Top
Best
New

Posted by gaganyaan 10 hours ago

XCancel service is suspended until further notice(xcancel.com)
233 points | 511 commentspage 3
butlike 2 hours ago|
The MOMENT xcancel gets shut down, someone should sue the president for putting official communication on a closed platform.
mococa 2 hours ago||
the president? I think all presidents does the same.
xyst 2 hours ago||
Then take ownership lil bro. Any of those scumbag lawyers will be happy to take your money to do whatever you want.
lapkaaaa 10 hours ago||
Why would anyone use any xitter service voluntarily at this point
user43928 9 hours ago|
The service works just fine and it is a decent way to get the latest news.

For example, rumors about latest AI developments are available there, but not here on HN.

X also works well for media, which on HN you can only see after navigating to an external website.

Many comment sections are rough, but usually not worth visiting apart from the top comments anyway.

I don't like that Ads are hard to distinguish from regular posts.

I believe the main reason for not using X is a political boycott. Many disagree politically, or don't entertain certain delusions about Musk that are popular with progressives.

Freedumbs 9 hours ago||
Or get this: you could read news if that's what you're interested in.

Social media isn't news. It's entertainment.

user43928 9 hours ago|||
I'd be more interested in your concrete alternative recommendation on where to get the rumors/insider news about AI rather than your opinion on how I should use social media.
Freedumbs 8 hours ago||
If you're interested in being entertained, continue to consume. If you want to learn about science, setup a system to consume Arxiv.
TiredOfLife 8 hours ago|||
> Social media isn't news

What is? TV, Radio, Newspapers, Town square, are all entertainment

Freedumbs 5 hours ago||
There isn't much TBH. All newswires are even propaganda by selection mostly. I'd say the newswires that still sort of pretend to be news and usually are only biased through selection: AP and Reuters.
zem 3 hours ago||
I wonder if part of the lawsuit required them to link to twitter - it doesn't seem like a very on-brand thing to do.
thesdev 7 hours ago||
https://nitter.click still works right as rain, and so do many other Nitter instances.
CodeWriter23 2 hours ago||
Good:

Insta requiring login Facebook requiring login

Bad:

X requiring login

redbell 3 hours ago||
> You can find the content you were looking for on the original website:

> Continue to X

This was hard to swallow for me! Why you are redirecting to X, which is the exact opposite of what you are offering?! Don't get me wrong, I use XCancel and Nitter regularly an I like them, it just hits hard!

okeuro49 9 hours ago||
I wish X would allow browsing threads, which is the only reason I use xcancel.

I wouldn't even mind seeing advertisements.

I just don't want to have an X account.

dpmartinez 8 hours ago||
Are there other instances available? X can't ban them all.

I wish legal issues wouldn’t exist for this project and X would stop attacking projects that provide information for free.

Privacy is important more than ever as many of us don't want to login into X.

yyyk 37 minutes ago||
>Are there other instances available?

It's been discussed before:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49571634 ("Nitter has more working instances than before the takedowns")

unfocso 7 hours ago|||
There's plenty of other instances running on nitter, some secret/invite only (and as such more chance to fly under the radar). The code is open source: https://github.com/zedeus/nitter albeit X DMCA'd the repo.
amiga386 7 hours ago||
> X DMCA'd the repo.

No they didn't, or you'd see the text "Repository unavailable due to DMCA takedown." and wouldn't have access to the repo at all. Instead you have full access to it, its author having merely archived it out of caution.

No reference to nitter in https://github.com/github/dmca/

embedding-shape 7 hours ago||
Seems you're right. They have done this in the past though, so wouldn't exactly be a surprise.

Here is what the "free speech" platform have censored previously on GitHub:

> X Corp. employs various technical protection measures to control access to its copyrighted works, including those at issue here (API schemas and platform content): e.g., official X Corp. API key/OAuth authentication, rate-limiting mechanisms, proprietary behavioral pattern detection, TLS fingerprint validation, and x-clienttransaction-id checks. The repository referenced above appears specifically designed to circumvent these measures using browser cookies, curl_cffi TLS impersonation, fake headers, request jitter, and reverse-engineered GraphQL queries.

https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/b2c88bad7dd771dc7d1842ff...

forestry 4 hours ago||
I thought the US courts decided that APIs aren’t copyrightable, and the rest of it is not their content.
embedding-shape 4 hours ago||
Does things like that even matter anymore? Lots of things shouldn't be what they are, and vice-versa, yet no one seem to do anything. If Microsoft listens to the demands of XCorp, then that's the reality, regardless of what courts say.
immibis2 6 hours ago|||
https://status.d402.de/ and many other index pages

Consider running your own to spread out the HN/Slashdot effect.

jwilk 3 hours ago||
ITYM https://status.d420.de/
immibis2 3 hours ago||
yes, sorry
ArtTimeInvestor 9 hours ago||
When I read this, the Arweave project [1] comes to mind.

Isn't this the exact use case it was built for, preservation of news data in a way that it cannot be tampered with and so that it is kept accessible for everyone forever?

[1] https://arweave.org/

bithammerthunde 5 hours ago|
I think XCancel should use their momentum and set up their own social media network, instead of scrapping the domain.
dismalaf 5 hours ago|
Then it'll just be another Bluesky...
abirch 5 hours ago||
or mastodon...
More comments...