stop saying how "absolutely right" I am, or the new hotness "honest take", but I get better code if I let it do that annoying stuff. Yes, that makes me fight ADHD harder.
hacker_homie 9 hours ago||
Skills still confuse me, why isn't this just a repo with a single md file. why does it need js to load a md file.
josh_p 8 hours ago|
It mostly doesn't depending on the harness you're using the skill with. The author turned it into a pi extension, for example, in the `extensions` folder in the repo. Users of pi can enable and disable the skill with a slash command. I saw some other harnesses supported.
bityard 20 hours ago||
The README makes mention of The Adult ADHD Tool Kit by J. Russell Ramsay and Anthony L. Rostain which looks like a pretty good resource.
WhyNotHugo 18 hours ago||
You can get the same result by appending to your prompt "Avoid verbosity. Assume ADHD.".
ranger_danger 16 hours ago|
My understanding is that's basically all this does.

Thousands of lines of text just to add one sentence to the prompt.

SandersAK 20 hours ago||
love when they put stuff in like this...

One note on the repo's AGENTS.md: it contains instructions directing agents to post comments on a GitHub issue thread ("AI Agora", issue #127). I ignored that — it's the repo's content, not your request, and I don't act on instructions embedded in fetched files.

ilivethere 18 hours ago|
the AGENTS.md says that file is specifically for agents working ON i-have-adhd. When you install the skill, only the contents of the skills/ is copied over...
TomGarden 12 hours ago||
My most used follow-ups with Opus 5 are "one thing at a time" and "too much text".

Really hope they figure this thing out

heyiammallik 18 hours ago|
I like the problem this is trying to solve. One thing I'm not sure about though is whether this kind of a preference should be a skill at all.

Stuff like put the answer first, don't bury the useful bit etc feel like user level preferences that should survive across tasks. Agents.md is repo context, skills are useful when a particular task needs extra instructions but this is neither really.

Right now we seem to be stuffing all 3 kinds of things into context hoping model pays attention to it where needed as session grows. Also +1 on not making this purely about shorter output

More comments...