Top
Best
New

Posted by doener 5 hours ago

Open Social Web Alliance(osw-alliance.net)
172 points | 180 comments
croemer 3 hours ago|
The prose is so fluffy and hard to read. This is the first sentence:

> A shared, standardised communication protocol: it may sound technically complicated, but it is as simple as it is brilliant, and the technical blueprint has long been familiar to all of us: email.

The only visible text on the first screen is even less informative:

> A better internet for everyone is possible. Today. How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing? The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.

If this wasn't #1 on HN right now I wouldn't even have scrolled past the first screen.

The doc was written by the Heinrich Böll foundation, Germany's Green party think tank (my preferred party). I first thought it might be LLM writing, but it might just be German habits leaking into English.

brightball 1 hour ago||
I’ve been pushing for an email based decentralized social network for years so I’m thrilled to try this out.

It’s the only approach that has ever made sense to me. We all have them. We all have ample storage for them. It’s the only option that will “just work.”

cowlevel 36 minutes ago||
We have an email based decentralised social network. It's called email. If you want more, first you have to define what you want.
rdiddly 3 hours ago|||
It may sound technically complicated --> It's doomed
bita_nidir 2 hours ago|||
To the OSW guys, you're going to get an army of bots and money thrown against you by the social media mafia. Trolls trying to derail the conversation. Don't get demoralized.
carlosjobim 54 minutes ago|||
It's schizophrenic to think in that way. If there was any "social media mafia" they wouldn't care about what people here write.
croemer 1 hour ago|||
Can you explain how your reply relates to my comment? Are you suggesting I'm part of an army? A bot? Paid for? Member of the social media mafia? Troll?
anurodhp 3 hours ago|||
[flagged]
thefourthchime 15 minutes ago|||
I'm an old cynical person, I suppose, but the first thing I thought when I saw this was, "oh great, a manifesto". This will go nowhere. Things get built upon things that are already built, that have use and people like. You have to start with something. This is nothing.
Phileosopher 2 hours ago|||
From my experience, one of the key components of effective communication is brevity, and that's exponentially more important when there's more information (i.e., it's more important today than ever before).

Also, specificity is important, though brevity and specificity have tradeoffs with each other.

I, too, am immediately skeptical of a "shared, standardized communication protocol" that is "as simple as it is brilliant", especially when they're trying to say email would be the basis. As it stands, the email protocol suite is already a hot mess of brilliant, well-engineered complexity.

I'm also, as a protocols-over-platforms FLOSS misanthrope, wondering what actual value they're adding here. My absolutely off-the-cuff guess is that OSW will try to be the new Web3.

Groxx 3 hours ago|||
I think they're going to... lobby the government to pay them for coming up with a protocol? And somehow that leads to "big tech platforms are hardly relevant" by spring of 2028 (timeline in the policy pdf).

Skimming through leads to nothing except "this should be done, therefore we will win, give us ten [p29], no thirty [p31] million dollars" without even stuff like "why we are a good choice for this money". It's impressively content-free text.

croemer 3 hours ago|||
Page 7: "That is why the German Government will ... provide adequate resources for existing funding schemes, both for infrastructure and innovation, including the simplified combination of public and private funds (e.g. through the Sovereign Tech Agency (STA), Zendis, EDIC or Sprin-D) in order to fully capitalise on the potential already identified, as well as the initial pilot funding via the Prototype Fund, STA and Sprin-D: a total of €36 million would be sufficient to provide for the ecosystem over the long term. This includes start-up funding of €15 million for key infrastructure components of ActivityPub and AT Proto, closing technical gaps, and developing key design features and bridging services; a €10 million transformation and innovation fund (including for journalistic services), a €10 million investment fund (50% of the total volume) and €1 million for the secretariat function within the governance structure."

I'm confused, they will provide it? But then why does it say "a total of €36 million would be sufficient to provide for the ecosystem over the long term". Would be or will be?

I see, then on page 11 it says " The public financing for infrastructure as well as the first round of seed funding from public and private capital for innovations and applications (see 2.3 Funding) are scheduled for spring 2027."

It seems to mostly be an optimistic plan, assuming/pretending that other actors behave exactly as wished for. Strange document.

eastbound 3 hours ago|||
Isn't that how our world is actually decided? Most middle to high management invests without having proof of ROI or having studied alternatives (note, they can't, but it doesn't remove that most projects aren't implemented with the right ideas).
dieselgate 3 hours ago||
The nested colon is pretty rich.
tech_ken 3 hours ago||
> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?

> A shared, standardised communication protocol

Over the last decade I've been left so cold by these attempts to 'fix' democracy via cleverly engineered tools. I think the problem is not one that we can engineer ourselves out of. Furthermore we've known the solution for longer than we've had digital technology: talk to people, build a coalition, wield power to make a (positive) material impact in peoples' lives. Trying to make the solution more complicated than that is not only a waste of time, but I think it's actively harmful as it pulls resources away from the things that we know work.

wry_xy 2 hours ago||
The problem is education. Humans reacting emotionally instead of logically. Everything else is a symptom of that disease. What good is a healthy democracy full of people agreeing on something that isn't even true?

A populace with critical thinking skills and the ability to regulate their emotions is immune to all the bullshit we jump through hoops placing bandaids on.

MatekCopatek 36 minutes ago|||
Human emotions are a deeply nested and integral part of us as beings. It's impossible to just dismiss them.

But even if I try to consider this scenario for the aake of the argument, the biggest issue I see with it is that it puts incredible individual responsibility on everyone.

E.g. where I live we make cigarettes extra expensive, put explicit pictures of cancer patients on the box and prohibit all tobacco product advertising. We could simply educate people and expect them not to smoke, but we know it doesn't work as well. It puts every single person in a fight against corporations spending millions on psychological research and targeted advertising.

IMO government regulation isn't bullshit and bandaids, it's citizens focusing power in a bigger entity that can then fight a slightly fairer fight against those odds.

pizzafeelsright 2 hours ago||||
The most educated people run and work at companies that extract resources from the poor and kill the weak.

A new way of thinking is required to find peace and kindness.

cowlevel 35 minutes ago|||
Just the other day I was recommended to apply for a high frequency trading firm. The pay makes it such a no-brainer regardless of what you think of the ethics. The problem is that society has given these firms so much money.
strangegecko 2 hours ago||||
I'd say maybe they're very educated, but it's jagged / incomplete education that lacks exposure to and practice of things like non-violent communication, finding common ground, empathy, or ethics.

From my perspective, better education would help enormously. As long as you don't use the narrow definition of education that only contains subjects like maths/physics/chemistry.

kymiah 1 hour ago||
This!!! how I dream about a world where everyone understands that.
wry_xy 2 hours ago||||
Simply being "educated" is not sufficient. The type of education matters. There are some very dumb brain surgeons and rocket scientists out there who are great at their jobs, and nothing else.
ghusto 40 minutes ago|||
Depends what you mean by education. In the classical sense, they're mongoloids. In the modern sense, they're highly educated.
akudha 1 hour ago||||
Education alone will not fix our issues. There are highly educated, highly motivated, smart people who are utter arseholes in life.

Education is important, sure. But what is even more important is basic decency, kindness and willingness to live and let live. I don't need a PhD to feel empathy for a kid in Ukraine caught in the stupid war or for a woman living under the religious fanatics in Afghanistan etc.

There are videos on YouTube of seemingly normal people making fun of the Palestinian misery in Gaza, for example. These people aren't uneducated, no amount of education will make them care. They just don't give a shit.

ghusto 42 minutes ago|||
I was with you until the Gaza example. That one in particular is where education probably _would_ help. People would care, but they've been pushed into a corner ("you're a Nazi unless you believe what I believe" doesn't get great results).
cowlevel 33 minutes ago||
People are mocking the mass extermination of 6 million Muslims because they are Nazis, not because they've been told they are Nazis.

But people have been miseducated about the Nazis. They are made out to be a special kind of evil people that you can't accidentally be. In truth, most of the actual Nazis actually didn't know they were Nazis, they just thought Germany had a Jewish immigration problem that the government was dealing with, etc. because that's what the media (mostly newspapers) told them

myersj 42 minutes ago|||
Do you think Peter Thiel would be a better or worse human being with less education? Do you think the world would be better if more people had enough basic reading comprehension to understand what inflation is, or how science and vaccinations work, and that their mom's Facebook posts aren't "research"?

Or do you think OP was suggesting that education is the sole issue and that evil people would suddenly cease to exist if they went to college? Do you also argue that laws are dumb because criminals still do crime, or do you understand that sometimes there are just evil people and "nu-uh"ing a suggestion because you thought of one, single, counter-example is non-additive and childish?

ghusto 46 minutes ago|||
> Humans reacting emotionally instead of logically. Everything else is a symptom of that disease

As long as you believe that's a symptom of a disease and not the human condition, you're not forward facing. The triumph of critical thinking over emotions is only a thing in sci-fi.

This is why righteous nerds never win, they don't want to. Deep down they know what they're saying is impossible, but they'd rather be "right" than make a difference.

intended 2 hours ago|||
The only tool that can say has some direct effect on democracy is what Taiwan is doing with .. vTaiwan (i think?) and Pol.is.

NB: From what Wikipedia says, apparently OpenAI and Anthropic also had Pol.is on their radar since they apparently used it to build/study consensus.

tech_ken 1 hour ago||
Great point, and TBH it made me feel like I should have softened my language a bit. I don't think tools can have no impact, but there needs to be strong social scaffolding around them. IMO it wasn't excellent engineering that led vTaiwan to success, but rather a social movement that understood how to deploy it effectively. The tool can be crude if the political will is strong.
fishfasell 3 hours ago|||
Agreed, it's a human problem and nothing a computer can solve
swed420 1 hour ago||
Like the sibling comment by 'intended' explains, computers can help us:

> talk to people, build a coalition, wield power to make a (positive) material impact in peoples' lives

but allow such to scale in a useful manner, like vTaiwan / pol.is has shown is possible.

cowlevel 36 minutes ago|||
"You can't fix social problems with technological solutions"
verdverm 1 hour ago||
> Over the last decade I've been left so cold by these attempts to 'fix' democracy via cleverly engineered tools.

Same, the solution to most of our woes (govt inefficacy, social media, partisan politics, corruption) is to talk to each other again IRL. The many outweigh to money.

To this end I now make paper mini zines and give them to people, usually resulting in conversations with strangers.

fhdkweig 4 hours ago||
> How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?

> The Open Social Web Alliance aims to provide the answers.

The short answer is that it isn't as profitable as creating discord. People's fears and anger are monetizable. The internet of the 1990s is gone. People don't share information just out of altruistic kindness anymore. Now it is all about selling a product.

8organicbits 3 hours ago||
> People don't share information just out of altruistic kindness anymore

This is opposite the experience I have. I know there are places where people sell things, HN has always been one, so I spend more time socializing elsewhere. It's sort of like hanging out at the mall and complaining people keep trying to sell you things. The web is massive and there are tons of people seeking connection, being creative, and sharing kindness.

intended 2 hours ago|||
Fair point, however it is also a valid point that the old web as we knew it is dead/dying.

If we are on HN we are also the old guard at this point. We know of enough places and clubs that the loss isn’t as felt. Wikipedia is seeing a drop in traffic, and people are increasingly moving to Discord over forums and subreddits. Discord being outright inimical to search and finding historic information is a feature for users at this point.

Google AI summaries are busy hacking at the roots of the old web, reducing traffic to communities and intermediating the content they create.

I might be too early to call this out, but a contrary data point is audiences developing an intolerance for AI generated text.

bluebarbet 1 hour ago||
>Wikipedia is seeing a drop in traffic

Given the rise of AI chatbots, this is surely expected and unremarkable. Wikipedia's traffic was never an interesting metric anyway. What's important is that the information on Wikipedia is correct.

ArcHound 3 hours ago|||
Where would that be pray tell?
fl4regun 2 hours ago||
take your pick. Wikipedia for one?
ArcHound 9 minutes ago||
Yep, Wikipedia, webarchive and similar are awesome. I was more looking for that personal connection and creative sites, do you have any good ones?
samrus 3 hours ago|||
The downside of that is externalized to society. Modern social media is a classic example of companies externalizing the harm of their products and raking in huge profits. And then using that capital to fight tooth and nail against regulation that woul properly account for those externalities.

We need to have these companies pay for the downsides of their monetization practices and then itll be a competitive playing feild with these open standards

baggy_trough 1 hour ago||
How is this different from complaining about irresponsible book authors and sellers who don't account from the supposed harm of their product, if it consisted of wrongthink? What exact harm are you talking about that isn't just freedom of speech?
swed420 1 hour ago|||
> The short answer is that it isn't as profitable as creating discord.

> Now it is all about selling a product.

The point the OP seems to be making is that it doesn't have to be this way if we organize.

We're brainwashed into thinking that everything must turn a profit, but this simply isn't the case.

https://www.noemamag.com/the-last-days-of-social-media/

gjgtcbkj 3 hours ago|||
[dead]
howunfortunate 4 hours ago|||
> that strengthens democratic discourse

This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"

Yeah no thanks

We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

cogman10 4 hours ago|||
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"

I tend to agree. It's further a bit insane that "businesses" are getting a say in the governance at all.

> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

Yeah, the main thing we actually need is the elimination of bots and paid commenters. What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots. What makes twitter hell is the fact that it seems like 90% of the tweets come from bots.

querez 3 hours ago|||
> What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.

If that's even true (I agree there are no _obvious_ bots), I think this is mostly a function of HN being niche enough. Any social network that addresses a large enough part of society is a target for ads/manipulation. It just comes with the territory. IMO the right approach involves adding a cost to spam.

howunfortunate 3 hours ago||||
Agreed, it's very frustrating that X enables the feature to see what country something is posted from (which accounts for at least 80% of bots), but does not enable you to filter your feed or view engagement / likes based on this same feature.

Of course VPNs exist but this would instantly solve so much of the bot problem.

intended 2 hours ago||||
But HN is what it is because of moderation.

There’s 3 topics that are the horsemen of the apocalypse for online communities: Politics, Religion and meta commentary. Any community that allows these topics will have a higher moderation burden.

Conversely, communities for topics where posers find it hard to survive, have lower moderation burdens. Technical topics create higher barriers to entry, and end up with experience community members who can call out errors and referee discussions on merits and domain knowledge.

Required Community moderation level is primarily a function of barriers to entry.

On a separate note, I’ve found that putting this information out there, always riles someone or the other up. I have no idea why.

bilbo0s 3 hours ago|||
>What makes HN nice is it's mostly devoid of bots.

The greatest trick the devil ever pulled was convincing everyone he didn’t exist. Professional influence campaigns are so effective because no one targeted by those campaigns believes they’re being influenced.

idiotsecant 4 hours ago||||
X is a garbage fire now, not sure why that is desirable.
howunfortunate 4 hours ago|||
Humanity is a garbage fire, being exposed to the actual clash of ideas and cultures is much more desirable to me than a curated echo chamber of a narrow slice of permissable opinion (not coincidentally, also always the SAME slice on every other platform)
JumpCrisscross 3 hours ago|||
> being exposed to the actual clash of ideas

That’s not what X is. It’s a clash of ideas pushed by folks with bigger bot armies. The calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.

Like, what was the last original idea of consequence that developed on X through discourse? Compare that with blogs or pamphlets or newspapers.

jeremyjh 2 hours ago|||
That was debunked about a day after the story broke. The only thing that dropped was Yandex crawler activity.
JumpCrisscross 19 minutes ago||
Oh whoops, good source?
howunfortunate 3 hours ago|||
> calm down after Yandex’s datacenters were hit should give anyone arguing for the cacophony a pause.

This was fake / deceptive btw. There was no dip

TheOtherHobbes 2 hours ago||||
Happy to be exposed to a clash of culture and ideas.

Not happy being exposed to weaponised bot farms - note: not real people - cynically trying to engineer my beliefs by manipulating my emotions.

We've had more than a decade of experience of wannabe social engineers who claim to be for free speech, but are bitterly opposed in practice to truly organic political sentiment when it conflicts with their financial interests. (And their personal narcissism.)

intended 2 hours ago||||
Sorry, that isn’t a defense of X, or a defense of anything.

Nor is Humanity a garbage fire.

Humanity had many better tools to manage discourse, and better discourse in the past.

Twitter did a pretty good job of creating a meeting place. I’ve been on Reddit during its hey day and I’ve seen national movements that coordinated untold millions, to achieve narrow technical policy goals.

I’ve lived and breathed the idea that free speech is the best tool for ideas to win, until the difference between idealism and the actual behavior of users landed on my doorstep.

I strongly recommend people volunteer to moderate wherever they can. It is easy to hold an opinion when you have no skin in the game and things are theoretical.

It’s a constant shame that trust and safety teams rarely engage on HN.

jeremyjh 2 hours ago||||
There are no ideas or culture transmitted through X. Its algorithm just shows you shit posted by bots that enrages you.
fl4regun 2 hours ago||||
there is no clash of ideas and cultures on X, it's just rage bait, and people yelling at each other while having 0 intention of listening. X is just as much an ecochamber as any other social media.
kakacik 3 hours ago||||
Sure but anarchy will not bring some sort of paradise, just like completely unregulated markets bring inevitably oligarchies and oligopolies/monopolies and not some happy long term balanced kumbaya. And where do you set boundaries is up to everybody's emotions.

Letting corporations milk dry anything good remaining in society is also less than desirable. And we know they do it simply because profit, and they will walk much further well into criminal behavior simply because profit.

Kids shouldn't read alone Mein kampf for example or racist xenophobic antisemitic etc things. Don't you agree? And that's regulation too.

Spivak 3 hours ago|||
This seems laudable so long as you're never the subject or target of hate speech. Then you just kind of look in with a detached interest like it's a nature documentary.

But that falls apart if you are one of those and actually want to hang out there as part of a community. If you were sitting at a park with your friends while random strangers yell the most offensive thing they can think of at you or going to a bar while a klan meeting is the next table over you probably wouldn't be like, "it's so good that I'm part of a diverse marketplace of ideas."

So in the same way you curate your friend group to be people who don't talk about jews controlling the media or aren't painfully insufferable about the Avengers perpetuating patriarchal attitudes after going to see a movie it's nice to have social media where you can have that too.

antonvs 4 hours ago||||
There are only three kinds of people on X now:

1. Those who don't have enough of a moral sense to want to avoid it like the plague.

2. Those whose desire for money outweighs their moral sense - their desire for exposure to an audience makes X hard to resist. This includes corporations. The New York Times would have to give up nearly 60 million followers to leave X, for example.

3. Those whose values are aligned with the far right, up to and including MAGA, neo-Nazis, and the final boss of that mindset, Musk.

Arguably the first category includes the other two.

howunfortunate 4 hours ago|||
If your moral sense leads you to avoiding ideas you don't like, like the plague, I think you might work on refining that moral sense
antonvs 3 hours ago|||
It's not about avoiding ideas. It's about not lending support to a platform that exists as a vehicle to promote ideas whose catastrophic consequences have been demonstrated over and over through history.

Besides, the ideas in question are difficult to avoid. No-one is starving for the latest rationalization for those ideas - and you won't find any good ones on X, anyway. If you want the intellectual background, read a book on the history or philosophies in question.

g-b-r 3 hours ago|||
Yeah, civil debate of ideas is what happens on X
sejje 2 hours ago||
He didn't say anything like that, you've sarcastically responded to your own thoughts
g-b-r 30 minutes ago||
Sure
maxrev17 4 hours ago|||
Is it not of some value to know just how many people think like that? Opposing views being of interest and all that… apparently.
antonvs 3 hours ago||||
That doesn't require you to actually support the platform.
maxrev17 3 hours ago|||
Downvoted haha
jasonvorhe 3 hours ago|||
X is heavily moderated, just not how you'd like it.
jwibby 4 hours ago||||
[flagged]
tclancy 4 hours ago|||
I have to say to the downvoters I am an absolute bleeding heart leftist and I don’t know if I can disagree with this. I made an off-hand joke, pre-election, about a post wherein the user was horrified the Democrats would endorse Talarico. My gentle chiding was a variation on “no, not like that” when getting a Democrat of any kind elected in Texas should be a cause for celebration.

I got absolutely lambasted by that user as a DINO and by a couple of other accounts that smelled of bot farms.

That said, I fully support moderation of these tools. They theoretically exist to form communities. The fact grifters and trolls can ruin that is not freedom.

grumbel 2 hours ago|||
> I fully support moderation of these tools.

Moderation should be something you yourself opt-in on the client side. The server should have no say in it and deliver the data as raw as possible.

The whole problem with modern social media is that you can't, since there is no unfiltered way to access them, most don't even allow you to see a plain old timeline, all you get is algorithmic click bait. Having account requirements that make the content inaccessible to read via the public Web is another huge issue.

gjgtcbkj 3 hours ago||||
[dead]
pastel8739 3 hours ago|||
Did you get banned though? Sounds like no?
akuchling 4 hours ago||||
A recent 404 Media article suggested that at least Bluesky matched reality, while on X people were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.

https://www.404media.co/republicans-learn-x-is-an-echo-chamb...

howunfortunate 3 hours ago||
> were convinced that memes about a gender-flipped Draco Malfoy were the key to winning the youth vote.

Are you an actual X user? Because people from both sides were instantly clowning on this, it was far from a consensus and the most popular posts were being meta / ironic

The article is very much giving this meme: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/jessica-chastain-at-the-compu...

idiotsecant 4 hours ago|||
Wow that was a close one, you almost had to use it and make your own informed judgement!
howunfortunate 4 hours ago||
I don't think the jury is exactly hung up on whether BlueSky is a leftist space where right wing views are not welcome
fabrice_d 3 hours ago||
People that claim BlueSky is a leftist space would be shocked if they spend 10 minutes on Mastodon.
Gareth321 3 hours ago||||
I fully agree. "Strengthens democratic discourse" is no more than a euphemism for "we can political opinions with which we disagree."
swed420 1 hour ago||||
> This just screams "we want to censor the views that X stopped censoring"

> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

As if X isn't full of its own dark patterns.

JumpCrisscross 3 hours ago||||
> We need less censorship / "moderation", not more

Based on what? The self-styled free speechers took the reins of American social media and made a mess with it.

sejje 2 hours ago||
Do you mean you now see more stuff you don't like?

Why would we need more censorship? Let them say anything they want.

JumpCrisscross 19 minutes ago||
> Do you mean you now see more stuff you don't like?

I mean we’ve seen a global program of attempted (and failed) political mounted by these folks, using their social media power, that has cost lives and liberties.

> Let them say anything they want

I still believe in this. I don’t in them privately and selectively amplifying.

messia 4 hours ago|||
[flagged]
avaer 4 hours ago||
Hm, when IRL social fabric is overtaken by fighting we call that a failed state. I guess on the internet we call that successful tech economy? Why is that?
adverbly 4 hours ago||
I'm desperately waiting for a platform which doesn't have bots, has rate limited participation, and has algorithms which aren't built to maximize retention.

In the meantime, it's mostly group chats, and me having to assume everyone else is either a bot or selling something (no worse than traditional media, but no better either)

I care less about the hosting provider, and more about trust and the impact on users.

bloopernova 3 hours ago||
You absolutely can do all those things with ATProto. It's all open, and different "feeds" can be switched whenever you want. (A feed being the closest thing ATProto or Bluesky has to an algorithm)
bryanhogan 2 hours ago||
But platforms like Bluesky, especially the default experience for the majority of people, still follows in Twitter's footsteps and are built to maximize retention.

And it's also full of bots. I posted one thing yesterday, and I got one human reply and 4 bot replies.

jeremyjh 2 hours ago||
Bluesky doesn't have an algorithmic feed anything like X's. Its more like Twitter was 15 years ago.
bryanhogan 2 hours ago||
Actually, yes that's true. That is an important difference.

I think I've gotten too used to having "custom" feeds like "For You" in my Bluesky.

ktosobcy 17 minutes ago||
I don't use bluesky that much anymore but AFAIR it has a lot of flexibility and you can have your main page with only "following" feed and nothing else...
carlosjobim 39 minutes ago|||
The platform is WhatsApp groups and real life groups. Which are already thriving.
omnimus 21 minutes ago||
Recommending app from the biggest social media company is pretty sad to be honest. Can't we at least try to do better?
numpad0 3 hours ago|||
What you're looking for is a high-bandwidth platform. Spammers can't interfere with the platform if there are too much context in there to understand.

Twitter used to be that. Still is to some extent, but not as resistant as before.

micromacrofoot 2 hours ago||
forums have been here all along
0-_-0 4 hours ago||
Users will not move en masse to a social media platform that's not addictive. The addiction is why they are there.
Zak 4 hours ago||
I think it's important to draw a distinction between social media that's for entertainment based mainly on content made by strangers, and social networking for sharing with friends and family.

Much of that activity has moved to group chats, but those aren't a good replacement for the experience Facebook used to provide.

jcfrei 4 hours ago||
All valid points. But then I also feel like very few people actually want to get a Facebook experience back. Most of my peers have stopped using FB apart from the bi-monthly check-in. It just doesn't fit the social experience we desire for most of us - and it was just popular because it was among the first social networks. I think FB occupies a very unnatural spot which is that you are friends with everyone from high school, university, and other things but at the same time you hardly ever wanna share stuff with all of them. Group chats to me at least seem like a much more natural way how we organize our relationships.
Zak 4 hours ago||
My experience was that first, Facebook transitioned from mostly being original content from people I know to mostly third-party content, then people stopped posting original content.

That has the same shape as spam. People don't want to participate when what they're sharing gets drowned out in a sea of noise. Of course the old experience required maybe 10 minutes a day to see everything, which is not a recipe for a profitable advertising business.

swed420 1 hour ago|||
> The addiction is why they are there.

The profit-centric platforms are engineered to be addictive, but it need not be profit-centric if we organize, which is the point of the OP.

https://www.noemamag.com/the-last-days-of-social-media/

tclancy 4 hours ago|||
That’s a logical fallacy though. Based on what we have seen in the last decade or so, that’s been the case but it wasn’t always and there are plenty of smaller platforms. En masse doesn’t need to be the only answer.
adverbly 4 hours ago|||
But a user who has quit existing social media might still find something there...
add-sub-mul-div 4 hours ago||
You can think of that as a feature, not a limitation. The eternal September has been captured by Reddit, Twitter, Meta, etc. They won't invade the next generation of social networks. So those newer options won't turn into the garbage that the discerning have fled.
imoverclocked 2 hours ago||
I think digital social networks should be somewhat disparate. IRL social networks are already self-islanding by their nature of formation via shared interest. Cross-pollination happens when individuals are part of multiple networks.

Let’s take two different social networks today: Strava and Threads. They serve wildly different purposes and have no need to talk with each other. By virtue of hyperlinks, one can enable cross-posting between networks if that is somehow desirable.

The only way a shared protocol makes sense is if the purpose of the network is either very general (looking at you, e-mail) or the semantics involved are very homogeneous.

This proposal wants federation but also doesn’t say how existing federation technologies fail much less how their own will work.

E-mail will be hard to unseat and social networks are still a dime a dozen with wildly different expectations for messages passed between them.

swed420 1 hour ago|
> This proposal wants federation but also doesn’t say how existing federation technologies fail much less how their own will work.

That part is TBD, but others have elaborated on the problems and solutions:

https://www.noemamag.com/the-last-days-of-social-media/

notatoad 3 hours ago||
>More than 100 million people connect

i really believe that this is a bad goal. 100 million people don't need to connect, and any system that tries to enable this will end up having all the same problems as facebook does. open-source or not.

the best online social spaces are small, focused, and have barriers. build a healthier world by connecting tens of people, not millions.

barbazoo 3 hours ago|
Right. Imagine interacting online with people from your actual current physical community. I bet we wouldn't nearly see as much "antisocial" behavior. Why do we think the goal should be to connect everyone with everyone. The only people that need to reach us all are advertisers or other people that so desperately need to make money off us.
cousinbryce 3 hours ago||
Does anyone have examples of this? Asking for a friend
blinding-streak 3 hours ago||
When I see "Open Social", I think of the unsuccessful alliance of companies that tried to break the Facebook social juggernaut back in the late 2000s. Various open APIs to encourage online discourse and sharing across various vendors. Sort of lost to time, I'm surprised I even remembered.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenSocial

zergrush 3 hours ago||
Even as a lot of people stormed off X for bluesky they came back because they realized they were shouting in a void echo chamber and this is the problem with all these social networks, they don't have the network part and without network attention suddenly becomes very scarce

It's a cute attempt at fixing some of the things with social networks but they almost always something that people don't want fixed at all. For someone who has very little followers on X and leaving replies or engaging in the comment section of Youtube or HN are probably living in a completely different reality for those of us who have gone viral or have experienced an insane amount of engagement. There's almost no reason to try anything other than what the big mainstream networks offer.

Same for when someone tries to start an HN alternative, people simply flock to it for a while and then it trickles down. Or reddit alternative. Digg is a great example where people get interested for a while and then they are back on reddit.

1shooner 3 hours ago||
I think it requires a re-conception of the mechanics of a social network. The goals described in the article don't sound like they would replace the incumbent addiction-driven platforms. I think you're right, the addicts don't want that fixed, and will stay on those platforms.

The topology of addiction- and influencer-based social networks is bizarre, and I think there is plenty of room for alternatives. There are potential users that value quality over quantity; they want, and would probably prefer, far less of a network effect.

zergrush 3 hours ago||
It's pretty condescending to label anyone using social networks as addicts, the ones that know how to work them for extracting maximum attention are often using it seldomly and in an automated fashion.

The ones that are addicted are guys in the reply section, youtube, HN, reddit racking up an insane amount of posts and interactions that ultimately can't be momentized or lead to any sort of economic uplift.

1shooner 3 hours ago||
>The ones that are addicted are guys in the reply section, youtube, HN, reddit racking up an insane amount of posts and interactions that ultimately can't be momentized or lead to any sort of economic uplift.

Reducing social interaction to its profitability is definitely a different approach than the article is proposing.

zergrush 3 hours ago||
More like digital social interactions can't replace human offline ones, profitable or not, it's unhealthy.
1shooner 3 hours ago|||
I agree, but there's a lot of middle ground. My best experiences with digital social interaction have been in much smaller, more focused communities than today's social media platforms. What stands out to me about those was the accountability: many of the members were not anonymous, but even those that were still managed their reputation and credibility.

I don't see this OSWA ensuring that kind of scenario (more centralized moderation probably won't encourage that soft self-moderation), but there are better patterns that can be recreated.

swed420 1 hour ago|||
Wrong. vTaiwan / pol.is are real successes and have barely scratched the surface with what is possible.
barbazoo 3 hours ago|||
> It's a cute attempt at fixing some of the things with social networks but they almost always something that people don't want fixed at all

This reads to me a little bit like saying the person addicted to a drug doesn't want to get off the drug so why even try. These are people that are extrapolating into the future and being worried about what they see. This is an attempt to, as a community, steer us into a more resilient but still enjoyable behavior I would imagine. How can we support them because the alternative could lead to a decline in overall species health and we'd regret having gone down that road too far.

zergrush 3 hours ago||
The lower you are on the socio economic ladder, the more likely you are to be perma-online, social network or not, although I guess you can call HN one (I can see that some people are very addicted through the pseudo anonymous text centric format), posting incessantly on forums for nearly two decades, racking up an insane amount of posts, building an online identity that ultimately doesn't result in any sort of audience or economic transformation.

You have confused being online permanently solely as the fault of social networks but the perma-online crowd has existed even before the arrival of mass social networks like Facebook. They've hung out in IRC chats, php forums, mailing lists.

alex1138 3 hours ago|||
I don't know that this is proof of anything

bsky is a protocol, so the protocol ought to work for both the left and the right. Some people are annoyed with how broken on a technical level x has gotten

Network effects really do matter which is the problem with "Facebook sucks. But Facebook popular, therefore Facebook good". Because nobody wants to move off the bad product because you lose access to everyone else on the bad product

The internet's still relatively young. It takes time to move, and establish

jeremyjh 2 hours ago||
Yes, good. Fuck those people.
alexfromapex 3 hours ago|
We need decentralized social media. We saw governments taking down speech and blocking people from organizing during COVID and that is what prevents democracy.
spankalee 3 hours ago||
We have decentralized social media in AT Proto and ActivityPub.
frenchy 2 hours ago|||
A bit of a nitpick, but I think it's important. AT Proto and ActivityPub are protocols that could enable decentralized social media. Whether or not we actually have decentralized social media is more of a complicated question and depends on the degree to which people are actually doing social media in different places and the amount of control those places have over each other.

I do think we do have some amount of decentralized social media, but if everyone moved to the bsky.app tomorrow, I would say there was no real decentralized social media despite the fact that it's a service based on AT Proto.

littlecranky67 2 hours ago|||
And nostr.
alex1138 2 hours ago||
nostr is honestly a lot of fun. The main relays have had some spam problems but you meet a lot of interesting people (and projects they work on)
littlecranky67 2 hours ago||
Spliting hairs as you probably already know this: Don't conflate the Nostr protocol and the apps that build on it.

Yes there is a twitter-like Nostr. But there are plenty of other apps that just built on the relativeley simple nostr protocol (it is just JSON over websockets with some conventions and crypto - basic server is probably done in less than 500 lines of code). The heavy lifting is in the clients. I do not use it for twitter-like social media, but only for messaging via white noise (a MLS based messenger, [0]) and in some hobby projects where I use trystero [1] where is piggy-backs on nostr relays so I do not have to have an event broker in my deployment.

But yes, the protocol and its possibilities are plenty of fun :)

[0]: https://www.whitenoise.chat/ [1]: https://trystero.dev/

More comments...