Top
Best
New

Posted by doener 5 hours ago

Open Social Web Alliance(osw-alliance.net)
172 points | 180 commentspage 2
grey-area 2 hours ago|
How do we build social media that strengthens democratic discourse and is both resilient and appealing?

We get rid of the adverts.

It's that simple. Advertising has perverted every platform it is introduced on (search, twitter, instagram, even email with gmail). So how do you fund such a platform without ads? Perhaps we need governments to step in with funding for a social good, as they do for roads etc.

Communication networks should not be solely in the hands of private companies and moulded for their benefit, encouraging 'engaging content' to sit between their ads, content that is by design indistinguishable from ads.

egypturnash 1 hour ago|
Social media should be publicly funded the same way the post office and libraries should be publicly funded.
amelius 4 hours ago||
We should start by taking away the advertising based monetization model.
jeremyjh 2 hours ago||
For someone reason people simply don't want to pay anything for less en-shittified online experiences. It is really bizarre.
Quarrelsome 4 hours ago|||
yeah, that entirely defines the emotive based framing of clickbait because it wins when in competition with any other content.
cousinbryce 3 hours ago||
Enshitification is downstream of capitalism
matthewsinclair 3 hours ago||
I think the first thing we need to do is stop calling it “social media” (which it clearly isn’t) and start calling it “algorithmic media” (which it clearly is).
janpmz 2 hours ago||
As I understand it, they offer a protocol and a "secretariat/office" for interventions. I.e the central office can overwrite the protocol:

They propose a publicly funded central Secretariat deciding on "interventions" (Section 2.2.2, p. 24–25 & 2.2.3, p. 27).

The Secretariat connects with state authorities and broadcasting councils.

One its duties is "to discuss new and critical cases and decide on interventions at the infrastructure or application level."

It also calls for mandatory reporting systems (of things people find offensive?).

wppick 3 hours ago||
We had something like this for a brief moment in time with xmpp. Most social platforms were using it and you could connect them all together in one place with your own client. But slowly companies started moving away from it in favor of their own protocols
theturtletalks 3 hours ago||
I had a similar idea. Basically a Shopify for personal websites where you can post your blog, micro-blog, videos, pictures, etc. It will also connect to the places your community lives like X, Youtube, Instagram, etc so you can post one and syndicate elsewhere.

Then you can allow your friends to make accounts on your website and then they can get access to certain posts and pictures. Your friends can also subscribe to your newsletter to keep up with you without doomscrolling.

Making your algorithmic feed would be easy since you just choose the people you want and it shows their posts. People could also curate their own feeds and charge a fee for users to see their feed if their curating skills are elite.

ModernTimes 4 hours ago||
To solve this problem you need to acknowledge that the problem comes from both the right (the horrible underbelly of X) and the left (the suffocating dead-hand of Reddit and BlueSky).

Most attempts to solve this focus on only one of the above.

LastTrain 4 hours ago||
I don’t disagree, but each are very different problems with different solutions. I think it’s important to make that distinction otherwise both sides bristle at being likened to the other.
numpad0 3 hours ago|||
I think neither of Twitter nor Bluesky is particularly left or right leaning, it's just unpopular corners of them that have not much else to talk about.

If anything, Twitter was always left leaning. The microblog architecture requires you to be visibly proficient, interesting, and cognizant of reputation to be able to gain ANY attention whatsoever, and that is not easily achievable while holding right wing biases. Microblog is just structurally very discriminatory against skill issues.

gdulli 2 hours ago||
Excuse me? A guy named catturd with absolutely nothing of substance to offer has 4 million followers.
numpad0 44 minutes ago||
I had never come across such a user.
Quarrelsome 4 hours ago||
Hah, on reddit "the left" i frequently see people discussing remigration: aka ethnic cleansing with nary a ban in sight.
shooly 3 hours ago||
"freedom of speech is only good when it reinforces my biases!"

that's certainly an interesting comment to make under a post about "strengthening democratic discourse"

Quarrelsome 3 hours ago||
Eh? I'm simply wondering why reddit is being categorised as being "left" when i frequently see extreme right wing view points expressed on there like "remigration".
86798765654 2 hours ago||
[dead]
lez 4 hours ago||
Nice initiative! We badly want open social web!

And the policy paper nails the important motives, although I miss some notes about why Nostr is not perfectly aligned with these values already.

Another critique: "We have identified five key challenges: infrastructure, governance, funding, attractiveness and public mandate." - I wonder why network effect has not brought up.

Of course these are not very important questions, if a lot of money is already available as funding to keep the devs busy for the next 3 years.

maxrev17 4 hours ago|
Social media is the attention market. You only get that with stuff which either rallies or pisses people off.

Seems a broken idea. No idea if it can be solved so simply. Or if the solution is dedicated forums as of the past. Shared interest away from degenerative musings on things people will not properly engage nor meaningfully attempt to solve.

More comments...